News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by divbzero on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:25PM (#33217276)
Yes, the naming of “Incognito” or “Private” browsing could be improved, but the messaging in Chrome is pretty clear.

In addition to:

Now you can browse privately, and other people who use this device won’t see your activity. However, downloads, bookmarks and reading list items will be saved.

It also explains:

Your activity might still be visible to:

• Websites you visit

• Your employer or school

• Your internet service provider

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:29PM (#33217305)
The whole point is that list does not mention "* Google"
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by Spivak on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:37PM (#33217366)
The argument would have to be that Google was using Chrome itself to track you in Incognito because they controlled the browser, otherwise they are just “websites you visit.”
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:57PM (#33217554)
Yes, that is in fact the subject of the lawsuit. From literally the first sentence of the article:

> alleges the Silicon Valley giant misled the public about how much data it collects from users even when they're in its Chrome browser's "Incognito" private browsing mode.

The accusation is that Google is leveraging Chrome to track you even in incognito mode, and it does not give any notice that it is doing so. It warns about the websites you visit, about who owns your local network, and about the ISP, it doesn't warn that Google is still actively tracking you in incognito.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by sangnoir on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:07PM (#33217638)
Can you explain how Google tracks users in incognito mode outside of the websites they visit? If there's no xlient-side Chrome telemetry in incognito mode, why should Google be special-cased when all ad networks can do the same thing that Chrome caveats explicitly?
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:27PM (#33217810)
> 2. Google's Alleged Collection of Plaintiffs’ Data

> Plaintiffs allege that Google collects data from them while they are in private browsing mode "through means that include Google Analytics, Google ‘fingerprinting’ techniques, concurrent Google applications and processes on a consumer's device, and Google's Ad Manager." Id. ¶ 8. According to Plaintiffs, "[m]ore than 70% of all online publishers (websites) use one or more of these Google services."

> Specifically, Plaintiffs allege that, whenever a user, including a user in private browsing mode, visits a website that is running Google Analytics or Google Ad Manager, "Google's software scripts on the website surreptitiously direct the user's browser to send a secret, separate message to Google's servers in California." Id. ¶ 63. This message includes six elements, each of which is discussed below.

[...followed by a lot of detail on what gets tracked...]

https://casetext.com/case/brown-v-google-llc

So there is client-side telemetry which completely de-anonymizes and geolocates you and Google tracks you in incognito mode everywhere that Google Analytics is deployed (~70% of the web). If you use incognito mode and visit porn sites that use Google Analytics, then Google has your complete de-anonymized porn surfing history in their databases. This is not what people are led to believe is happening by the incognito warning message.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by ryeights on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:33PM (#33217854)
> So there is client-side telemetry which completely de-anonymizes and geolocates you

This is not supported by the quote you posted.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:38PM (#33217906)
Yes it is.

I can assert things as well.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by ryeights on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:45PM (#33217969)
> whenever a user, including a user in private browsing mode, visits a website that is running Google Analytics or Google Ad Manager, "Google's software scripts on the website surreptitiously direct the user's browser to send a secret, separate message to Google's servers in California."

Which part of this indicates that the Chrome client contains code giving Google special privileges to track users in incognito mode that other websites don’t have access to?

>Google's software scripts on the website surreptitiously direct the user's browser

is referring to JavaScript. Any other analytics platform could (and does) do the exact same thing.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by Spivak on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:47PM (#33217985)
You claimed something was there, the burden is on you. The allegation is Google, through a combination of data collected from you Incognito browsing session and non-incognito data collected from other Google apps that happen to be running on the same device could be enough to deanonymize you. There is nothing at all alleging they use Chrome. Even the most egregious X-Client-Data header is called out as specifically as not sent in Incognito.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by belltaco on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:54PM (#33218051)
How is it client side telemetry when the exact same things would happen in edge, Firefox, Opera etc. with or without private browsing turned on. All of what you listed has zero to do with Chrome.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by twobitshifter on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:07PM (#33219490)
no, it wouldn’t because firefox and opera block cross site tracking.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by insanitybit on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:56PM (#33218563)
You're misreading or misunderstanding. It's not your fault, the plaintiff is taking great pains not to say "Google Chrome sends this data" and make it unclear.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by BeefWellington on Sunday October 16, 2022 @12:03AM (#33220937)
Ultimately though, it is Chrome sending the data to third party services. Firefox, Safari, et. al, do not permit these cross-site tracking requests.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by insanitybit on Sunday October 16, 2022 @01:31AM (#33221275)
They don't? How do they prevent javascript on a webpage making cross-site requests? That seems impossible.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by grupthink on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:52PM (#33218036)
Summary:

- Google Chrome won't track you in Incognito mode.

- Google Analytics javascript (if added by the webmaster to their site) will track you in any mode.

So the lawsuit is saying, "Google promised us that Incognito would let us browse privately, but Google is still tracking us". To me, they're really muddying the waters here, because clientside Chrome doesn't track you, but, doubleclick on a website, will still track you.

