News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:40PM (#33182762)
I have trouble understanding the furor around this. If someone said something about me that was patently laughably untrue, something that no sane person would believe, I'd just shrug it off.

Calling someone a "crisis actor" is like saying they are from Mars and have 3 arms. No reasonable person is going to believe it. It's not going to affect your job prospects.

Defamation is "damaging the good reputation of someone" and I don't think this falls into that if the test requires the person to be rational. If the test doesn't require the person to be rational, calling anyone anything could be construed as defamation.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by diydsp on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:44PM (#33182840)
>Calling someone a "crisis actor" is like saying they are from Mars and have 3 arms. No reasonable person is going to believe it.

I've had to counter that argument from many of my high school classmates on facebook. They repeat these statements like sheep from Animal Farm.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by CRWW on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:45PM (#33182848)
So the extraordinary amount of harassment the families received as a result of the crap he was spewing is completely meaningless? Sure no reasonable person is going to believe it but there are a lot of gullible idiots that eat up everything he says. Really easy to say you could shrug it off when your family wasn't just murdered.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by Zigurd on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:45PM (#33182850)
Alex Jones did a lot more than that. His defaming the families of dead kids resulted in his followers and supporters harassing those people. The harassers need to be held civilly and criminally liable, too. But Jones persisted over years in encouraging this harassment.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:53PM (#33182960)
> encouraging this harassment

Did he actually encourage people to harass them? I haven't heard anything of that, because that changes the story if true.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by edmundsauto on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:47PM (#33182880)
While profiting from it and knowing he was lying.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by dfcowell on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:45PM (#33182854)
Jones has a rabid following who engaged in a campaign of stalking and harassment - including death threats and harassment by mail to their homes - against the plaintiffs. It went quite a bit beyond one guy saying some mean things.

I think you’d probably find that harder to shrug off.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:46PM (#33182866)
In this case there is demonstrable harm here. The Sandyhook parents have had their lives threatened and confronted by strangers both on the street and in their home due to Jone's words - the problem is there were a lot of unreasonable people who very much believed Jones and while you claim you would, you wouldn't just shrug this off. His accusations made their lives unsafe by sullying their reputation with irrational people.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:48PM (#33182891)
I don't think holding a person accountable for another person's irrational behaviour is reasonable though. If you tell me "it's going to rain" and I take that as a call to attack people with umbrellas, is that your fault?
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by AlexandrB on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:00PM (#33183073)
Seems like the kind of thing a jury of your peers could decide. Kind of like what happened in this case.

It also bears mentioning that the gulf between "it's going to rain" and "the parents of murdered children are actually 'deep-state' actors aiding a conspiracy to take away your rights" is vast.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:07PM (#33183202)
Neither contains a call to action.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by AlexandrB on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:14PM (#33183356)
I don't think that's a great standard. For example if I consistently call a group of people subhuman and vermin that should not exist I may not have a call to action but the ideology I'm promoting is pretty clear. It's not unreasonable to hold me accountable when a member of my audience decides to attack an individual from the group I'm dehumanizing. Nor is it unreasonable for a member of that group to sue me.

And again, the grey areas here seem like the kind of thing that a jury is able to decide. Alex wasn't found guilty by executive order from the president.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:22PM (#33183493)
I think it's entirely unreasonable. Having a horrible opinion is a million miles away from telling people to do horrible things.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:53PM (#33182967)
But that's not at all what happened. Jones lied in a deliberate attempt to provoke harassment of these poor people. If owned a radio show and I go on and said you were a child rapist and should be stopped by any means necessary would you believe me faultless if you got attacked?
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:57PM (#33183023)
> a deliberate attempt to provoke harassment of these poor people

That seems superbly unlikely. If that were true, what would he stand to gain from that? What did he have against these people?

I can't imagine he was just sitting there chuckling maniacally "yes yes I'm going to hurt these people who just lost their children". That's an imagined cartoon

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by SketchySeaBeast on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:10PM (#33183277)
You're right, he may not have done it deliberately for the harassment, but he clearly had no qualms about it and made no move to stop it when he knew it was happening. He deliberately lied, and deliberately spread false, vicious claims about the parents.

He makes a living of spreading fabulous and wild lies designed to spread fear and anger. In this case, and in the context of all those other anger fueling claims, he lied and said that the shooting was a false flag, that no one died, and that the parents were crises actors who faked the death of their loved ones because the state was going to use it as an excuse for gun control, and he continued to claim it, even after the parents were harassed, even after they initially sued him, and even went so far as to make accusations about the parents and judge on TV during the trial.

What do you believe his goal was? And do you believe those claims don't meet the requirement for defamation? Again I ask how you'd feel in my proposed scenario, if I accused you of being a child rapist on TV, even if I didn't say you needed to be stopped, but that you were raping children for satan. Would you think that's just fine because no one rational would believe it?

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by AlexandrB on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:01PM (#33183106)
Money? His audience eats that shit up. He may not have had anything personal against the victims, but he needs grist for the mill of the type of content he creates.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by mikkergp on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:38PM (#33185237)
Have you listened to Alex Jones speak? I get that we should try to see the humanity in people and that 99.999% of people are complex and nuanced but some people really are sociopaths. Some people really are cartoons.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by HeyLaughingBoy on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:03PM (#33183144)
If I send someone to kill you would you consider me unaccountable?
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by donatj on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @05:07PM (#33183218)
That entirely misses the point. He didn't send the people. They acted on their own based on bad information he fed them. No call to action.
Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by duskwuff on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:47PM (#33182878)
> If someone said something about me that was patently laughably untrue, something that no sane person would believe, I'd just shrug it off.

If it were one ordinary person making those accusations to a small group of their friends and acquaintances who also knew you and could see for themselves that those accusations were false, that'd be one thing.

When the person making those accusations is a celebrity, broadcasting those accusations to an audience of millions who know nothing else about you, that's quite another matter.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by Pxtl on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:48PM (#33182883)
Does the "reasonable person believes it" test apply when numerous people did believe it and engaged in a campaign of harassment and threats against the families? Yes, those people were not reasonable, but on the other hand since Jones runs a snake-oil sales outfit, it's also notable that these are exactly the people he intends to attract. Unstable extremists are his target audience.

He professionally cultivates an army of nitwits for profit, and then weaponizes them just to keep engaged in his product.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by myko on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:48PM (#33182886)
> No reasonable person is going to believe it.

Frankly I agree with you, but there are a lot of unreasonable folks–and every InfoWars consumer falls into that category.

Re:Alex Jones to pay $965M to Sandy Hook victims by john-radio on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @04:51PM (#33182920)
I don't have a lot of respect for the people who listen to Alex Jones or Infowars or believe the content that's published there, but the site had (has?) millions of dollars in revenue and Jones's podcast had (can't find a reliable source, so educated guess:) millions of listeners. So it's quite disingenuous of you to say "no reasonable person is going to believe it" when millions of people didn't find it so unreasonable that they abandoned Jones as a commentator; maybe they themselves, are not reasonable, but that doesn't make the reputational damage any less of a problem; arguably it makes it a lot more of a problem since now these people have to deal with violent threats, being SWATted, and so forth due to the reputational damage among unreasonable people.