News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by colechristensen on Saturday October 22, 2022 @09:45AM (#33298255)
Approximately zero innovation is needed to provide sanitation, clean water, or food production in the poorest areas of the world. They are not that way for lack of some rich country developing a new widget or publishing a paper.

Global poverty like that is the result of lack of resources and poor society/government organization.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by mangecoeur on Saturday October 22, 2022 @09:49AM (#33298290)
That’s exactly the whole point of this work: that too much effort is spent developing new widgets instead of figuring out why governance or society is not delivering peoples needs and what to do about it. This needs interdisciplinary approaches that are not tech focused.
Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by tomrod on Saturday October 22, 2022 @09:53AM (#33298317)
Sanitation: shovels, pipes, and pumps

Clean water access: shovels, pipes, pumps, treatment processes

Food: roads, shovels, pipes, pumps, transportation

No interdisciplinary approaches needed. Resources, rule of law (so builders don't abscond with funds), a tidbit of path planning, and Bob's your Uncle. Lower the costs and mitigate the risks.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by jerojero on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:17AM (#33298501)
If it was as simple as you're painting it then it wouldn't be a problem. The fact that it is a problem should indicate to you that there are factors you might not be considering.

For example, the logistics to provide plumbing to developing nations are extremely difficult because of the instability of these regions as well as the lack of cooperation from developed nations to precisely help in these much needed regards. A lot of the help these places get come in the form of philanthropic pursuit or misguided help that end up either not helping or sometimes worsening the situation.

Not only that, but there are many interests at play that also get in the way of these places developing. For many powerful actors in these countries the status quo is good enough and any form of development actually threatens their position. And yes, sadly, this applies to plumbing as well!

It's very true that we know how to do plumbing, in the technical sense, but in reality we don't know how to do plumbing in these regions because our technical knowledge is not applicable given the socio-political situation. So this does require an interdisciplinary approach, one that involves sociology, psychology, economics, politics, etc.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by tomrod on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:36AM (#33298655)
You covered exactly what I said, with more words, until making the claim that an interdisciplinary approach is required. "Interdisciplinary approach" means we need to research the problem space. The research is already done. The solutions are ready and exist. Its the implementation that people get squeamish on for fear of offending portions of the coalition in power. Their squeamishness doesn't justify delaying action, which is what your approach advocates by casting solutioneering as requiring additional raw research versus applying what is known.

Pipes, shovels, and pumps solve a lot of core problems for a community. Where and how they get laid down doesn't require sociology or political economy research. You might care about the people displaced by the infrastructure, which a compassionate person will, but don't forget that home construction and legal recompense for eminent domain are also known.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by tbrownaw on Saturday October 22, 2022 @01:44PM (#33300376)
> Its the implementation that people get squeamish on for fear of offending portions of the coalition in power. Their squeamishness doesn't justify delaying action,

And that action that's totally appropriate but people are just too squeamish for would be ... what, an armed invasion to impose "better" cultural values?

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by tomrod on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:42PM (#33300905)
Sure, in certain cases where the people ubiquitously want pipes, shovels, and pumps, but the power structures in place prevent it and the invader or external trader brings it without wanting to rule. I'll leave that for the dithering interdiscipinarists to dicker about as a hypothetical.

However, more steelmaned and aligned to my original statement, as well as more common when facing decisions, being okay with the realistic tradeoffs that an endangered plant might have a reduction in habitat.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by MonkeyMalarky on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:28AM (#33298577)
Fascinating that political sociology invalidates known plumbing technology.
Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by mistermann on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:57AM (#33298816)
Sir: surely you're not suggesting that we (humanity) may not be interested in metaphysics (the fundamental nature of reality (both physically materialized as well as counterfactual), the first principles of being, identity and change, space and time, causality, necessity, consciousness, possibility, etc), but that metaphysics may be interested in us?

