Re:Mandelbrot Beats Economics in Fathoming Markets
by pixcavator on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @03:18PM
(#3325749)
>"economists asserting the difference between modeling human behavior vs. the behavior of physical objects"
Is it really that different? Try to attach an object to several springs and see if it behaves "rationally".
Re:Mandelbrot Beats Economics in Fathoming Markets
by dreamdu5t on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @04:44PM
(#3326207)
It is very different.
Physical objects do not have free will. They don't act towards goals. They conform to unchanging mathematical patterns.
Humans do not. What I do today cannot be accurately used to determine what I will do tomorrow.
Re:Mandelbrot Beats Economics in Fathoming Markets
by _delirium on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @05:52PM
(#3326570)
Ah, but that's assuming something very much in debate. Humans are actually quite predictable in many ways, though not as well as springs (currently). Aggregate behavior can often be predicted to reasonable accuracy, at least as well as with other complex, non-human systems like the weather. And even individual behavior can be predicted with enough information (and neuroscientists can even predict some specific decisions seconds in advance, given the right instrumentation). Just knowing some demographic and contextual information about a person hugely reduces your error on predicting what their "choices" will be.
Re:Mandelbrot Beats Economics in Fathoming Markets
by dreamdu5t on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @06:27PM
(#3326716)
It's a little different because the weatherman isn't forcing his predictions on you.
The debate takes on a different dimension when you're talking about political policy, when the weatherman passes a law forcing everyone to wear raincoats on days of high chances of precipitation.
It came from economists asserting the difference between modeling human behavior vs. the behavior of physical objects. In that sense it is not meaningless. It's an important distinction that in order to model human behavior, we have to accept that people's goals are myriad and constantly shifting, and that we can only come to know their goals or preferences by them being revealed in action.