News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by olliej on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:49PM (#33240530)
I asked, what are examples of beliefs that are excluded by CoCs?

Most CoCs I've seen simply state a variation of "don't be an asshole", "don't act like some people aren't actually humans", etc - which seems reasonable to me: being an asshole drives away contributors, treating some people as subhuman has a similar effect.

I have yet to see a CoC that limits beliefs (e.g. "no christians", "no muslims", "no atheists"), nor politics (e.g. "no democrats", "no republicans", etc), nor any other group really - I have certainly never seen any CoC that excluded sexuality or biology, and I would love an example because I think that kind of discrimination is important to acknowledge and avoid.

I'm sure that you could find some smaller projects that do shit like the above, but by and large CoCs are generally boring "respect other people in the community" drivel.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by readsadhours on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:38PM (#33241032)
The original(?) one was not great as it contained exclusionary/discriminatory rules. See the "We will not act on complaints regarding" section https://web.archive.org/web/20160304034554/http://todogroup....

I am not aware of any modern CoC containing such section.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by olliej on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @01:50AM (#33243428)
What was discriminatory in the "We will not act on complaints regarding" section?

* ‘Reverse’ -isms, including ‘reverse racism,’ ‘reverse sexism,’ and ‘cisphobia’

These aren't real things though - they're usually brought up in the context of methods to try and address underlying biases due to historical ("reverse" -racism, -sexism), or that I have never even heard of anyone claiming 'cisphobia' so I am unaware of when/how that would be claimed.

* Reasonable communication of boundaries...

Seems like there's nothing to discuss here at all - once a person says "stop talking to me" you can move on

* Refusal to explain or debate social justice concepts

No one owes anyone their time, this is all stuff that has been covered extensively, and is easily googleable.

* Communicating in a ‘tone’ you don’t find congenial

If anything this seems lax compared to many current CoCs that expect/require professional communication. This is "person X came across as angry/belittling/dismissive and it makes me upset" isn't something that they'll act on.

* Criticizing racist, sexist, cissexist, or otherwise oppressive behavior or assumptions

e.g the CoC won't act on someone complaining that someone else criticized racist, sexist, cissexist, etc behaviour.

Again, I fail to see the "exclusionary/discriminatory" rules.

I see the bigger issue with this section is that it makes an explicit list of things that don't matter and will be ignored. This is tricky as it means they ignore things that I would say should not be ignored, and vice versa. It also kind of means any kind of assholery that comes up in future isn't explicitly covered, so what rule applies?, etc

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by jeroenhd on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:57PM (#33240596)
You can read the CoC here: https://github.com/PolyMC/PolyMC/blob/aecd158d3c9fce7e42143c... Doesn't seem to exclude any normal behaviour.

Considering the torrent of transphobic posts related to this issue, this could be a hostile account takeover or maybe a transphobic developer. I associate the language used here with 4chan above all else, though some far-right groups use the same lingo.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by kelseyfrog on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:04PM (#33240679)
The SQLite CoE[1] comes to mind. It is the one that gets closest to exclusionary[2], but even so it's still generally well-regarded on HN when it's discussed.[3][4].

1. https://sqlite.org/codeofethics.html

2. In that it assumes a Christian God. Rules: 1, 10, 21, 41, 42, 49, 50, 58, 60, 62, 70, 72.

3. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18273530

4. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=18313131

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by olliej on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:52AM (#33243104)
Oh, woof that's quite the CoE :-O
Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by wisnoskij on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:22PM (#33240866)
I had not even read the CoC at that point. But it is somewhat similar in practise to the old Discord stuff. Hateful exclusionary Dog whistling mostly, nothing outright actionable, nothing you could take to court, but well understood what it means and how certain people will be treated under it.

The current rules under Lenny are ~dont be an asshole, dont cause drama, respect people.~ And yet people are lying about, brigading, spamming, and trying to destroy the project (and apparently harassing and sending threatening messages to Lenny) because he did not adopt a different CoC.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by nalllar on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:25PM (#33241445)
There is a big difference between "did not adopt a different CoC" and "removed all the other maintainers from the project and unilaterally deleted a CoC which had been around for a long time".

As far as I can tell, your message is itself misinformation.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by wisnoskij on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:13PM (#33241812)
If you look at the github history, it looks like people were literally griefing and deleting all of polymc. So it looks like he did not remove developers until after they threw a temper tantrum and started trying to destroy the project. What is a owner supposed to do when people you gave authority to start accepting PRs that delete all the content or replace the readme.md with trolly memes and harassment?

OR maybe some were removed before. All I know is clearly this targeted harassment campaign are not being forthright and truthful, otherwise the github history would not show what it shows.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by None4U on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:45PM (#33242019)
Can you link to which commit you're talking about? Have you verified it's not from a fork or a PR?
Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by wisnoskij on Monday October 17, 2022 @10:02PM (#33242114)
Hmm, maybe I just dont understand github. I have only ever done one PR. I see people approved (https://github.com/PolyMC/PolyMC/pull/1243) and took that to mean PolyMC devs approved it, but maybe the forker approved his own fork and that has nothing to do with polymc devs?
Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by Nullabillity on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:50PM (#33242055)
This is just... not true? The README.md history[0] shows that it was last updated in august.

[0]: https://github.com/PolyMC/PolyMC/commits/develop/README.md

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by wisnoskij on Monday October 17, 2022 @10:06PM (#33242136)
It is possible I dont understand how GH works. I apologies if I was wrong. I was talking about (https://github.com/PolyMC/PolyMC/pull/1243), which got 2 approvals. But it is possible I dont understand what approvals are, but to looks to me that people with authority on polymc to make changes approved of troll/destructive changes. But I am not an GH expert, maybe you dont need authority approve a PR that deleted the entire project and completly changes the readme?
Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by Macha on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @07:17AM (#33245623)
Anyone on GitHub can give a grey checkmark approval. It's basically just a thumbs up. The green checkmark approvals are the ones given by people who at time of approving had project approval permission and only these green checkmark approvals have any mechanical effect.

Additionally, everyone who has ever contributed to the project gets a "Contributor" tag on their profile (current recognised contributors with permissions get a "Member" tag). You can see the trolling PR authors and approvers lack those.

So no, the trolls, including those giving the grey checkmark approvals, are not the former maintainers.

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by IAmLiterallyAB on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:53PM (#33242067)
I see nothing like that in the Git commit history? What are you talking about?

Edit: it looks like some randos opened some PRs in the past couple hours. But that was after he already went rogue and kicked everyone?

Re:PolyMC compromised by rogue developer having unabomber ma... by wisnoskij on Monday October 17, 2022 @10:08PM (#33242156)
I apologies if I just do not understand how the GH PR system works. I see approved/reviewed troll PRs. Maybe randoms can review/approve PRs? I assumed they had to be devs to approve PRs.