News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by arethuza on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:01AM (#3318820)
Do you think anyone has a copy of SAP at home that they hack on in their own time for their own pleasure? I suspect not...

Anyway, I have to repeat my favourite quote about SAP from a Slashdot discussion:

"SAP is how Lucifer interacts with our world."

http://yro.slashdot.org/story/09/05/28/2143219/Allegedly-Rig...

Which I think sums it up nicely.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by Maro on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:27AM (#3319155)
My father has been a SAP consultant for about 20 years. I remember when I was a kid, he told me about this guy at his work who took SAP home and hacked on it at home in all his free-time (he was single). Unlike most SAP consultants who are only qualified for one or two SAP modules, this guy got to wizard-status in all of them. My father always said this guy got so good he had a demi-god like status at the company and was making big bucks.

So, SAP is certainly not sexy, but if you can take the pain and get good at it, you'll make big bucks.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:54AM (#3319235)
I think this is definitely traditionally true, and there are people making big bucks in the SAP space - contract rates can be high for geniuses.

What's changing is that open standards mean that the wider tech community can integrate into SAP. This both commoditises the business, drives rates down and makes it more accessible. I suspect that in 10 years time we will see a very different Enterprise IT market.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:23AM (#3319139)
I love the comments but this is exactly the stuff I was talking about in this article. I'd love to show the wider tech audience a bit more about SAP and how it works. Guess that can be my project for 2012.

1) Yes, you can download a trial version as Zalthor points out. I'm trying to work with SAP to make this more open and easy to do. It's important.

2) SAP customers vary from 1 employee (SAP BusinessOne) to 250,000+ employees (SAP ERP). But from a download perspective the interesting stuff is coming with Gateway and the Unwired Platform. With those tools - the server components of which will be available in the cloud - you can build Edge/Web Apps and Mobile apps using whatever tech you want. Ruby on Rails, iPhone, whatever. That's the sort of open integration which I hope will interest this audience, not downloading copies of SAP ERP for home.

3) Couldn't agree more, don't block social media at work. I wouldn't work for a company that did. By the way, SAP encourage social media and have 50k+ employees. But some organizations are stuck in the dark ages.

4) Streamworks integration is coming for the mainstream soon. It will be PaaS, integrated with the new Java environment and developer toolkit and supports open integration. It's had a bad press so far. Hopefully this will help.

Hope this helps.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @09:22AM (#3319322)
I think you might be somewhat lonely in this good will campaign for SAP.

In my decade-long career as a lawyer for customers who buy enterprise IT, the only company that I consider more obnoxious across the table than SAP is Oracle. If you are doing business with these companies, you pretty much deserve what you get. I've seen a few CIOs lose their jobs when ERP falls apart (it almost always does, for a variety of reasons).

I'm not saying there isn't a bunch of useful technology, but these aren't technology companies – they're sales organizations, and that side of the business is not pretty. I can't understand why anyone does business with obnoxious sales organizations like these in 2011.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by AndyNemmity on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:21AM (#3319765)
"it almost always does, for a variety of reasons"

No, it doesn't. I understand that's a meme because it does happen, but "almost always" isn't just something you add to the conversation to try to make your point stronger.

SAP ERP systems fill a purpose, and they do so quite well.

There are definitely instances where a change to your ERP system is so large that it's under budgeted, or the consultants hired aren't any good, but ERP is a value proposition provided you don't f it up.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:47AM (#3319872)
It might be anecdotal, but it isn't just a talking point. I told you – I've done these deals for a living for more than 10 years. It's about the difference between what was promised by the sales team, and what was delivered, and who's left holding the bag.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by AndyNemmity on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:51AM (#3319885)
I don't disagree that the sales team promises a lot more than is even possible very often.

But almost all ERP systems fail? I still cannot get behind this. You're saying in 10 years the vast majority of deals you've done with ERP have failed?

If that's really true, perhaps you should do something differently. I work with many successful ERP systems. I actually haven't worked with any failures, although of course I'm aware of them because of people like you who tell me.

I trust your experience, but at the same time, it's very different than my own.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @12:19PM (#3319979)
Failure is a very broad spectrum. Failed to deliver as promised is more accurate. Sometimes with spectacular results.

There's very little I can do to help, since ERP vendors are very risk averse. I can assure you that by the time you own a license, they've booked the revenue and moved on to the next sale. If anyone gets stuck holding the bag other than the customer, it's the consultant doing the implementation. I usually advise clients not to buy from these (and other) vendors, unless they accept the risks. They're free to self-insure against it.

As a matter of course, the CIO gets someone's foot up his ass for a year or two and is lucky to keep his/her job. Budgets are blown. Change orders flood in. Unforeseen costs. Missed deadlines. Contract remedies are weak because no one had the stomach to fight for them when they were on the table. Finger pointing everywhere. And so the world turns...

