News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @01:59PM (#33166625)
> if this kind of reporting sparks the interest of a young physicist out there, I guess its mostly harmless

I'm not sure I agree. If reporting like this funnels more young physicists into doing this kind of research, which has been going on for decades without making any successful experimental predictions, then I don't think it's harmless.

Not only that, but this kind of reporting has a subtext: Science is the Authority. Even when Science tells you what seems like obvious nonsense. And that pernicious effect goes far beyond a few young physicists.

That is not to say that there aren't scientific claims that seem highly counterintuitive to the lay person, but which are nevertheless true. There are. But those claims are nailed down by massive quantities of experimental evidence that matches the predictions of the models to many decimal places. The speculative claims discussed in this article have no evidence to support them. Big difference. But you'll never find that out by reading these kinds of articles.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by zethus on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:04PM (#33166709)
> The speculative claims discussed in this article have no evidence to support them.

Can you highlight which claims that you find to be speculative without evidence? There's a mix of existing theories that are being actively studied in theoretical physics (holographic cosmology), and some claims that the author seems to call out in rhetorical question. I get that either will whoosh over the lay person.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:18PM (#33166920)
> There's a mix of existing theories that are being actively studied in theoretical physics (holographic cosmology), and some claims that the author seems to call out in rhetorical question.

All of those are speculative claims without evidence to support them.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by zethus on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:24PM (#33167037)
I'd argue that in the case of AdS/CFT correspondence, they've been mathematically proven to be _possible_. Doesn't mean that it is true. We also don't have all of the answers to AdS/CFT questions to prove a holographic universe theory with utmost certainty. I would, however, agree that evidence could have been presented in the article, but I'm guessing the target audience for this piece may have never clicked into an array of academic papers.

The classical wormhole as an extreme fold in spacetime is mathematically _possible_, but given what we've observed in the universe, extremely unlikely to naturally occur.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @02:34PM (#33167224)
"Mathematically possible" is a much lower bar than "has evidence to support it". Yes, AdS/CFT is mathematically consistent, as are classical GR wormhole models. But there is no evidence to support either.

> I would, however, agree that evidence could have been presented in the article, but I'm guessing the target audience for this piece may have never clicked into an array of academic papers.

If you know of any scientific papers that present evidence for AdS/CFT (or for wormholes, for that matter), please post links. I'm not aware of any such papers.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by zethus on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:24PM (#33168019)
Ah I understand your argument now and can agree we are on the same page. Can't say I know of any empirical/observed evidence either. I don't believe AdS/CFT can be used to make predictions of precise accuracy beyond serving as a toy model to reshape other physical observation.

To get off the tangent, I've backed up the comment chain and am thinking about your original comments on the harmfulness of articles like this. At first I shared OP's sentiment that it is generally harmless, but the more I think about it, the more I take your stance. Curious what your thoughts are on exposing more people to theoretical physics sans popsci buzzword articles?

For anyone else who's following this thread, I would recommend checking out "The Trouble with Physics" https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/108939.The_Trouble_with_...

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by jemmyw on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:01PM (#33168503)
Would also recommend Sabine Hossenfelder for some similar views on the path physics is taking / dangers of popsci https://www.goodreads.com/book/show/36341728-lost-in-math

I've also enjoyed her YouTube videos that have knocked down a lot of my popsci derived thoughts.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @04:02PM (#33168519)
> Curious what your thoughts are on exposing more people to theoretical physics sans popsci buzzword articles?

It's a great thing to try to do; I try to do it myself as a contributor to Physics Forums [1], for example.

I'm not sure how much good books like The Trouble With Physics actually do as far as exposing more people to physics sans popsci, because, while they might point out issues with how speculative research in physics is done, they don't actually teach any physics.

I personally would recommend Feynman's books for the layman, such as QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter or The Character of Physical Law, or Six Easy Pieces (followed by Six Not So Easy Pieces), as ways for people to get at least some exposure to physics without popsci buzzwords. IMO even those books are limited, because you can't really understand physics without actually doing the math and solving some actual problems. But they're still way better than popsci articles (or, for that matter, popsci books like those of Brian Greene or Michio Kaku).

[1] https://www.physicsforums.com

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by codethief on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:08PM (#33172305)
> Yes, AdS/CFT is mathematically consistent, as are classical GR wormhole models

Nitpick (one which I'm sure you are aware of but it might be relevant for other readers): Classical GR (including wormhole spacetimes and others) is mathematically rigorous. All objects are precisely defined and you can write down actual mathematical theorems.

In contrast, AdS/CFT is anything but rigorous. It's basically just lots of handwaving; it's a hunch that people have, based upon lots of mathematically rather non-sensical calculations.

So I wouldn't want to equate the two in terms of rigorosity / consistency.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by random314 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:16PM (#33167882)
Einstein's relativity was purely theoretical when it was accepted world wide based on abstract principles.

So, your characterization of how modern physics works is completely wrong.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @03:23PM (#33167999)
No, your claim regarding the historical facts is completely wrong.

