Re:The Canon Cat and the Mac That Steve Jobs Killed
by ChrisMarshallNY on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:07AM
(#33288137)
I don't understand the hostility. I simply told a story about one of the many "bad judgment" stories that I have encountered, and the lessons learned, therein.
I wasn't asking for judgment.
Re:The Canon Cat and the Mac That Steve Jobs Killed
by zasdffaa on Friday October 21, 2022 @10:51AM
(#33288592)
Was intended as blunt, not hostile (how does it come across hostile?).
WRT 'giving the users what you want not what they want', that's a classic mistake I've made several times and finally learnt from. Hopefully you can get there faster than I did.
Re:The Canon Cat and the Mac That Steve Jobs Killed
by ChrisMarshallNY on Friday October 21, 2022 @11:05AM
(#33288775)
I did, many years ago. The story is from about 1993.
Sigh. You screwed up. You gave the users what you wanted to give, not what they wanted. You must always test & iterate.
> The next release had a lot more text.
Yes, I was too general - different interface needs must get different interfaces. Sometimes icons aren't appropriate, sometimes icons + text is better, sometimes you have to get creative.
> For one thing, icons tend not to translate well
I said that.
> We're best off using ISO icons[0], but designers hate them, and always insist on reinventing the wheel.
That's a flaw in the designers, not the icons then. Are you blaming the icons for that failure?