News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ajross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:02PM (#33207530)
> The path to 100% green energy without coercing people and making decisions that could backfire, is to upgrade the energy grid to the point that electricity is dirt cheap

How does installing the most expensive generator in the country not work directly against that principle? Per a quick check on Wikipedia, it looks like the ~1.2GW Vogtle 3/4 is going to cost $28.5B, which is about eighteen times what an equivalent windfarm (at $1.3M/MW) would cost to install. And that's just counting construction costs, operating costs are even more skewed against nuclear.

Sorry, but to be blunt: nuclear is snake oil being marketed to right-leaning tech bros who think wind and solar are something only granola munching hippies should love. It doesn't work on a balance sheet. And frankly it's not remotely close.

If you genuinely care about the goals you espoused, you need to get off then nuclear horse. Once we've filled the channel with actually cheap renewables, it's time to go back and cover the remaining 2-5% or whatever with expensive stuff. Not now.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ufmace on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:26PM (#33207789)
The nuclear plant can be relied upon to produce its full rated 1.2GW 24/7/365 absent maintenance periods scheduled well in advance.

Wind power etc will produce its rated power only when it feels like it with no warning or predictability. To get actual continuous reliable power you need either massive grid-scale storage that nobody's even seriously proposed constructing, or massive over-capacity distributed over a continent-sized area with enough grid capacity to transfer sufficient power from areas with access to areas with shortages, which we also don't have and don't seem to have seriously proposed constructing. Probably both actually.

IMO there's no question that we've gotta get out metaphorical shit together and build lots more nuclear faster if we ever want to actually decrease carbon emissions in our lifetime.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ajross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:27PM (#33207805)
Can you try to make that argument with price numbers and not rhetoric? I used to think like you did. Then I started looking up quantitative stuff. Please do the same.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by mattwest on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:31PM (#33207845)
How about you provide some of this "quantitative stuff" you've found then.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ajross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:41PM (#33207955)
I literally did, check upthread. What's happened is that replies are choosing to ignore those numbers, thus my pleading that you look them up yourself since you won't read what I provide.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ufmace on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:34PM (#33208506)
My argument is not really about price, but instead capability.

I'm not saying that everything is just great with nuclear now - my impression is that it's vastly overpriced due to excessive regulation and red tape and being over-cautious. Part of my argument is that one of the things we need to do is cut way back on all that stuff to make more plants faster and for less money than we currently spend on them.

If you total up all of the deaths from all nuclear power incidents that have ever happened, including Chernobyl, the total is orders of magnitude less than what the Global Warming people tell us is going to happen if we keep pumping out CO2. We know how to build the plants now, we know we need to get CO2 emissions down now, so let's do it.

Bottom line IMO, either A) the Global Warming people are full of shit and they know it or B) we absolutely must get serious about nuclear power now, evaluating the cost both in dollars and lives against what unchecked CO2 emissions will do. We should be building them fast and cheap and cutting corners - I don't want people to die in nuclear accidents, but if we don't have anybody dying in accidents, then we're probably not building them fast enough. Kind of like how Elon Musk said about his rockets, if you're not failing, then you're not moving fast enough. We've got to get it done yesterday, waiting on grid-scale storage and transport improvements won't be fast enough.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Schroedingersat on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:56PM (#33210523)
> The nuclear plant can be relied upon to produce its full rated 1.2GW 24/7/365 absent maintenance periods scheduled well in advance.

Yes. That is exactly what is happening in france.

If you are willing to spend $23000/kW you can get a wholly renewable + storage system with 5 or 6 9s of uptime in months rather than decades vs. best case of 93% for nuclear. You'll also get 10kW net or so of variable power on top of your guaranteed 1kW.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by proc0 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:18PM (#33207702)
It mainly is the output, and we've had nuclear tech for decades. We could have built enough to go 100% green already and I don't think at the moment we have the necessary tech for wind and solar to satisfy everything going electric, let alone the current consumption. If wind and solar were cheap and reliable, people would have switched already.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by endisneigh on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:05PM (#33207567)
Why do you believe people who like nuclear are right leaning?
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by mh7 on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:09PM (#33207600)
>equivalent windfarm (at $1.3M/MW)

Does that include storage costs?

