From my limited perspective of having recently worked at Intel, they had a lot of dead weight. There was a lot of talent, but it was also diluted by a lot of management and bureaucracy.
I honestly don't know if layoffs are an effective solution to this, but IMHO they could definitely benefit from lower headcount and greater urgency.
I'm still trying to reconcile it with the CHIPs thing. Intel on one hand is admittedly bloated and inefficient, and so is choosing to reduce its headcount and therefore bandwidth to do work.
So what is the CHIPs money going to. Typically when you invest in something like this you are buying people's time to do the work and also materials and supplies to build the stuff like factories, etc. So if we are lowering headcount it's not going to labor.
I suspect as you say it's more about changing worker types, like getting rid of skillsets they don't need so they can hire those they do like people to build semi plants here.
So, in my mind, the only way it adds up is if Intel goes on a big hiring spree soon. Otherwise, where did the money go? We can buy equipment to build plants but who builds them?
Gelsinger thinks x86's days are numbered. So Intel's historical moat of designing and manufacturing x86 chips is going away.
So now it's more compelling to treat design and manufacturing as separate business concerns:
- For potential foundry customers, it reduces fears that Intel will give higher priority to fab'ing its own chips.
- It frees Intel's chip designers to design chips without needing to assume they'll be built at Intel's foundries. E.g., they can design chips for TSMC's process if that would result in a better product.
And given all these factors, I suspect Gelsinger and the Intel board of directors are planning to separate the design and manufacturing functions into separate businesses. (Either practically speaking by limiting their interaction within Intel, or literally by making them separate companies.)
----- B--- (Hupa) received a BA from Stanford and wrote her 2017 Berkeley PhD dissertation Wailaki Grammar on a Dene language spoken along the Eel River in northern California. Now an Assistant Professor of Native American Studies at Humboldt State University, her research focuses on Dene languages, and on historical-comparative linguistics for language revitalization within the Wailaki and Hupa communities. While at Stanford and Berkeley she also worked with speakers of Karuk, Yucatec Maya, and Sereer. B---- is a coauthor of "Xo’ch Na:nahsde’tl’-te: Survivance, resilience and unbroken traditions in northwest California" (2019, with Cutcha Risling Baldy, in Ka'm-t'em: A Journey Toward Healing), and has contributed to the Hupa Online Dictionary and Texts project (at UC Davis). She is also a traditional basket weaver and singer from the Xontah Nikya:aw in Hoopa Valley, and a member of the board of the Advocates for Indigenous California Language Survival.
You can easily guess what the purpose of the program is.
1500 years ago, Aryabhata came up with an algorithm for approximating an integer ratio with (what we today call) continued fractions, and we use it today for that and for inverting elements of finite fields. Aryabhata was a Hindu, speaking Sanskrit, living in a monarchy; no corporation he formed part of still exists, or could exist, at least according to accepted legal principles. Yet his algorithm continues to be correct today, and like the movement of the Earth, it would continue to be correct even if nobody believed it.
Platonists believe that mathematical constructs like programs are actually more objectively real than things like stones or puppies, because propositions about them have a truth-value that is independent not only of the speaker's social context but also of time. Today this puppy is alive; tomorrow she will be dead. The Pythagorean Theorem doesn't do that.
How do you even know whos going to be fired?
Intel has not announced layoffs. There is a rumor layoffs will be announced at the next quarterly earnings release.
it's not a jobs program and majority of the layoffs are targeting non-technical areas. Raw number of engineers isn't a great metric for government programs either, could be easily gamed. Focus should be on building up the ground level infrastructure needed so actual innovation can happen, not just giving money to Intel and other established players to further strengthen their monopoly
The CHIPs bill was pretty broad. It might make sense to subsidize a pure-foundry company as an ongoing issue (in particular, isolate these big investments from the boom-bust semiconductor trends). Or somehow try to come up with subsidies that go to Intel to the extent to which they act as a pure foundry, but that will be pretty tricky to work out I guess.
An ecosystem of open fabs seems to be a prerequisite of those small plucky startup chip design teams. Of course they can order from TSMC but then they have to wait however many weeks to test out each prototype...
The US government, US, we, gave Intel and some other companies a huge sum of money to stay awesome.
Then they announce huge layoffs to get rid of a lot of thr talent, people, heart of their business.
So, wouldn't we have been better off as a society of we had just offered thT CHIPs money as a startup find and asked a bunch or people from Intel to leave and build new semi companies using this fund?
In the end the meteic for success of the CHIPs program in the short term should be number of people working in semi in the US. How did we dedicate money and resources to this thing of national importance and end up with fewer experts working on it?
Money is the root of all evil, power corrupts us all.