News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by Loic on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:15AM (#33203780)
For people interested in random selection of representatives: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sortition
Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by thechao on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:24AM (#33203904)
The research I've seen (slight) is that a random person is, on average, a more competent statesman than the average politician. (This is a result of the self-selection bias in people choosing a political career.)

The major downside is a lack of accountability; however, at least in large parts of the US, factionalism & gerrymandering have almost completely removed accountability, so we're not really losing anything.

Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by rocqua on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:46AM (#33204240)
Links to the research?
Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by Supermancho on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:08PM (#33205402)
I don't know if this helps: https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344163235_Sortition...

MP means Member of Parliament (or equivalent representative of a democratic government). Belgium has been a hot-spot for this kind of initiative.

Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by pdabbadabba on Friday October 14, 2022 @10:50AM (#33204301)
Can you point us to any of that research? I'd be very interested to see how they managed to measure people's competence to serve as government officials. I'm frankly skeptical that can be done in a useful way.
Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by barry-cotter on Friday October 14, 2022 @07:23PM (#33209970)
> The research I've seen (slight) is that a random person is, on average, a more competent statesman than the average politician. (This is a result of the self-selection bias in people choosing a political career.)

This seems extremely unlikely just by virtue of the fact that the average person has an IQ of 100 and the average MP doesn’t. Practically guaranteed to be above 115. There are very large differences in education. The median voter in the US is over 50 and never went to, never mind graduate from, college.

Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by eru on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:15AM (#33211697)
Yes.

For that reason, instead of picking people directly at random, pick ballots at random to fill up parliament.

In theory, you could pick random votes first, and then ask them about their choice. But there's all kinds of targeted influence possible at that stage. So let voters make their choice first, and then pick randomly.

You'd need some kind of resolution mechanism for when multiple random ballots have the same candidate on them. Eg give the guys vote in parliament a higher weight, or have people write down multiple candidates in order, or just pick another random vote etc. (Some resolution mechanisms might work better than others. I don't know.)

Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by toss1 on Friday October 14, 2022 @12:20PM (#33205544)
YES!

I've long thought that once a person attains a certain level of success, roughly including college degree, certain military rank, managerial position of certain scope at medium-large company, etc., they should be subject to random political service in state or federal legislature or executive branches. Perhaps after one term, they can stand for re-election for maximum of two terms, 10 years max, to take advantage of experience gained. Pay should be greater of a set level or 110% of their max earnings in previous 5yrs (so service is not punitive).

There would of course be some random evil and grifters, but their concentration and ability to embed for life would be very limited.

How we get from constitutional structure to there is another question.

Re:FDIC's Position on the Role of Vacation Policy as an Inte... by eru on Saturday October 15, 2022 @12:19AM (#33211715)
I'm all in favour of sortition, but I don't think it's a good idea to force people to serve.

Just pick randomly from all willing candidates to fill up parliament. Or even better: still have elections were people can vote for willing candidates, but instead of picking the winner by some kind of majority or proportionality scheme, you pick n ballots at random to fill up the n seats in parliament.

(You can come up with your favourite scheme to handle the case when a single candidate gets multiple votes for her selected. Eg give her extra weight in decisions?)

I would suggest using sortition only for instances where the law of large numbers helps you. Eg for filling up a parliament with a few hundred representatives, but not for picking a single president.