The reality is that web 3D's time seems to have arrived. It doesn't matter if it's through WebGL, Flash, Unity the issue you raised is present in all those solutions. Even Native client has that potential if the sandbox is not watertight.
In all, if we want a more capable web these are risk I feel are worth taking. But that's my personal view.
IMO, GL_ARB_robustness is almost completely worthless. The one thing it gives you is the ability to time out rendering, in effect, which of course prevents certain types of DoS attacks. There are many other provisions in the extension, but those are already universally implemented in ANGLE and the like; they don't do anything to help with the security of the lower level.
> The reality is that web 3D's time seems to have arrived. It doesn't matter if it's through WebGL, Flash, Unity the issue you raised is present in all those solutions. Even Native client has that potential if the sandbox is not watertight.
NaCl has the same issues regardless of the sandbox, but I agree entirely: hardware accelerated 3d on the web is worth the risk we'll be dealing with for the first couple of years. I've stopped writing desktop 3d software/demos entirely in favor of WebGL simply because I believe so much in it, but it's not stopping me from doing security research into it as well.
At the end of the day, I'm convinced that a reasonably skilled attacker could do terrible, terrible things to my system via WebGL. But the benefits outweigh the risks for me.
I think that proper protections should be put in from the hardware on up through the drivers, but it's going to take a lot of work and a lot of research to get it right.
What it comes down to is that current GPUs do whatever you want with no concern for security; that part depends on the driver and userspace 3d stack. This isn't necessarily bad, but GPU manufacturers can't write code. Bounds checking and all that are pretty well covered by things like ANGLE (translates OGL to D3D on windows and acts as a sanity checker and shader validator everywhere else) but that doesn't help you if, say, your driver improperly compiles valid-but-malicious code. Avenues like that are effectively not researched at all.