Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc...
by hutzlibu on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:21PM
(#33219566)
"Firefox and Safari call this "private browsing". Firefox also uses a mask icon. Are these any different?"
Well, "private" is clearly different from "incognito". But the mask with firefox is misleading, too.
And the article is misleading as well, because it implies that chrome is still tracking you in incognito mode, which is not right. Google might be tracking you.
But to comment on the lawsuit, I lack details.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc...
by BeefWellington on Sunday October 16, 2022 @12:11AM
(#33220963)
Firefox and Safari actually behave differently with the cross-domain tracking requests being complained about here. So yes, they are different.
And, to be clear, the whole focus of this lawsuit is the plaintiffs are saying that since Google also owns server-side Google Analytics, that incognito mode is inaccurate because "Google is still tracking you".
But the only way for Google to handle that would be if (a) Incognito mode specifically handled GA differently, and that would be a privacy violation, or (b) GA detects you're in Incognito and stops tracking, but all the browser vendors have gone to great lengths to try to make private modes as "unsniffable" as possible, and I view the very effort to sniff for privacy mode as a violation.