News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app... by int_19h on Thursday October 20, 2022 @02:28PM (#33278717)
Before Android and iOS, the dominant smartphone/PDA platforms were Windows Mobile and Symbian. And whatever their usability issues were, I don't recall there being a problem with downloading (or even buying boxed) third-party software directly from the authors and installing it directly.
Re:How Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app... by kolinko on Thursday October 20, 2022 @03:55PM (#33279855)
As a developer from that era - developing for Symbian was absurdly difficult and awkward.

Around 2007 we tried building an app that scanned barcodes in a store to show you comparison from online stores. Symbian's APIs for cameras were so broken, that we couldn't get a decent enough resolution of photos. Java had permission/ux issues that made the app unfeasible. It was literally impossible to build an app like this back then, even though phones had good enough cameras already.

Not to mention the fact that you needed a whole studio to build and test even a simple app like this - so many variants of OSes, and phones, and every single one had it's own quirks.

And to add an insult to the injury - we had to pirate the SDK, because the official links to SDKs didn't work for a few days, and nobody seemed to notice.

So yeah, in theory the users could download apps to the devices. But in practice it was easier for devs to hack into iPhone 1.0 and build apps there - even before the official app store launch, than it was ever to build something for Symbian and the others.

Re:How Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app... by derefr on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:36PM (#33280330)
Before Android and iOS, no third-party developer cared about smartphones/PDAs, because they were a tiny sliver of the market and so you couldn't make money targeting them. Bigcorps like Microsoft/Facebook/Twitter might make free apps for these, just to cover them (since their own employees used them); but no ISV cared. If you were an ISV developing paid "apps" for "mobile" at all, you were developing J2ME apps for feature-phones.
Re:How Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app... by int_19h on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:34PM (#33281104)
That's plainly not true. Sure, there weren't "millions of apps" in the store, but like I mentioned above, there was actual boxed software sold for those platforms.
Re:How Google is forcing us to make our open source VoIP app... by derefr on Thursday October 20, 2022 @05:51PM (#33281294)
My point is that no ISV ever bootstrapped or got VC-funded in the 1995-2007 period by making a bet on selling "apps" for the PDA software market; the revenue would be too low to keep the company going, and the TAM would be too low for even longer-term-minded VCs to be interested.

What probably did happen, a bit, was that ISVs that made software for other markets, may have ported their software to PDAs, and sold that. (E.g. "WinZip for Windows CE", things like that.) But that doesn't mean that these companies were surviving off of this. These were effectively "halo products" (products that don't sell many units, which are made instead to increase the brand perception of key influencers who happen to have such niche interests, and thus influence their [influential] opinion of the rest of the product range through the halo effect.)