Because a windfarm alone cannot replace a nuclear power plant no matter how cheaper or how much electricity the windturbines generate because on days without wind they generate zero Wh.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ajross on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:25PM (#33207780)
That's simply not true, because wind output never goes to zero across the whole grid. Even assuming the pessimal case[1], wind needs to drop below 5.5% (1/18th) of its average capacity before nuclear even reaches break-even!

What fraction of the time is whole-grid-amortized wind capacity running at 5% of average? Has that ever even happened? I don't have numbers, but I'm willing to bet that this has never actually happened.

What you've done is try to counter my overwhelming quantitative argument with a qualitative hedge ("but storage"). Please, (please!) look up the numbers here.

Nuclear is a borderline scandal. If it was some other federal subsidy of an industry you disliked, you'd almost certainly call it fraud.

[1] i.e. no use of gas peaker plants, legacy nuclear, solar, pumped hydro, batteries, etc... Literally trying to run the whole grid on wind and wind alone.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by infamia on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:59PM (#33208170)
How do you explain the grid meltdowns in recent years in areas that have tilted their output towards renewables? California and Europe have had some pretty epic grid destabilizations recently, and all the analysis I've looked at points squarely at the unreliability of renewables. Base load matters, we have seen this time and again. Stitching together a bazaar of unreliable renewables with overlapping failure modes and claiming it is just as good as traditional base load providers has been proven false thus far. Either it can't be done with our current tech, or we don't know how to do it (and we should not try until we are confident we can make it work well).
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ajross on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:31PM (#33208471)
I'm not sure I see the evidence you're invoking? "Grid meltdowns" are quite rare, actually, and on the whole electrical infrastructure has been getting more reliable over time, not less.

And in any case the two biggest "meltdown" events in recent history in the USA were in... Texas, and had to do with weather effects on fossil fuel generators.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by pfdietz on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:28PM (#33210713)
Also weather effects on a nuclear plant there.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by infamia on Friday October 14, 2022 @11:26PM (#33211437)
California has had rolling outages for years and in 2020 they had a blackout that impacted hundreds of thousands of residents during a heatwave. The failure occurred a bit after dusk when solar stopped producing and other states didn't have as much power to send to California to make up he difference. All the information is in the link below. California's energy policy looks a lot like Germany's which is to heavily weight your grid towards renewables, call yourself green, and then prey your neighbors produce enough energy to keep your grid stable. All the information is in the link below. The governor of California enacted a state of emergency concerning power shortages and narrowly averted another grid failure last month, so I wouldn't say that their reliability is anywhere close to acceptable.

https://www.sandiegouniontribune.com/business/story/2020-10-...

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by matwood on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:13PM (#33207644)
But you have to factor in land usage, wind variability and general location challenges of wind. I think wind is great where it makes sense, but I'm not sure it plus solar alone will get us over the hump and completely off fossil fuels.

https://medium.com/@alkidel/the-land-footprint-of-solar-and-...

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:16PM (#33207678)
The cost already factors all those in.

Land usage or energy density or amount of materials used are all red herrings.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by mattwest on Friday October 14, 2022 @03:35PM (#33207884)
Just because you say they are red herrings doesn't make it so. Eventually you will need to reconcile with the laws of physics.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @04:38PM (#33208549)
Which law of physics are you talking about here?

I sometimes see mention "laws of physics" as a reasons renewables won't work, but nobody has ever, literally ever, been able to point to the law. Or run the numbers on why renewables would be be feasible for supplying all our power and even an order of magnitude more than we currently consume.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by mattwest on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:16PM (#33208898)
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:27PM (#33208996)
That doesn't answer the question.

Since you say "laws of physics" prevent renewables from supplying out energy. I call bullshit.

