Re:Paul Krugman: How I work
by Prrometheus on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @04:43AM
(#332064)
He was awarded the prize for his academic work, not his shilling for the Democratic Party.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Paul Krugman: How I work
by DanielBMarkham on Tuesday October 14, 2008 @06:43AM
(#332120)
It's a prize. A prize in the field of economics, which is hardly physics. Unless there is some empirical process for selection and award, it's just the result of a committee's opinions.
If we can agree on that, certainly you can see that the door is open for the members of the committee to be swayed by lots of things, including his political work/views. To act otherwise is to try to turn respected scientists into some sort of mechanistic non-humans. People are influenced by all sorts of things, at the conscious and unconscious levels.
I have no idea what part of my statement is controversial. Yet it seems to just drive some people nuts.
As far as I can tell from the Wikipedia page, there is no difference in the selection processes for the physics and economics prizes... All prizes are just the result of a committee's (and nominators', and screeners') opinions. In this respect, they are all equally valid.
For what it's worth, though, the committee members are selected by Norwegian/Swedish institutions, which are perhaps less likely to be swayed by political actions in the U.S.