Re:Ask HN: Why is Hacker News not interested in defense tech...
by PaulHoule on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @11:41AM
(#33249069)
I think HNers perceive other technology areas as being open, that is, somebody with a good idea can start a company, possibly get funding, have a chance to succeed.
In the case of defense it seems to be a matter of who you know instead of what you know. In the adjacent aerospace field, for instance, boondoggles like this
are widespread and somehow the people involved can't see it the way that the rest of us see it -- that is, $23 billion spent on that is something we couldn't spend on something else and is a reason why "we can't have nice things". I managed to hear a significant amount of gossip about a program that a 3 letter agency decided to pursue with EADS despite EADS having no familiarity with the technology involved and being frankly completely lost about how to proceed.
There is a hermetic culture of people involved in defense contracting who, I think, just don't see the barriers involved. You, for instance, received a security clearance when you served in the Navy. For a small company getting security clearances for workers who don't already have them could seem next to impossible.
In the case of defense it seems to be a matter of who you know instead of what you know. In the adjacent aerospace field, for instance, boondoggles like this
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Space_Launch_System
are widespread and somehow the people involved can't see it the way that the rest of us see it -- that is, $23 billion spent on that is something we couldn't spend on something else and is a reason why "we can't have nice things". I managed to hear a significant amount of gossip about a program that a 3 letter agency decided to pursue with EADS despite EADS having no familiarity with the technology involved and being frankly completely lost about how to proceed.
There is a hermetic culture of people involved in defense contracting who, I think, just don't see the barriers involved. You, for instance, received a security clearance when you served in the Navy. For a small company getting security clearances for workers who don't already have them could seem next to impossible.