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @07:11PM (#3326868)
I think what you are saying can be true, depending on the sales exec. What can also be true is they are looking to build a long term relationship. It varies from person to person unfortunately.

What you describe is a classic large Systems Implementor problem, and that can be very true. The A-team sold the project and the B-team deliver it. They screw up the requirements gathering and the implementation. I've seen it happen many times.

Sometimes the product is to blame because it doesn't work as promised. Most of the time the consulting organisation didn't know the product well enough and made a mess of it. Totally agree on your contract point. Agree contracts, terms and conditions up front. Pay attention and take time.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:12AM (#3329101)
Indeed, as classic a pattern as you can find in contracts. Most of the time, when a big company dangles a big contract, the suppliers fall in line and agree to objective success criteria, a reasonable acceptance procedure, and reasonable operating parameters with meaningful remedies.

The problem with ERP is institutionalized – the licensors have set themselves up to absorb almost no risk of project failure. The big consultants are also masters of shifting risk back to the client. That leaves the client to deal with a middle tier of consultants that is a mixed bag of capabilities, capitalization, etc.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by chris_dcosta on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @04:02AM (#3323063)
My experience too.

The sad thing is that SAP started with all the right intentions, one model fits all - but they messed up when they bowed to the demands of ignorant IT managers and opened the pandoras box of custom built software.

The real irony is that SAP started because custom built software was the problem, and SAP's founders knew - like anyone with a bit of intelligence - that almost all companies run the same business processes.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @07:08PM (#3326851)
Yes I am very lonely here, but it's interesting. I'd love to bring the tech and enterprise it crowds together and learn that we're really not that different.

Oracle is much worse from a sales/license perspective and a lot of my SAP customers are frustrated with them. Most of my customers have excellent relationships with their SAP account team.

On the ERP falling apart point - sorry but that's just not born out by fact. Project failures and system failures happen and most of the time that's caused by either using the wrong product, or by bad consulting - or poor support. I've never encountered a SAP ERP that has fallen apart.

SAP is a company with two CEOs - one sales and one technical, and they are definitely half a technology company. I really recommend you take a look at the tech they are producing. Of course they have to sell and market it - they have to turn a profit from all the R&D. Shame you have had a bad experience with the sales community.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Thursday December 08, 2011 @09:17AM (#3329113)
To be clear, I don't consider it a "bad experience". It's my job to deal with the guys across the table. Let me play out for you every ERP negotiation ever:

Me: If the system fails to perform to spec within the anticipated implementation timeframe, we get our money back, or at least get to hold back part of the fee until you get it right.

ERP Licensor Finance Guy: We can't do that, for revenue recognition reasons.

Me: Why should my client care about your accounting? My client has a business to run. What happens when you're paid, and we have a box of nuts and bolts to show for millions of sunk dollars?

ERP Implementor Operations Guy: We've never had a problem in the entire history of our company. We're good guys. Trust us.

ERP Licensor Finance Guy: If you don't sign within a week, our discount comes off the table.

Me: Here we go again.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by arethuza on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:29AM (#3319791)
Don't you think that as a lawyer you are more likely to be involved in cases where ERP project don't go well? ERP projects are difficult so it's hardly surprising that some go off the rails.

There are many, probably thousands, of companies out there who are using large ERP systems pretty effectively - of course, you generally don't hear much about those.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @01:29PM (#3320293)
No, I only negotiate the deal. Follow up is generally limited to answering questions, sending notice letters, change orders, etc.

You don't hear anything about them (except maybe a press release that no one reads) because they're always highly confidential. If my client has a claim, they use Unfrozen Caveman Lawyer.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by absconditus on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @10:40AM (#3319625)
What are the other options exactly?
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:02AM (#3319693)
For what? Glueing crummy old legacy systems together? Managing a workforce? GL? Performance metrics?

Part of the problem is monolithic, kitchen-sink software. Most people are basically using SAP/Peoplesoft as a development framework anyway – playing into more vendor lock-in. It's like the Lotus Notes of the aughts.

There are tons of targeted solutions that can play nice with intelligent use of modern, open data interchange protocols.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by thechut on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:43AM (#3319850)
I'm currently taking a class in managing SAP ERP systems, and noticed how really bad it is. The user interface for end users is absolutely abysmal. Like some other people here have pointed out it doesn't scale very well.

There are a couple open source ERP products, Compiere which is technically open source but uses a service model. However, the most interesting open source ERP is by far Openbravo. If you're question about other options was serious, you should look into using Openbravo: http://www.openbravo.com/about-us/

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @07:03PM (#3326832)
It's true that SAP ERP could really do with a better interface (and it does, for the consumer end of the market by the way). But SAP ERP is bought by people who enjoy the business benefit (increased revenue, decreased cost) rather than by the users - that's life.

