News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by nullc on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:39AM (#33230087)
I think that model only works if the stable civilizations are advanced enough to survive arbitrary threats, otherwise they'll just get wiped out by chance over time and replaced with expansionist ones which are more robust against anything other than being systematically destroyed by something they irritated. ... plus to destroy an expansionist civilization you'd have to have significantly superior expansionist technology.

I.e. how do you destroy an expansionist fleet which has scaled up to the point that it's furthest point from you is increasing close to the speed of light?

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by pencilguin on Monday October 17, 2022 @02:31AM (#33230374)
See, you don't know how, and I don't know how.

But they are, remember, incomprehensibly more advanced than you or me. And they know a bunch of other incomprehensibly more advanced civilizations all the way on the other side of the expansionist noobs. And, just because they don't usually see much point in going out there doesn't mean they can't, or won't, when the time seems right for it.

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by nullc on Monday October 17, 2022 @01:09PM (#33236575)
Not much point in reasoning about magic though, might as well say "God will provide" as it gives similar insight. I think assuming that the laws of physics, as we understand them, and reasoning whats possible and likely within them is a lot more interesting.

I can come up with one respons within the believed laws of physics at how a hypothetical stable civilization could suppress exponential ones even though exponential ones would quickly be expanding their radius at close to C: the stable civilization would need to pre-seed the visible universe with idle hidden outposts of a sufficient density to detect and suppress exponential expanders.

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by pencilguin on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @03:57PM (#33267222)
The non-expansionists don't need to fight all possible expansionists. They only need to fight the ones that come around. If B can't beat A, A will soon encounter C, and then D and E, with a fresh roll of the dice each time. The bigger they get, the more adversaries they cross.

We are not predicting the future, but trying to account for an observation. For the scenario to remain on the list of reasons why we haven't been visited, it suffices that it is possible. There are of course lots of other possible reasons, among them that there is nobody to visit.

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by nullc on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @11:57PM (#33270682)
> The non-expansionists don't need to fight all possible expansionists. They only need to fight the ones that come around.

That come around us since we're trying to explain why we haven't seen an expansionists. So this line of thinking predicts that we're in the shadow of a non-expansionists, I guess?

Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by pencilguin on Thursday October 20, 2022 @04:14PM (#33280089)
Exactly.
Re:DarkForestSim: A Netlogo Simulation of the Dark Forest Hy... by GoblinSlayer on Monday October 17, 2022 @04:51AM (#33231174)
If the fleet flies far enough, they will merely isolate themselves in the intergalactic space.