Re:Mythbusters experiment goes awry, sends cannonball throug...
by DanielStraight on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @04:56PM
(#3326260)
I will admit that my certainty in my conclusion was premature, but it's still my best theory. The mythbusters are professionals. The choice of location was supported by government designation. And the mythbusters were supervised in the experiment. Negligence is still possible, but I feel it's much less likely than a freak accident.
Either way, what I was really trying to address was the attitude in this post ( http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3324444 ), among others, that accidents like this should never happen. I was trying to say that not every accident is caused by negligence. Even if this one was, the main point stands.
I also realize that sounds like a cop out, which is not my intent. You are absolutely right. My conclusion is really just a theory right now, and I should have presented it as such.
Re:Mythbusters experiment goes awry, sends cannonball throug...
by MichaelApproved on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @08:27PM
(#3327096)
I do agree with you that MB are usually very safe and careful and I suspect, like you, this was a freak accident.
This statement is just as ignorant as any accusing MB of sloppiness. We know almost nothing right now. To say it a freak accident that couldn't have been predicted is premature.
There needs to be an investigation then a conclusion.