According to this lawsuit, Google's biggest sin is saying "Now you can browse privately..." but when you open Chrome Incognito it clearly says "Your activity might still be visible to websites/employer/ISP"

Kind of a weak case for the plaintiff, and a weak article (engineers joked about the icon? and wanted to change the name? It's definitely a shitty name but this article makes it sound like this a smoking gun.)

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by ipaddr on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:12PM (#33220493)
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by Spivak on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:07PM (#33217634)
Every source about this lawsuit has said that what is meant by this is Google tracking you on Google properties. Unless they outline how the tracking is done it’s pointless.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:27PM (#33217814)
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by Spivak on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:42PM (#33217935)
> through means that include Google Analytics, Google ‘fingerprinting’ techniques, concurrent Google applications and processes on a consumer's device, and Google's Ad Manager…

So not using Chrome. They’re arguing that Google is collecting the usual web tracking and that other Google apps a user might have collect user data.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by shadowgovt on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:09PM (#33217655)
Why the hell would anyone assume that the software vendor who made the browser had no visibility into the use of the browser?
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by JadeNB on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:17PM (#33217723)
> Why the hell would anyone assume that the software vendor who made the browser had no visibility into the use of the browser?

Why the hell wouldn't anyone? I mean, expectations of privacy have eroded, but "you used this company's product, so you must be giving them permission to see everything you do with it" is an argument that, despite many companies' attempts to push it as just common sense, doesn't and shouldn't fly.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by moeris on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:23PM (#33217774)
Because they accepted terms of service that explicitly stated what information can be collected.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by BeefWellington on Sunday October 16, 2022 @12:04AM (#33220943)
That's actually one of the points of the lawsuit: the TOS is unclear and improperly vague.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by shadowgovt on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:11PM (#33218705)
It really is the status quo now. It's in fact surprising when online software doesn't collect telemetry. It's increasingly surprising when offline software on an Internet-connected device doesn't collect telemetry.

VSCode collects telemetry these days.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by JadeNB on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:58PM (#33219039)
> It really is the status quo now. It's in fact surprising when online software doesn't collect telemetry. It's increasingly surprising when offline software on an Internet-connected device doesn't collect telemetry.

I completely agree that it is the status quo, but it shouldn't be. It's unreasonably for people to be surprised by violations of privacy, but I don't think that it's unreasonable for people to expect respect for their privacy.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by shadowgovt on Saturday October 15, 2022 @10:57PM (#33220687)
What "respecting people's privacy" means is very unclear and varies widely from person to person (the best quote I've heard on the topic is something to the effect of "People claim they value their privacy but then they'll give their information to a clipboard-holder in a mall for a Snickers bar... In fact, usually they don't even offer the Snickers.").

In that context, companies do their best to guess what their users want and ask for explicit consent when they can't. In Google's case, once we actually dig down and unravel the complaint that was filed by the Texas AG (https://www.texasattorneygeneral.gov/sites/default/files/ima..., page 55-ish), the claim is Incognito mode doesn't stop targeted advertising based on browsing behavior because the fact that browsing occurred is known by the servers. Well, duh. Of course servers have a history of access to them; expecting them to not is like expecting Amazon to not have a list of people that ordered from it (how are they supposed to ship you what you ordered if they don't know that?).

And in the cases where people have gotten retargeted ads because they went incognito and then logged into Google... how the heck do they figure they're in any sensible way "incognito" when their name and face are at the top of the page they're viewing?

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by patmcc on Saturday October 15, 2022 @04:53PM (#33218536)
I mean, I certainly wouldn't expect/want Microsoft to have a copy of everything I've ever typed into a Word document or Excel spreadsheet.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by shadowgovt on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:13PM (#33218719)
I'm now honestly curious whether Word and Excel still do spell check locally or have delegated to a cloud service.

Cloud Word and Cloud Excel obviously do, but "online services are online" had better not be surprising.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by duskwuff on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:24PM (#33217780)
It shouldn't have to. There's no implication that the list in the Incognito start page is comprehensive. Nor is there anything special about Google in this context -- the fact that they created Chrome doesn't give them any more access to users' data in Incognito mode than any other web analytics firm.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:37PM (#33217895)
The lawsuit alleges that they have a lot more access that any other web analytics firm and that they deanonymize and geolocate you on any web property that uses Google Analytics which enables them to fully track you.