Name the law.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by mattwest on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:33PM (#33209063)
Oh it certainly does. Any honestly, if you have such strong opinions on energy production and haven't read Smil's work, then all of this back and forth makes a lot more sense.
Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by epistasis on Friday October 14, 2022 @08:04PM (#33210251)
And yet you still can't articulate a single "law of physics" that's going to be violated.

So, I maintain that this is 100% BS, just an argument to authority. If there is an argument in hat book, do you understand enough to give a sketch? Or point to the principle?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by ben_w on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:48PM (#33209220)
Land use, you're saying land use is not a red herring?

Replace all energy and not just what is already electrified, and also boost global energy use to the per-capita rate of Qatar (I think the highest in the world at about 2.5 times the average of the USA), and also boost world population to 10 billion, you can still do this 30 times over with PV placed slightly worse than if it was randomly scattered.

There's a lot of land on this planet of ours.

That's why land use is a red herring.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Schroedingersat on Saturday October 15, 2022 @02:50AM (#33212430)
Solar produces 20W/m^2 net in mid winter at ~55 degrees north. LCOE at these latitudes is lower than nuclear and dropping. 99% of people live closer to the equator than this, and the majority of the remainder have enough hydro or wind/geothermal for a 100% renewable mix.

In famously sunny washington state a current technology solar storage system with the same net capacity factor as US nuclear and the same number of days where >0 backup is needed as European nuclear for less than what Vogtle cost per watt. Add wind and this goes down dramatically. Allow the builder to sit on their thumbs for a decade before starting and they'd open before a new nuclear build while providing 100% capacity and a quarter of the cost using batteries made of abundant materials and solar panels made with the silver and copper that came out of existing uranium mines.

The average american has 200-400m^2 dedicated to parking their car. Worldwide average per capita primary energy is 2kW. Even at 20W/m^2 this provides enough. Even wind at 5W/m^2 can produce enough final energy in that much area (with the side benefit of not really affecting other uses).

Wind is much better than solar economically at high latitudes and is slightly anti-correlated with solar.

There are terawatts of tidal sites available in high latitude coastal areas and the LCOE is already lower than nuclear with a much better learning rate and only a few hundred MW of preexisting capacity.

What law of physics contradicts this?

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Schroedingersat on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:17AM (#33211708)
At 60W net per m^2 US average primary energy can be served in 250m^2 per capita or less than the per capita paved car parking space.

The inkai uranium mine is one of the largest mines in the world. It spans about 760km^2 of desert. At that latitude current generation solar has about 16% capacity factor of 230W/m^2. There are much denser uranium reserves, but if land use being significantly low than solar is your overriding concern then there's only a few decades worth of reserves available for use in PWRs.

A solar project there would produce about 25GW net.

The uranium mined produces 50GW gross at typical burnup. Mining, transport, enrichment, and post burn lifecycle consume ~10-20% of this.

The exclusion zones for those reactors would be roughly another 170km^2 so the nuclear is only ~30% better.

Add wind turbines at 10W/m^2 and do it not in the arctic and the renewables win handily by net output. You can also use all of that land for other things as well without getting radon poisoning or being shot by armed guards. Modern multi megawatt wind turbines don't meaningfully use land as being able to see two or three turbines off in the distance doesn't really prevent you from doing most things.

As to variability, the people of france would like a word. Less facetiously you should consider cost to meet a minimum power target. With the $23k per kw of Vogtle, hitting higher reliability than any nuclear reactor is trivial -- you also get 10 or so kW of variable power.

Re:The first Gen III+ Nuclear plant begins fuel loading by Schroedingersat on Friday October 14, 2022 @09:02PM (#33210562)
I'd argue that now is the time.

The time to spend $1 trillion on renewables to cover 90% of the load and another $1 trillion on reduction such as electrified rail, active transit infrastructure, insulation, and industrial efficiency and another $1 trillion on nuclear + tidal + mmwave geothermal + whatever other technologies work in principle but not in practice.

But if you are going to cut one because we would rather spend it on military it should be the least effective one.