News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by jonathankoren on Monday October 17, 2022 @07:19AM (#33232047)
I don't think you actually considered the energies and timespans required (let alone the political will) to yeet a rock at an unseen planet on the other side of the galaxy.

At 1% the speed of light, it will take 10 million years just see if you hit anything on the other side of Milky Way. If you have to wait 10 million years, why do you even care? You'll be extinct, as will your target.

Even if you do decide chuck a dinosaur killing sized boulder (which, really is probably the smallest you'd want to use), you'd have expend 4.5 * 10^23 joules just to accelerate it. That's equivalent of all the solar radiation that hits the Earth over five days. That's a huge lift for even a supposed Kardashev I civilization. It's something more practical for a Kardashev II civilization. Although to be fair, the practical threshold is probably somewhere between I and II. And let's be clear here. If you're dismantling planets to build mirrors, you're Galacticus.

Getting back down to actual facts, it's unlikely there are any Kardashev II civilizations anywhere near us. The infrared skew of their emissions and stellar dimming would be detected. Further out? Well, I guess, but I doubt it. There's nothing particularly unusual about our corner of the galaxy.

Anyway, how would the decision to throw a rock across the galaxy even work? A civilization obtains Kardashev II, and immediately starts looking for Kardashev Is or earlier, and starts tossing rocks at them, just in case they don't go extinct in 10 million years, and somehow don't also become a Kardashev II in the next 10 million years, because as soon as they do, they're going to hit you with a rock at you 20 million years? To put that in perspective, 20 million years ago was when apes and monkeys split on the evolutionary tree. At this point, you might as well toss a rock at every planet that has a biosignature, because 10 million years is a long time.

If this casually genocidal Kardashev II civilization exists on the far side of the Milky Way, and wanted kill humanity, they'd be looking at humans and apes' last common ancestor. They'd have wait another 10 million years just to get a radio signal, and then what? Throw the rock immediately, and hope that in the ensuing 10 million years humanity hasn't learned how to redirect a relativistic rock? Or maybe they just threw the rock without even waiting for the radio signal, and it's on its way right now! Maybe the asteroid that hit 65 million years ago was a warning shot! Maybe they were trying to kill off a Silurian civilization before it even got really started, and ironically spawned us!

This strains credulity.

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by linkdink on Monday October 17, 2022 @09:03AM (#33232883)
Replicator machines could outlive their creators. Then maybe most civilizations think it's safer not to risk being discovered by one, just in case it exists. That seems reasonable and doable.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by jonathankoren on Monday October 17, 2022 @11:23AM (#33234794)
You’ve gone from accusing me of a straw man argument, to postulating that not only do the Stargate Replicators exist, but every other advanced civilization knows they exist but somehow hide from them, even though by all conservative estimates, if Von Neuman proves did in fact exist, more than enough time has elapsed that the entire galaxy should have been converted to a grey goo by now.

Replicator machines “seem doable”?!?

Explain. Seriously. Explain what technologies and energy sources would create a complex autonomous machines from unrefined raw materials.

If it’s easier, explain how you’d make make a paper clip from first principles in the middle of a Greenland glacier. What are you going to do? Use electrolysis to split the water, and then have a fusion device fuse hydrogen into iron? Scrape across the surface to find trace atoms, and hope you find enough iron? Even if you have iron? How do you plan to forge it into steel, and then shape it? Are you going to use a tunneling electron microscope to place individual atoms? What’s the energy budget for this? How are you collecting and storing it? What’s the mass of this machine?

“Seems doable”! Pshaw! EVERY ONE of these thought experiments from the 1940s are just magical premise to base a much simpler analysis on. In the case of Von Neuman proves, it’s determining a limit on how fast you could settle the galaxy. It’s not a serious proposal. It never was.

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by linkdink on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:00PM (#33236446)
Still a strawman because I didn't say sci fi replicators. You could make an automated system that travels, mines, and manufactures. Like a 3D printer that prints copies of itself. That's not unbelievable.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by jonathankoren on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:08PM (#33236569)
You literally described sci-fi replicators.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by linkdink on Monday October 17, 2022 @02:16PM (#33237560)
I thought those were all-in-one nanobot things?
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by jonathankoren on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:41PM (#33239259)
Nanobots are even dumber. They're magic.

The problem with von Neumann probes isn't the proverbial 3d printer. It's the filament. You have to build an entire supply chain for every individual component from first principles. That's why I asked how do you even make a single paper clip in Greenland. That's literally just a stainless steel wire. That's trivial compared to making an excavator, let alone an interstellar spacecraft.

Think about it. Mineral deposits aren't uniformly distributed. You're going to need to combine elements from thousands of kilometers away, and that's assuming their reachable from the surface with relative ease.

The only plausible way build a "replicator" is actually to send entire premade factories, harvesters, and transports to a planet in a giant cooperative swarm, along with literally tons of preprocessed materials for repairs until you get a self sustaining supply chain running. And that implicitly assumes that all the requisite materials are even available. Land on a planet without plate tectonics, and your heavier elements may forever be locked under tens of kilometers of solid rock, or even better 60 kilometers of solid ice, liquid water, and rock. (Good luck with your Europan gold mine!)

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by linkdink on Monday October 17, 2022 @10:38PM (#33242346)
So there's no benefit to collaborating because of distances and time scales. A system of machines is plausible, so there's a non-zero risk of encountering something like that. Civilizations decide to hide because only bad things could happen if they don't. And now you have a dark forest. The hunter doesn't have to exist. The prey just has to be fearful.