...because of how executive compensation is typically structured. Non-executive employees can also receive stock grants.
1. Guide the company to do things that boost the stock price in the short term (1-3 years) but destroy the company's ability to compete on longer time lines
2. Dump your stock position
This doesn't usually happen with founders, but I can personally attest to the fact that this has been intentionally by board members of billion dollar businesses.
There are also more subtle approaches, e.g. board members pushing for strategies that hurt the company, but boost the board members' other holdings.
It's possible to not have a top-down approach on a day-to-day basis, but for the founders to still maintain veto power at the end of the day if shit happens.
And what employee would prefer a promise to represent their best interests on the board over actual representation?
That said, like pure authoritarianism, pure democracy as a state governance system also has failure modes, and its merits are also debatable.
How does being a non-employee make an outside board member less self-interested? What if an outside board member wants to get paid $500K a year in cash for serving on the board and overthrows the CEO to get it?
At the end of the day board members have a fiduciary duty to shareholders that applies regardless of whether they're an employee.
The idea that someone who spends almost all of their waking hours on a company would be more likely to tank a company than someone who spends a few hours a month as an outside board member seems odd to say the least.
That's the thing, they (assuming you're talking about an investor or cofounder) wouldn't want to. They're holding onto a chunk of equity that would be worth maybe $10M, $100M, maybe even $1G, if the company gets to IPO, so they would NOT want to sabotage the company by taking a $500K salary from it now and have their shares be worth nothing.
Employees who have peanuts in equity have different incentives. They couldn't give three hoots about the company's long term success if they can get $500K this year for a downpayment on a house to send their kids to a good school district.
An employee has incentives like needing the company to survive so that they can maintain their healthcare, pay rent/mortgage each month, maintain a work visa, and recieve a pension. Getting a big downpayment on a house makes the employee even more tied to their employment, since now they have a bigger monthly cost to fill than before.
Unless you're already clearly a unicorn it's not particularly easy to find a buyer for your founder equity in a startup at the prices it might IPO at if things go well.
Founders selling their own equity too early will also destroy morale and investor relations to the point where the company isn't likely to succeed anymore. Buyers realize this, and aren't going to hand you IPO prices for it.
However, they also don't sabotage the company since word would get around that they or the VC they represent are terrible board members that sabotage companies.
Besides reputation damage, they can also be sued by the shareholders for failing to uphold their fiduciary duty.
It's similar to why the CEO doesn't just pay themselves their entire series C, close the company, and retire (assuming the bylaws allow the CEO to pay themselves).
Not always true. I've had VCs who want to split their investment between fund and personal at the last minute when you pretty much don't have a choice and don't have time to shop around.
Your thinking doesn't seem to take into account the social and economic power dynamics at play. The working class has less bargaining power than the capitalist class right now in general. We are forced to live under their terms and have very little say in what the status quo is.
Like actual democracy, the system is only as good as its people. No management system will spin gold from a carton of clowns.
A democracy would certainly give a company a huge advantage. I would take a significant pay cut for that. But it does have to produce tasty soup as well, and in order to exist at all, pay salaries.
I'll be candid in saying that I haven't found a company that meets my high expectations. :)
I don't understand how this applies. If anything, having only employees on the board would mean fewer total cooks (i.e. stakeholders influencing decisions) compared to having those same employees in the company plus a board of outsiders.
Or isolation of the board from information at all levels of the company leads to poor decision framing?
That's only possible if every workplace is organized along those lines, and workplaces are networked together to coordinate their action. It's not possible by people just leaving a company, you need to also construct the structures of democracy.
I always felt like seeking input from employees, especially those who have contributed significantly and that you value a lot, is extremely important, but it's not necessary for them to have board seats and votes to consciously take steps to obtain their feedback and make good use of it.
Since participation in a company is entirely at-will, what's wrong with "Join if you agree with the founders' vision, leave if you don't"?
Too many cooks spoil the broth.