Because if you are, I have some unfortunate news: metaphysics is woo woo. And if you do not believe me, try doing a survey and see what results you get. Or, if you do not trust the opinion of the general public, try also running surveys within scientific and Rationalist communities, or even here on HN, and see if your results are substantially different.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by mistermann on Saturday October 22, 2022 @02:13PM (#33300610)
That this is attracting downvotes is not surprising, but it is very interesting.

One of the many things I find interesting about metaphysics, and humans (but I repeat myself) is that "most" humans, particularly those who are more educated, tend to be certain that metaphysics is dumb/useless/etc, yet the fact that they are unable to articulate the reason why this is true (and defend the articulation in a sound manner) seems to have little to no effect on their opinion of the quality of their belief. But unfortunately, this idea itself is metaphysical, so it can be easily dismissed by the initial belief. It's like a bootstrap problem of sorts.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by tomrod on Saturday October 22, 2022 @06:53PM (#33302953)
> That this is attracting downvotes is not surprising

Your parent comment and subsequent followup are difficult for me to parse. If others had similar difficulty, it could account for the downvotes. I did not downvote your comments.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by mistermann on Sunday October 23, 2022 @02:46PM (#33309156)
It was a little sarcastic, to be fair.

Genuinely curious: what's difficult to parse?

I think part of the problem is how inconsistently the domain of Metaphysics is perceived by many in general, and then there's also the fact that New Agers have to some degree hijacked it and caused an association between the word and "woo woo" to form in people's minds, so when they hear the word, they believe it IS "woo woo". This is the phenomenon at which my "childish" sarcasm is aimed (what's good for the goose is good for the gander is my excuse).

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by runnig on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:00AM (#33298374)
Shovels, pipes and pumps are the common denominator in these
Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by colechristensen on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:05AM (#33298411)
Ivory tower musing about why poor countries are corrupt and disorganized is not the key missing activity blocking them from prosperity.

The countries which are not poor and disorganized did not get there through the benevolent study by their betters.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by jotm on Saturday October 22, 2022 @10:05AM (#33298407)
No, we know why: the people. The governments, the culture/desires.

And I don't mean only Africa or Asia, (before someone calls me racist). Any country has had this problem.

The simplest solution is to instate mandatory community service, preferably in lieu of military service, but it could be a sort of "Subotnik" as seen in the USSR, which would be used for... You guessed it, doing community/public service work. Then you have all the manpower and just need food (some compensation/thanks is good) tools and organization/training (can double as job training).

Not much to ask imo, but of course many people will cry about it. Mostly people from countries with a lot of homeless and unpaid internships, but it's not like most people want to do unpaid work much, either. On the bright side, most people won't raise much of a fuss about it, either.

So that's not happening. Government officials stealing foreign aid is happening. Local production is not happening. Wars are happening. Toilets are not. Etc.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by concordDance on Saturday October 22, 2022 @12:45PM (#33299878)
How exactly does time limited slavery help with the culture?

What stops this labour being used in corrupt or self serving fashions just as the money is?

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by inglor_cz on Saturday October 22, 2022 @05:07PM (#33302240)
This is an interesting question.

The ancient Incan Empire collected taxes in labor (basically part-time slavery, everyone had to do their 2 months a year or so), and they managed to build enormous infrastructure across the Andes in just a few decades. And in high quality. Many of the roads can still be seen, 500 years after they were built.

How did they prevent capture of this labor by corrupt local officials? I don't know.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by jotm on Sunday October 23, 2022 @04:49AM (#33305533)
Slavery, fucking L. There are villages without proper taxation or any public services. Paying in labour works as an alternative.

What stops anyone from using a kitchen knife to stab someone to death?

If you look at it that way, you'll get nothing done.

Re:Science, technology and innovation isn’t addressing world... by concordDance on Saturday October 22, 2022 @12:38PM (#33299812)
Unfortunately reforming governments and cultures isn't something we know much about.

Too hard to do experiments.

Innovating cheaper infrastructure is at least somewhat actionable.