https://casetext.com/case/brown-v-google-llc

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by jsnell on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:56PM (#33218068)
That's a very long document. Can you point to the exact place where they allege that they have "a lot more access that any other web analytics firm"? I tried searching for "access", "geolocat" and "deanonym" and none of the hits describe anything like what you claim is alleged.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by phailhaus on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:04PM (#33218639)
So can Facebook. Should they add that disclaimer on the incognito page too? If you're going to argue that they should call out Google analytics specifically, then you're saying that they should have a comprehensive list of every tracking company out there. But why? They've already made it clear that websites can still track you in Incognito.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by PeterisP on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:25PM (#33217790)
"* Google" is part of "websites you visit" since the tracking asserted here happens only to the extent that you visit Google websites or when websites track you using Google tools.
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:33PM (#33217856)
I'd argue (and this is the point of the lawsuit) that Google being a third party spying on you on 70% of the websites that use Google Analytics is not being adequately disclosed by the warning message in Incognito mode. There is no "oh by the way we de-anonymize and geolocate you and we have your entire porn surfing history in our servers, cheers mate" notice there. The vast majority of internet users would expect that their IP would naturally leak to the porn site they visit, and that seems to be what the warning is about. It doesn't suggest at all to the average user that Google is watching all your activity across all the porn sites you visit--that doesn't become an obvious risk without a lot of specialized knowledge (which most of the readers here probably know, but which 99% of the rest of the world doesn't, which makes that interpretation highly deceptive to the average person).
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by geofft on Saturday October 15, 2022 @03:49PM (#33218000)
Not that I disagree with you about whether the average person realizes it, but it's not just a risk because Google has JavaScript trackers on your porn site. Google could just make a deal with the porn site to access their server logs and correlate data that way. The fact that you disclose information to the sites you visit means they may, in turn, disclose information to whomever else.

As a totally non-web example of this, as of 2017, "Google’s third-party partnerships ... capture approximately 70% of credit and debit card transactions in the United States." https://adwords.googleblog.com/2017/05/powering-ads-and-anal...

When you buy something with MasterCard, in person, with a magstripe or even an old-school carbon-copy imprinter, MasterCard can go give that data to Google.

I think the incognito warning could say "Websites you visit, and anyone those sites share data with" to draw attention to this, but I'm not sure if that's quite enough. I'm leaning towards the argument from this article that "incognito" itself is simply a poor name.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by smoldesu on Saturday October 15, 2022 @05:42PM (#33218927)
"By using Chrome or ChromeOS, you agree to the Google Terms of Service located at https://policies.google.com/terms and these Google Chrome and ChromeOS Additional Terms of Service. These Google Chrome and ChromeOS Additional Terms of Service apply to the executable code version of Chrome and ChromeOS."

Google's TOS (as you can see linked there) seems to apply to both Chrome and Google Analytics. By downloading Chrome and agreeing with their EULA, you already acknowledge that this data is being collected. I don't really get what people are objecting to, here.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by lamontcg on Saturday October 15, 2022 @08:43PM (#33220050)
>99% of people aren't capable of reading the legalese in a TOS agreement, those are all by their very nature inherently deceptive.

And Google's Privacy Policy linked to off of there is one of the subjects of the lawsuit and that it is deceptive.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by ineptech on Sunday October 16, 2022 @12:44AM (#33221084)
What I object to, at least, is that GA could ignore incognito mode users, but doesn't. Yes, other ad networks might still get incognito users' data, but they're not the biggest spy company on Earth, Google is. It's misleading that they collect data on both ends of the HTTP call, and have a feature called "Incognito mode" that only affects one end.

I don't see the difference between that and, say, Coke selling a product called "Diet Coke" that just has regular coke in it. A disclaimer reading "Warning: this is just regular coke," might make it legal but it's still messed up, and I wouldn't blame someone for trying their luck in the courts over it.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by tuukkah on Sunday October 16, 2022 @04:22AM (#33222050)
The TOS can make data collection legal but it doesn't make data collection and implying otherwise legal. Or do they have a clause that says you accept data collection even when they say you're browsing privately?
Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by kalleboo on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:37PM (#33219665)
> Google being a third party spying on you on 70% of the websites that use Google Analytics is not being adequately disclosed by the warning message in Incognito mode

That's something which should be adequately disclosed by the websites you're visiting, which the problem that GDPR tries to solve (and currently fails to solve due to poor guidance and enforcement). Ideally a GDPR "cookie banner" should simply say "This site uses Google Analytics, <other services> to track you across the web. [Allow] [Deny]" instead of the current dark patterns.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by rkagerer on Sunday October 16, 2022 @04:05AM (#33221974)
Who ever would hit Allow?

There is ONE simple answer here that is in the best interest of your user, and that's rip the invasive 3rd party analytics out of your website.

Anything else is failing to put your users first, and eventually those users will go to a competitor who does. There's so much opportunity out there right now for startups that prioritize decency.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by kalleboo on Monday October 17, 2022 @12:40PM (#33236092)
> Who ever would hit Allow?

That's kind of the point of GDPR. But they're not enforcing the main requirements under the law - that the consequences are clear and that choosing to allow or disallow are equally as simple.

Re:Google engineers joked about how incognito mode isn't inc... by bartimus on Sunday October 16, 2022 @03:28AM (#33221840)
But isn't that the same as opening a different browser (Firefox)? Your activity can still be tracked. It's not something that can be prevented within the scope of a private browsing feature.