News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Go: Redefining For Loop Variable Semantics by foldr on Thursday October 13, 2022 @09:06AM (#33190445)
>Your comment just confirms that, as I said, it does more than that – it also adds a reference to the object.

It simply evaluates to the address of the object, just as it does in C. if you think the & operator is doing something in addition to this, I think that must just be based on a misunderstanding.

I am not quite sure what you mean by 'adding a reference' to the object.

Let's take this function:

    func foo() *int {
      var x int
      return &x
    }
All that happens is the following:

- An integer is allocated (and initialized to zero).

- The address of this integer is returned.

If we dig into the implementation, we'll see that the integer is allocated on the heap. As far as Go's language semantics are concerned, everything is allocated on the heap and left to the GC to clean up.

As an implementation detail, values that provably don't outlive their containing functions are (sometimes) stack allocated. As x outlives its containing function, it won't be stack allocated. That's it. There is no special operation of 'adding a reference' or 'extending a lifetime'. Nor does the compiler even analyze lifetimes except for the purposes of applying an optional optimisation which has no effect on the semantics of the program. If you turned this optimisation off (which you totally could) then there'd be no need for the compiler to worry about x's lifetime at all.

Re:Go: Redefining For Loop Variable Semantics by quietbritishjim on Thursday October 13, 2022 @12:31PM (#33193272)
> All that happens is the following:

> - An integer is allocated (and initialized to zero).

> - The address of this integer is returned.

That is not all that happens, at least down at the C/assembler level.

Let me illustrate what I mean. Consider this function, which also does both of these things (cobbled together from Google searches so please excuse incorrect syntax):

    func foo() uintptr{
      var x int
      return uintptr(unsafe.Pointer(&x))
    }
All that function does is allocate an integer (and initialise to zero) and return the address of that integer. Exactly the same as your function, right? Except it's obviously not - it doesn't extend the lifetime of the integer variable.

So why not? The GC somehow knows to ignore the number returned from my function, even though, under the hood, it's still stored in a register or stack location or whatever in exactly the same way as the address returned from your function. So how does the GC know to ignore it? Is that number somehow marked in a way that says "GC, when you're scanning memory looking for address-like numbers, don't pay attention to this one"? No. It doesn't look at the number in the first place because it hasn't been told to look at it.

In contrast, in your example, the memory address is not just returned from the function (in the C sense that it's put in a register for the caller to receive). It, additionally, somehow registers that memory address with the GC to let it know that there's another reference to that variable location. That is the extra thing that your function does that mine doesn't. And that magic happens (or at least starts) at the moment you use the & operator.

Re:Go: Redefining For Loop Variable Semantics by foldr on Friday October 14, 2022 @06:30AM (#33201711)
Yes, Go has a precise (i.e. non-conservative) garbage collector. It seems odd to me to think about that as some kind of special feature of the & operator. It's certainly not a surprising feature. Knowing that Go has a precise GC, one certainly expects the GC to know that the value of &x references x. If it didn't that would be a major bug.