To say that SAP ERP doesn't scale on the other hand is a bit nuts. It scales easily to the biggest companies in the world. Apple iTunes Store sales billing runs on SAP.

I've not spent a lot of time looking at open source ERP in the context of large enterprise. I'd be interested in a serious comparison of the contenders and their UX, ability to scale to many countries/currencies/languages and their ROI and supportability and extensibility.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sunchild on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @12:26PM (#3320008)
OpenBravo's demo video is a lesson in what not to do.

When I open a software demo video, I want over-the-shoulder or screencast-style video of the software in action. I do not want the Comic Book Guy narrating Wikipedia's definition of 'agility'.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by zalthor on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @12:50PM (#3320114)
Open ERP is quite interesting. (http://www.openerp.com/)
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by MatthewPhillips on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:38AM (#3319185)
Very well written article. My problem with SAP is simple. I have no idea what they actually do. None. They do a terrible job marketing their products to people who would actually use them (as opposed to the people responsible for choose which products in this category get purchased). The only product of SAP's that I know anything about is Crystal Reports, and only because it ships with Visual Studio.

For example, here's the one-liner about BusinessOne that you pointed out:

A SINGLE INTEGRATED BUSINESS MANAGEMENT APPLICATION FOR SMALL BUSINESSES

^^ I get nothing from that. The details section on their website don't do much better. I fear this is not accidental; the pitch is just enough to get you on the phone with one of their sales people.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by arethuza on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @09:29AM (#3319352)
"I have no idea what they actually do"

For ERP applications (which SAP is arguably most famous for) you are basically getting all of the "standard" features that you require to run a business in one highly integrated (and usually highly modular) package. This will include, at a very basic level:

- Accounting (general ledger, fixed assets, accounts receivable, accounts payable, budgeting, consolidation, maybe treasury)

- HR

- Payroll

- Supply chain/warehouse

- Manufacturing (processes, bill of materials etc.)

- CRM

- Interfaces (including web portals, EDI, perhaps direct links to manufacturing systems)

- Many many others...

What arguably makes this all rather complex is providing all of this functionality in a way that can work across a large multi-national organisation - for example, the accounting and tax rules in different countries can be very different. Even the basic technical challenges of getting a Tier-1 ERP working in a global company are non-trivial.

Factor that these things are highly customisable and you can perhaps see why they have to be so complex.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by sime on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:55AM (#3319238)
Yep,

For example. I read the article and think ok, this SAP HANA in-memory technology sounds interesting. I google it, go to their website and see a two minute video that supposedly explains it.

I think cool I'll watch that to get an overview of what it's all about. I watch the first twenty seconds after which I'm still actually eager to learn more. But then the video stops and they put an overlay telling me I need to register to continue watching the video. WTF!

So I still have not much idea of what it is and frankly no further inclination to find out.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by johnappleby on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:51AM (#3319230)
I hear you. SAP suck at that stuff. The problem with SAP is it's so complicated, you can do anything you like. And so, it becomes hard to explain. Not sure what the solution to that is.

SAP has a new CMO, Jonathan Becher, who I hope will bring some improvements to this stuff. Marketing is supposed to be about making stuff easier to buy - and as you rightly point out, SAP aren't always that good at that, especially to a casual observer.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by cromulent on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @10:39AM (#3319621)
>> a copy of SAP at home

This is a good example of one thing SAP are doing poorly.

An equivalent of this is "A copy of Microsoft at home". I hear even SAP consultants speaking like this, which shows their communication is not getting across properly.

SAP is the company. They have many products. Each one can be installed separately. Some are available as demos or learning products.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by davidmathers on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @12:02PM (#3319929)
The equivalent is actually "A copy of Oracle at home." SAP started with just the ERP product.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by zalthor on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:40AM (#3318916)
You can get a trial version of SAP here > http://www.sdn.sap.com/irj/sdn/go/portal/prtroot/docs/webcon...

But the problem is that its not meant to be run at home. I'm guessing most contracts for SAP run into the 10s of millions and I don't think they intend to give that up quite easily. Though there are a few companies (for example: Secude) that pretty much sit around and build hacks on SAP applications, but that too involves a lot of paperwork with SAP and almost always ends up with SAP buying out those companies.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by smiler on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:13AM (#3319726)
I tried to download this trial - it 404s
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by paganel on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:15AM (#3318851)
Also, FB would get a lot more users/visits if lots of major enterprises wouldn't block access to it so that their employees could spend more time in SAP and not on FB (it happened at my wife's job, a medium to large European oil company).
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by dextorious on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:12AM (#3319106)
"""Do you think anyone has a copy of SAP at home that they hack on in their own time for their own pleasure? I suspect not..."""

