I'm strongly of the belief that Google's internal strategy has long surpassed "organising the world's information", and is now something like "become the world's biggest private intelligence agency.", but that's a paranoid side-note.. ask me more on this at your peril. ;)
Regardless, I wouldn't have written any of this if I didn't have a certain love for the company, and desire to follow their movements with some level of intimacy. I just don't agree with everything I suspect they'll be doing 20 years from now.
So I think that comment is just a little over the top, it's not that far beyond what the undisputed reality is.
For example it recently occurred to me: Google Voice transcribes your voice mail to text. I wonder to what extent they index that and use this as a sample of your telephone conversations as a way of better targetting ads to you. That strikes me as very scary because at that point I have no control over the retention of this information and then it becomes something the government can easily subpoena via something like the Stored Communications Act.
Must be why they are paying those huge retention bonuses...
When we're talking about a company what's the difference between a "conspiracy" and a "plan" or "strategy"? (Serious question.)
Your argument about the "google hacker's revolt" is is even more laughable that the conspiracy theory.
Then I will. It's a conspiracy theory, worthy of all the mocking typically associated with such a thing.
Anyone who's been watching Google long enough, closely enough, knows how out of character this would be. Such efforts, not to mention the purported motivation, is not in their nature.
Google employees start hundreds (thousands?) of new projects every year with little coordination. Some of these end up becoming big, official things, and we end up with Gmail. They throw stuff at the wall and see what sticks.
There might be some group inside Google thinking along the lines this guy is. I doubt it, but it's possible. It might even be the native client guys. What there isn't, is a massive internal conspiracy crossing every product team up and down the chain of command, aimed at making Google the sole arbiter of what can run on your device.
Even if the executives wanted it to happen, it couldn't. How do I know this?
Because Google is full of hackers who would instantly revolt. They've had enough problems with things like their real name policy and the handful of places they've had to acquiesce to DRM.
A coordinated effort to make Google into The One True Gatekeeper into your electronic life on a scale unmatched even by 1990s Microsoft? I await the flying pigs.