News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by davidw on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @09:21AM (#333245)
Another thing for you to keep in mind: the same group handed out prizes at some point to Hayek and Friedman.
Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @09:28AM (#333253)
I've been reading around some. As I was the first to admit, I am ignorant. FWIW, glowing reviews are running about 70-30 with critical reviews of their award. There's a nice glowing review over at Forbes (http://www.forbes.com/opinions/2008/10/13/krugman-economics-...)

Even then, the author ends with:

"But these days, even while disavowing overtly protectionist positions, Krugman's columns do sometimes have a protectionist tenor. Not only purists, but developing country policymakers, worry that Krugman is part of the shifting intellectual climate in the United States that has become ambivalent about keeping markets for goods and services open. Now that he also has the imprimatur of the Nobel Committee, Paul Krugman has a special responsibility to retain his cosmopolitan and internationalist credentials. At this time of financial crisis, Krugman should be reminding us that shutting down markets for trade helped transform the depression of the 1930s into the Great Depression."

I'm open to discourse, just not impressed with the downmodding as a result of going against the herd over here. I've found economics a subject of some interest, but even with as much math as it takes, my _opinion_ is that it is far from a hard science like physics. So pointing out that politics and people's biases are involved shouldn't be such a freaking big deal, in my opinion. And that goes with Hayek, Friedman, and Krugman. My comment holds for all of them. That's the weird part about it.

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by davidw on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @10:03AM (#333287)
> I'm open to discourse, just not impressed with the downmodding as a result of going against the herd over here.

That sort of thing pretty much invariably happens with economics or politics on sites like this, whatever persuasion the 'herd' happens to be.

Which is why I think discussion of said topics should be ruthlessly hunted down and driven away.

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by olefoo on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @11:34AM (#333385)
And it's good to keep in mind that a downmod can mean anything from "I disagree with this." to "This whole line of discussion pro or con is stupid.".
Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @11:45AM (#333394)
Can I point out again how stupid single-arrow voting is?
Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @11:49AM (#333397)
Can I remind you that from where I sit, the title of the original post translated into something like "Famous left-leaning columnist awarded prize by committee slammed as being too political lately"?

So I was hunting the articles down and driving them away. The problem is that it didn't look like that for the majority.

If you don't want to see dissent and downmod it, then how can minority opinions ever sway the majority that they are wrong? Sure, in this case I'm probably smoking crack, but there's something really bad here.

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by olefoo on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @12:35PM (#333436)
I've seen your handle in far too many threads lately, and for the most part I just scroll past; because life is too short. In this particular case I chose to comment because economics is an interest of mine as an entrepreneur. You do not appear to be contributing to the conversation about ideas, you seem to be mostly emoting and acting as though anything that does not conform to your rather straitened ideological views is a personal attack on your ego. And you've been doing this all day every day.

In this particular case it's clear that you did not RTFA since it's about Krugman's workflow, and says relatively little about the substance of his work and almost nothing about his politics other than that he regularly attempts to think and write about topical policy debates.

It looks rather as though you read the the name Krugman and reacted unthinkingly with an attack. That is not dissent, that is noise. If you want to make noise may I suggest that the politics reddit is the right place for you and that Hacker News is for people who want to focus on the ideas rather than the emotions.

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by DanielBMarkham on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @12:50PM (#333448)
Do you want a reply to this? I'm confused. If I'm trolling (which I'm trying not to) then why comment in this manner? As a way of appealing to other readers? I thought the thread system was set up in order to reply to individual comments. Seems more like a rebuke.

Nicely done -- especially liked the part about emoting. The neat thing is that it makes it impossible to reply in any fashion whatsoever. Which of course was the point.

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by olefoo on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @01:20PM (#333482)
I'm willing to grant you the benefit of the doubt when you say that you are not intentionally trolling, but I respectfully submit that that is what you come across as.

Starting highly charged political threads on topics that are only tangentially related to the linked article does not contribute value to the discussion.

I've noticed for myself that one of the signs that I am spending too much time in front of a computer is that I get into emotional arguments on internet message boards or IRC. It's easy to forget that a level of emotional involvement that would be normal and healthy IRL can make you seem like a raving lunatic online.

Take that as you will. I am through with this thread.

PLONK

Re:Paul Krugman: How I work by davidw on Wednesday October 15, 2008 @12:08PM (#333411)
To me it looked like you were more irritated with his political orientation rather than the fact that the article was here at all. I don't want to see Krugman, or mises.org or Cato or Denis Kucinich or Nader or Brad DeLong, Tyler Cowen, or any of them here, even though I happen to enjoy reading some of the above some of the time (I'm not saying who), and in the right forum (over a bottle of good wine) would enjoy discussing them a great deal.