Device manufactures couldn't care less about AV1. And yet, Google made AV1 support mandatory for Android, Android TV etc.
Or else they wouldn't get Youtube, or get Android, or both etc.
> As you say, hardware manufacturers are holding back codec progress.
Google: releases several codecs in quick succession
Google: uses dominant market position to force everyone to adopt these codecs [1]
HN: Why do device manufacturers stifle progress?
> it's not abuse because it's a better and open standard.
The mere fact of it being better or open doesn't make what Google is doing any less of an abuse of their position.
Except it literaly does. Abuse in the market it not defined by the loss of another company but by the loss of the consumer. Anti-competition laws are ultimately meant to protect the consumer. The consumer. "Abusing" a company in itself is perfectly fine: it's a free market after all.
Abuse of dominance occurs when a dominant business (or group of businesses) engages in activity that stops or substantially reduces competition in a market. These anti-competitive activities may be:
predatory (incurring short-term losses to eliminate a competitor and gain future market power);
exclusionary (trying to prevent a business from operating in a market);
disciplinary (trying to punish a business); or
intended to adversely affect competition (e.g., by making other companies want to compete less and denying consumers the benefit of competition)
Ah yes. Tables. Let's look at the actual text and text in some linked articles [1]
=== start quote ===
Last year, Google began requiring AV1 support for new Android TV and Google TV devices
...
[1]
Google is requiring makers of Android TV devices to support AV1 starting this month. Additionally, Google also seems to push makers of smart TVs and streaming devices not based on Android TV to use AV1 for YouTube.
Google has long forced device makers to use the free VP9 codec for 4K YouTube streams.
=== end quote ===
So, Google is abusing its market position to ram through its own standards. But sure, it's Apple and Safari who are the bad guys.
[1] https://www.protocol.com/youtube-tv-roku-issues