When I'm lost in some interface I can usually find my way to what I wanted or find my way out using those buttons. With my iPod Touch, I end up mashing the home button and starting over, which sometimes just doesn't even do what I wanted.
You might say that I am just used to Android, and that's probably true, but I have had the two devices for almost the same amount of time, and use them both daily. I just prefer Android. Yes, iOS is way smoother, the UI is prettier, and the hardware is even nicer in some cases. But when I get lost or struggle with the interface, somehow it really sticks out on iOS. (I should mention that I get frustrated with Android plenty too)
It's the kind of attitude in your last sentence, suggesting that you cannot fathom why anyone would choose the objectively inferior Android OS, that people get annoyed at in these horrible discussions. It boils down to taste, and to suggest that some people's preferences are not true is unfair. (I'm probably doing you a disservice, I'm sure you're not a raving Apple fan. But you know what I mean, I hope)
(I also wrote a long description of an example of getting lost on iOS but it was really long winded so I trashed it. I can explain it if anyone is actually interested though.)
Android is more open, and its apps have a lot more power over the phone. iPhone is smoother and its apps tend to perform, look, and behave more consistently. There are probably also "killer apps/features" that could make or break one platform for certain users. If you need Flash, you need Android. There are probably many examples of apps that only exist on one platform.
I'm really not much of an Apple fanboy, but to me, smooth performance is an absolute necessity. Simply put, the abysmal performance of basic native widgets on Android is an absolute deal-breaker for me. It so happens that I also generally prefer the design of iOS and the Apple app ecosystem, but obviously those preferences are completely a subjective matter of taste. My first smartphone was a Palm Treo 650 that was extremely snappy, and maybe that's what initiated my mindset, but I won't ever carry a smartphone that isn't. If, at some point in the future, there weren't any smartphones that were snappy, I simply wouldn't have a smartphone (actually, I don't even have one now, but I'm considering getting an iPhone 4S).
* They wanted a smartphone, but they live on the east coast (NYC). For sometime, iPhone was only on AT&T, and AT&T had a reputation for bad reception there. I believe this has improved in the recent years, though, and well, Verizon and Sprint are also in the game now.
* They made an arbitrary choice based on a current promotion, TV ads, look of the phone, screen size, etc., without any deep knowledge of the app ecosystem or hackability. There were also a couple who have never owned an Apple product, but felt that Apple was too trendy, and wanted to get something "different."
IMO, Android and iOS are two very different beasts that look the same if you were to just compare the specs. Both have phones with touch screens. Both have apps. Both have cameras, etc, etc. This is how users compare. We know that these are not the useful criteria for comparison. But how would you reasonably explain this to a non-tech user?
For the OS, I prefer Android because it is more flexible and smarter. Apps that are doing stuff in the background behave like expected, actually doing stuff in the background. The back button is standardized, apps on Android collaborate more because of the well designed intents system, I like my interactive backgrounds or screen widgets, I like my task manager, I like my Wifi tethering without paying a freaking tax for it, I love that you can install apps from outside the marketplace without a jailbreak, I love the way my contacts are fully synchronized with Google's Contacts, I love how Facebook adds new phone numbers and updates the pictures of my contacts list, I love how upload buttons in the browser are NOT disabled, I like the turn-by-turn directions of GMaps, I like the awesome/native integration with GMail, I like that I am allowed to have Flash on it (I rarely use it, keep it disabled, but it is useful when I need it) and I could go on and on.
As for the marketplace, I like how unrestricted it is. I have an app that blocks calls, SMS messages and deletes all logs of blacklisted phone numbers. This was the first app I installed on my Galaxy S since it is so useful to me. And when I tried it on the iPhone, apparently apps like iBlacklist need a jailbreak - I mean, WTF? That's not a smartphone.
The iPhone 3GS I bought because people like you claim it is so much better. I bought it without a contract so it was a lot more expensive than my legally unlocked Galaxy S purchased with a plan. I regret buying it.
Unfortunately there's a really loud minority of iPhone users that are recommending iPhones, getting really heated over Android. So here's what I suspect - I suspect that this is a side effect of buyer's remorse, trying to justify an investment that you know in your heart is a losing bet (pretty sure this syndrome has a name, but I don't know it).
That's probably true to some extent, and Android should still get credit in those cases because it was specifically designed to support a wide variety of hardware. Contrast with iOS which was designed to produce the best possible experience on a few specific hardware platforms, which means that iPhones are stuck on 3.5" screens and resolutions that are exact multiples of the original.
Things like live wallpaper make a great, great first impression. Many people have seen an iPhone, then the see the Samsung "beach" live wallpaper and say "wow".
I'll also add that preferring Android hardware isn't one thing it can be one or many of all sorts of features:
- Larger screen (or smaller, though this is less common)
- Hardware keyboard (slider or Blackberry/Treo form factor)
- LTE (and faster HSPA+) support
- Removable / upgradeable battery
- Expandable / removable storage
- More flexible ports (e.g. HDMI, USB host support [control your digital camera!], etc.)
- Other niche options (e.g. NFC, gaming controls, stylus support, etc.)
Not to mention the dimensions that the iPhone only caught up on with the 4S like:
- Faster CPUs / more cores
- Higher-resolution camera
And on and on.
Having my upcoming calendar on screen at the same time as the phone/sms/mail/web buttons just works well for me. I imagine others would get similar value out of a music and facebook widget combo.
I don't think anyone denies that there are Android phones with amazing hardware specs (great screens, slim designs, fast CPUs, etc.). I just have trouble believing that people (other than the exceptions I mentioned earlier, which I highly doubt are a significant percentage of Android users) who have used both Android and iOS truly prefer the Android OS.