Re:Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
by karencarits on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:05PM
(#33210257)
Thank you for sharing this. Psychoanalysis is often heavily criticized but it has this nice tendency to be curious and open about things and produce intriguing and interesting thoughts
Re:Psychiatry Wars: a lawsuit that put psychoanalysis on trial
by projektfu on Saturday October 15, 2022 @07:20AM
(#33213813)
That doesn't really match my experience of depression unless you somehow redefine all those terms to mean something else.
It's hard to see where the libido is in someone who doesn't want to get out of bed, even to eat. Or in the case from the article, someone who feels like a piece of wood, and who paces the hospital like a Roomba.
All effects of drugs are effects and they become side effects when they are undesirable. You used to be able to buy the same medication as either a decongestant and an appetite suppressant. In either case, the other effect is a side effect.
On the other hand, if you took an antacid every day for your depression, and had no effect on it, for years, you might consider that it didn't work. However, the analysts didn't think that was possible to say about analysis.
“Recently the thought occurred to me that we have antidepressants back-to-front, as it were. The listed side-effects of these drugs (mostly SSRI’s) is really the main action, and the advertised effect is the real side effect.
In other words antidepressants reduce anxiety and depression as a side effect of reducing libido – in the more inclusive sense of ‘life force’. Perhaps the relief of depression occurs because anxiety and depression are symptoms of libido or life energy hitting up against an obstacle or difficulty either in the internal or external world. This obstruction interferes with the ability of libido to express itself. Reduce libido and the unpleasant effects (depression and anxiety) of libido encountering an “obstruction” are correspondingly also reduced.”
https://aucklandpsychotherapy.co.nz/antidepressants/