News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by mellavora on Friday October 21, 2022 @09:53AM (#33288006)
Sweden prior to 1990. Norway prior to 2010. Lived in both, know what I'm talking about.

Germany today and in the 1800s. You know why we have delivery services (Amazon etc, prior to that catalog companies like Sears etc)? It started as mail order, which started in Germany. Because the society had enough trust that you could mail money to a stranger and expect them to send you the product.

Also, the German post was a marvel of civic engineering. Government run projects at its best.

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by luckylion on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:36AM (#33289136)
I'm in Germany and that time is long gone, I'd say that was pre-1990 or 1995. The trust is no longer there, and the German Post is a joke that is currently falling apart and hasn't worked in 10 days in many regions.
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by lioeters on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:12PM (#33289628)
What would you say is the cause of this loss of trust and the degradation of German Post's quality of service? Surely it's not because German society is more multicultural.
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by wahern on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:24PM (#33293197)
But can you send money through the system without expecting it to be stolen? In most postal systems around the world today, just the idea of sending money through the post sounds inherently naive.

This is how high trust societies break down: cynicism. By objective standards things are no less than they were at the height of trust, but people's expectations have shifted and so subjectively people feel things are worse and begin withholding their trust.

This is why wealth inequality can create such a dilemma, because even if everybody continues to become better off, if you feel relatively worse off, than from a social cohesion standpoint it's just as bad. As overall wealth increases, because of the power law (or whatever curve), you see an acceleration of absolute differences in wealth as the high end of the curve grows steeper. This dynamic makes for a quite difficult sociological problem, which perhaps can be categorized under the rubric, "mo' money, mo' problems".

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by luckylion on Saturday October 22, 2022 @04:01AM (#33296398)
I wouldn't send money through the Post, and the idea sounds naive to me as well.

I don't believe that nothing has changed, but it's hard to point to individual events that prove how they've changed, because they're small things that lead to changes, which lead to more changes. It's still very different between the cities and the more rural suburbs and fully rural villages, and you can see it very clearly when you watch for the small things, e.g. can you leave your bike outside a small store without locking it up. It is what it is, it's not coming back once it's lost.

Today, crime that abuses the remains of Trust is rampant. Old people are tricked out of money by abusing their trust in authorities and their general trust that when somebody calls and says their daughter had an accident, that their daughter had an accident, because nobody would do such a cruel thing. And yet they do, happily laughing about it on TikTok, killing trust.

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by slavik81 on Friday October 21, 2022 @12:05PM (#33289544)
Germany was a bunch of seperate states until 1871 when Prussia finished conquering its neighbours. I don't understand how that could be a high-trust monocultural society in the 1800s.
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @01:14PM (#33290519)
> I don't understand how that could be a high-trust monocultural society in the 1800s.

It makes sense if you squint hard, and understand that "culture" in such arguments, is being used as a proxy of something else that is no longer acceptable to say out loud in polite company. So it was a bunch of disparate states with different traditions, but the same European "culture" (wink, wink, nudge, nudge).

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by TimedToasts on Friday October 21, 2022 @02:07PM (#33291140)
This is an extremely bad faith take. The person you are replying to said nothing of the sort and now you're implying that they're a bad person.

But not saying it out loud, of course. Just "the implications"...

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @07:21PM (#33293992)
I'd love to hear your good faith answer to gp's question on fractured polities that are now present-day Germany

>> I don't understand how that could be a high-trust monocultural society in the 1800s.

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by llanowarelves on Friday October 21, 2022 @04:49PM (#33292883)
Bad faith.

And it goes the other way, if you want to play that game.

If what you were saying were true then "whiteness" couldn't possibly refer to things such as purely abstract cultural-norms (either don't exist or is weasel-word according to you). So then what are they referring to?

Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by sangnoir on Friday October 21, 2022 @06:56PM (#33293858)
If my intepretation is in bad faith, I'm assuming you can answer GPs question then: how were the many pre-unification bavarian princedoms whose independent histories went back 100s of years monocultural?
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by watwut on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:02PM (#33293008)
I know about pretty significant low trust high paranoia and violence period in German history. Or even more of them.
Re:We Become What We Behold by Nicky Case by llanowarelves on Friday October 21, 2022 @05:32PM (#33293268)
To see Germany's squandered potential all we need to look to is Japan (clean, safe, high-trust country with almost no homeless).

They hawked a lot of stuff from Germany from that time period; Lots of loanwords, uniforms, civic systems copied. Germany really did lead the way. As did Anglos with the law.