Re:The Dangerous Populist Science of Yuval Noah Harari
by fedeb95 on Friday October 14, 2022 @02:15AM
(#33200183)
Please sustain your claim that there isn't science into the study of human evolution. Some rigor is indeed possible, it's pretty easy to say there isn't looking from the outside. Sure you can't apply fancy statistics or mathematical proof. But just to sustain that by not doing it you don't have nothing to gain from a study more serious that Harari's is a big claim that needs justification. Also your claim about Harari's conjecture being somehow relevant because Putin is a dictator is just meaningless.
A note: I find it disturbing that an historian is so much paid and supported by various questionable people. The politicisation might be just there. Why is he the only historian paid that much, while at the same time providing a view of history no other historian agrees to (in serious publications)?
Re:The Dangerous Populist Science of Yuval Noah Harari
by MrsPeaches on Friday October 14, 2022 @05:09AM
(#33201269)
I found sapiens to be a frustrating read with endless talking-out-of-your-arse speculation that I would expect from an undergrad with delusions of grandeur.
I generally recommend this book as a much better survey of the history of humanity: https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/408204.Ideas
It is a speculation, ok. And right now, we are on the brink of a nuclear war, because of one man’s insecurities. So to suggest that our non-linear evolution afforded us means of mass and self-destruction, but no commensurable means of self-control is not such a wild conjecture. And anyway, even we want to look into science of it, there is really no much science to look at. Because when it comes to history of humanity there is a sample of one and fundamental irreproducibility. As you step away from pure biology towards any field that studies human as a species or human societies, it is ridden with unsustained claims and politicization.
It reminds me of Taleb’s work on black swan and skin in the game. Sure, to some devoted followers now everything is a black swan and trump and putin are the champions. But you don’t need to subscribe to his entire philosophy to agree that he brings up many good points, that might have been hidden otherwise.