And what does this has to do with anything? Do you have a copy of the Google search engine to run at home? (the real one, not a plain text indexer like Google desktop).

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by dvanduzer on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:45AM (#3319209)
Hack on Solr. Dabble with the NLTK. Implement a couple of the algorithms in the Collective Intelligence O'Reilly book. There're plenty of interesting opportunities for the hobbyist in the world of information retrieval.

Neither Facebook nor SAP are solving particularly interesting problems. Is it useful to facilitate meaningful human interactions? Yes. Is it valuable to glean insights about the operational structure of a business? Certainly.

Both of these companies do something like this, but emphasizing the wrong aspects of scalability. TechCrunch is still boring, but SAP isn't interesting.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by AndyNemmity on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @11:27AM (#3319784)
"Neither Facebook nor SAP are solving particularly interesting problems."

Then you have no perspective of the problems SAP is solving.

SAP is solving tons of big data problems with a variety of interesting data modeling and analysis.

These are wildly interesting problems. They are as interesting in a small startup environment as they are in a large company.

There seems to be this real us versus them attitude with people who identify with startups.

People that work in SAP are no different than startups. Many people that work at SAP come from startups.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by dvanduzer on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @07:27PM (#3321839)
I've no doubt the engineers at Facebook and SAP find plenty of interesting problems to fill their day. The macroscopic problems that both companies are solving in their respective niches are... What?

It's not a startup versus enterprise thing. It's (partially) a question of whether the interesting propellerhead problems are in aid of an interesting larger goal.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by msellout on Wednesday December 07, 2011 @03:03PM (#3325648)
The macroscopic problem that SAP works on is collaboration within large organizations. How to make processes more efficient while reducing bureaucracy. I'm not saying they're doing a good job of it, but that's the task. It's a big, very interesting task.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by Jd on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:13AM (#3318848)
Does anyone have a copy of Google at home that they hack on in their spare time? Or Apple? Or Facebook?
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by darklajid on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:22AM (#3318869)
I can access Google from home. And Facebook.

Which SAP instance are you suggesting to connect to, would I be so inclined? How would you start creating things for SAP vs. for example Facebook (or G+ now, or the Mac Store)?

There's a set of companies on the one side with broad public appeal and lots of ways to hack and tinker. On the other side you have a behemoth with an army of suits, costing you a couple of limbs for every move - and it's completely useless for the layman.

Note the last statement. If you don't run a business and are in a couple of related positions you just don't care about that stuff. If you are you're probably using and either loathing or loving it. But even if they had SAP in 99% of all companies, they'd still only reach a limited subset of people.

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by Jd on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:23AM (#3319138)
My point was that in no case (Google/Facebook/Apple) does anyone have "a copy" of the core product that they can extend. The developer platforms of each are in a sense extensions to the core products and most "hacking" around Google/Facebook/Apple is related in some fashion to B2C products. SAP also has an army of suits creating B2B products, which makes sense since it is their core market (e.g. B2B offerings instead of B2C).

That said, I completely agree that there are (apparently) higher barriers to entry to SAP and it mystifies me why this would be in their best interests -- I assume in some sense it is the security of the "gated community," where one knows that if one engages a SAP consultant he/she has already been vetted in some fashion.

This sort of approach (which I find typical of Germany) leads to a high average but a real handicap when it comes to innovation. But then again if you are doing something very well it is easy to make money hand over fist and then use that money to buy the latest greatest new sauce once it is ready (which is what SAP has done here with this acquisition).

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by brd on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @10:59AM (#3319683)
I need to defend SAP on this subject. While I agree that they are pretty poor about reaching out beyond their own ecosystem they acknowledge this is a weakness of theirs and they are trying to fix it. They've done a lot over the last year or two to try to make it easier to dabble and they are continuing to push for a more open environment for 3rd party developers.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by freshfey on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @06:19AM (#3318857)
I think arethuza meant something like the facebook developer platform, xcode (iOS/Mac OS X hacking, read: apps) and the Google API's.
Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by arethuza on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @07:37AM (#3319041)
I think I probably meant the emphasis to be on the "own time for their own pleasure" rather than the "at home" part of my comment.

Maybe there should be another version of that silly Gartner diagram where the axes are "importance" and "interestingness" - SAP would be high importance and low interestingness .

Re:Why TechCrunch is boring, SAP is not, and the world has g... by Jd on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @08:19AM (#3319125)
Agree with the rephrased emphasis and likely placement on mentioned silly diagram. SAP Streamworks was pretty interesting IMO, but I don't think there was any opportunity to engage independent developers. Hard to expect anything like that out of the depths of the enterprise and (IMO) that is a good reason to produce consumer (e.g. B2C) rather than enterprise (B2B) driven apps.