News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by ipaddr on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:38PM (#33240406)
Doesn't really explain how co-pilot is stealing your community. I've used co-pilot and it works great until you are past boilerplate than it falls apart.
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by ja3k on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:44PM (#33240467)
> Over time, this process will starve these com­mu­ni­ties. User atten­tion and engage­ment will be shifted into the walled gar­den of Copi­lot and away from the open-source projects them­selves

The author seems to be implying that since Copilot can reproduce the code of open source repository X in certain scenarios there'd be no reason for programmers to learn/use/engage with repository X. But this is silly. Maybe some open source repositories could be tab completed with a little prompting but people will presumably choose to add a dependency instead of tab completing the code of express or something.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by cowtools on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:54PM (#33240576)
It strips GPL, or any license.
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by bigiain on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:04PM (#33240684)
It strips the (mandatory, in a lot of cases) licence text. But the licence still applies.

(Or I guess more technically, the original authors copyright still applies, and the rights granted to use the work under the license as an exception to the strict limitation under copyright - do not apply...)

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by cercatrova on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:54PM (#33240574)
It also doesn't make any sense. Copilot suggesting to me the signature of a function from some library is not actually the same as executing that library. That library still needs to be downloaded onto my computer to be executed. And who will write new features to a library if not for the people who are interested in that?
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by remram on Tuesday October 18, 2022 @12:09AM (#33242859)
Open-source licenses have terms that apply to the source code, not "execution", so I really don't understand your point?
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by otterley on Monday October 17, 2022 @06:55PM (#33240580)
Agree, the argument seems pretty threadbare. Millions of programmers use open-source software every day and incorporate it into their own projects without ever engaging the authors of the code upon which they rely.

Perhaps the author means that there’s a possibility that the programmer to whom the code was suggested won’t necessarily know its provenance and how to engage the community from whence it came. If so, that’s a stronger argument, but I don’t know that it’s the best one they can make.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by ok123456 on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:17PM (#33240806)
It's just basically a search engine, but the context is the rest of your code.

Writing software just auto-completing from CoPilot would be like trying to write a whole novel with the auto-predictive text on your phone. You could do it, but the results would be non-nonsensical and full of semantic errors. I don't think there's any real 'provenance' at play in either case.

This guy is a literal who, who is really over estimating the value of his open source contributions over a general development tool that can reduce the cognitive load of working in some hairy code bases.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by bakugo on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:02PM (#33240656)
"It's not a problem that it steals code because it doesn't work that well right now" is not a valid argument, don't pretend that AI doesn't advance on a daily basis.

Reminds me of people who defend AI art with "you can tell it apart from real art" yeah no, at the rate we're moving you won't be able to tell at all in a year or two.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by blacksmith_tb on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:18PM (#33240819)
I agree with your starting point, but art actually makes the questions clearer I think - having AI art "you can't tell apart" is possibly a bad thing for human producers of art (or not, obviously lots of artists don't make their art just to get paid, but if you do...), but seems like a great thing for the human consumers of art? Copiliot/tabnine etc. could certainly give you terrible suggestions, but my experience is they often help with boring scaffolding-stuff which isn't likely to be full of bad ideas, just time savings. Could they mess you up? Oh for sure. But mostly they just seem like an autocorrect that doesn't guess wrong every other time.
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by crispyambulance on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:09PM (#33240722)
They don't really explain in a satisfactory way how Copilot is "stealing communities" even though they themselves complain that Microsoft hasn't provided "solid legal references".

Copilot is an AI stunt, an exploration, trying something new and exciting with very mixed and not-so-useful results.

This lawsuit, however, is just lawyers doing what they do for fun. I guess the retained Microsoft lawyers love it too. Glad to see lawyers having so much fun and profit. But we would all be better off with out so much lawyering, can't they do something more worthwhile?

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by batmanturkey on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:53PM (#33241674)
You are willfully ignoring thst the article absolutely DID address this point!

The license and attribution are stripped from regurgitated copied code snippets from code projects. If the people don’t known which project the code was taken from, how can they one day contribute to that codebase? If the code projects on GitHub are not getting the people who use their code at least aware of the project, that project disappears. Copilot is an interloper who doesn’t even tell you which project the code snippet was ripped off from!!

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by skydhash on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:58PM (#33241705)
I’d guess it is basically: you’re making a mural people can look at for free, but a business selling canvas reproduction of it without attribution.

If I solve a problem and I say: Sure, use my code if you want, but be sure to contribute any improvement back to the community - I wouldn’t be happy seeing a tool spewing it out everywhere. And it’s not even free. In this case, microsoft is literally making money on the back of millions of programmers. And without approval.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by dahdum on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:27PM (#33240917)
The community argument is weak but it’s just content marketing, not a thesis. The goal of the article is to generate leads for potential members of a class action lawsuit.
Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by max51 on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:41PM (#33241068)
The fact that the company building it doesn't want to put their own code in the training set should be really big red flag.

It has been proven over and over again again that you can get copilot to regurgitate verbatim code that originally came from a proprietary codebase.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by tiborsaas on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:26PM (#33241450)
It doesn't, it's just a very easy to relate to argument.

Generating snippets of code has nothing to do with a fully functional software package/product/service and an organic community around it.

One might argue that a community could be more easily formed thanks to co-pilot because it increases developer productivity and lower the effort to contribute so OS projects actually benefit from co-pilot. If this sounds far fetched, then probably the first case is also similar.

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by batmanturkey on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:55PM (#33241685)
IF they attributed the code snippet to the project they ripped it off from!!

But they deliberately don’t tell you thst… it’s just a code snippet floating in space like they invented it

Re:GitHub Copi­lot inves­ti­ga­tion by batmanturkey on Monday October 17, 2022 @08:52PM (#33241663)
The license and attribution are stripped from regurgitated copied code snippets from code projects.

If the people don’t known which project the code was taken from, how can they one day contribute to that codebase?

If the code projects on GitHub are not getting the people who use their code at least aware of the project, that project disappears.

Copilot is an interloper who doesn’t even tell you which project the code snippet was ripped off from!!