I really _really_ want to love Clojure but the first three points (unfortunately along with the Lisp syntax simply because it’s different enough) alienate too many people from the language and it seems like that’s something that Clojure has at best accepted as not the target audience and at worst is still unwilling to acknowledge.
Its quite frustrating actually. The people who are likely to be greatest advocates of the language (its a new-age Lisp!) are likely to be vocal about its failings, and are also hit with worst reactions like being told their issues are not issues.
If you are already part of the team, Clojure folks are very friendly. I want to avoid saying cult, but sometimes it has characteristics of one.
Failing to write a native runtime from scratch and unearth one of the founding bedrocks of the language doesn’t mean Clojure is hostile to input or trying to alienate anyone, it’s just a massive project that no one is currently interested in (for good reason IMO).
2) Thats true, but its not leaky abstraction. Clojure never claims to abstract the host away, it embraces it so you can do all low level Java/JS stuff and seemlessly use their libraries without FFIs.
3) You have all Java/JS libs. Most Clojure libs are simply "done", so they get no commits. I don't know of any unmaintend ones.
4) Java is improving? Clojure is mostly done with that already. It was designed long after Java and makes many improvements obsolete.