If by "relativity" you mean special relativity, nobody used it for anything when it was published. The first real use of it theoretically was to explain the Compton effect in 1921, based on experimental results. It took another decade or so for it to be routinely used, mainly due to its success in explaining the fine structure of atomic spectra and in developing quantum field theory.

If you mean general relativity, the first event that could be said to have gotten it "accepted world wide" was the 1919 eclipse expeditions organized by Eddington, which confirmed the GR prediction of bending of light by the Sun. And even then acceptance of it was still limited (see below).

Also, even before that, GR was known to correctly predict the extra precession of Mercury's perihelion, which could not be explained by Newtonian gravity. So that was a piece of evidence for GR that was known before it was published.

Note that even after the 1919 eclipse expedition and the 1921 explanation of the Compton Effect, relativity was still considered too "out there" to justify a Nobel Prize; when Einstein got the prize in 1922 the Nobel committee specifically excluded relativity from the scientific work by Einstein that was the basis for it.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pclmulqdq on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @07:55PM (#33170848)
I believe that GR being true implies the truth of SR, so the 1919 eclipse expedition is actually evidence of both.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by random314 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @08:04PM (#33170934)
Clearly, you don't have a background in physics.

Einstein's speech in the Nobel ceremony was entirely about relativity, which had been accepted as fact since 1908 within the physics community. General relativity was immediately accepted as fact on being published. The same is true for the discovery of gravitational waves.

Relativity was excluded from the prize for relatively obscure reasons, the then famous philosopher Henry Bergson objected to Einstein's concept of time at the time that the committee met to decide on the prize[1]. To top it off Alfred Nobel was not a fan of theoretical physics and made it clear that only experimentally verified theoretical results should be awarded. This is at odds with the physics community. No prominent physicist has objected to relativity since 1910.

If you have actually studied physics, you will see that special relativity is "obviously" correct. There is no reasonable explanation of electromagnetism that doesn't logically imply special relativity. If you accept Maxwell's electromagnetic field equations, special relativity follows mathematically from it.

Theoretical Physics proceeds by exposing contradictions within theories and solving them.

1. Galileo challenged Aristotle's physics by assaulting the contradictory laws for heavenly and earthly bodies

2. Newton gave it a sound mathematical footing resolving contradictions between the laws of heavenly and earthly bodies

3. Maxwell resolved contradictions in Biot Savarts law by introducing displacement current and thus predicting that light is an EM wave

4. Special relativity eliminated the extra ordinary coincidence that prevented any physical experiment from distinguishing an electric field from a magnetic field, even in a theoretical setting, by proposing that the speed of light is constant wrt the observer [2]

5. General relativity solved the extra ordinary coincidence that we cannot distinguish gravity from acceleration while also resolving contradictions between gravity and special relativity.

These theoretical explanations were adequate by itself and did not need experimental verification to be celebrated. Because they solved long standing contradictions and coincidences in a simple compact explanation that reduced the axiom set in physics, not increase them.

That's what differentiates theoretical physics from experimental physics. Alfred Nobel had an aversion to theoretical physics, that's why Higgs had to wait for his prize for decades. But the physics community always knew that the Higgs boson existed. Otherwise, they wouldn't spend billion plus dollars on speculation.

Stanford would not hire Susskind as a professor in theoretical physics if the physics community thought his works are flights of fancy. The same goes for the Lucasian chair conferred on Stephen Hawking, who worked almost entirely in theory with very little experimental verification for his work. Einstein was offered professorships in theoretical physics at various institutions in the 1910s, including the prestigious ETH Zurich well before any sort of experimental verification of his theories.

[1] https://nautil.us/this-philosopher-helped-ensure-there-was-n...

[2] https://www.fourmilab.ch/etexts/einstein/specrel/www/

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:35PM (#33172489)
> There is no reasonable explanation of electromagnetism that doesn't logically imply special relativity.

In other words, the experimental confirmations of Maxwell electrodynamics can also be considered as evidence for SR. That's fine, but it contradicts your claim that SR's acceptance was purely "theoretical" and abstract.

> These theoretical explanations were adequate by itself and did not need experimental verification to be celebrated.

Einstein took a similar position. As one story goes, when he was asked what he would think if experimental tests contradicted the predictions of relativity, he said something like "Then I would feel sorry for the Lord, because the theory is correct."

All of which does not at all change the fact that, unless and until a theory makes accurate predictions, it cannot claim to be "scientific truth". "Solving theoretical contradictions" is fine and a worthwhile endeavor, but it's still not the same as making accurate predictions. String theorists wax lyrical about the same wonderful things you mention, but that doesn't change the fact that, unless and until string theory makes accurate predictions, it cannot claim "scientific truth".

> the physics community always knew that the Higgs boson existed. Otherwise, they wouldn't spend billion plus dollars on speculation.

By the same argument, supersymmetry would have been discovered at the LHC, since the physics community "knew" that supersymmetry was "right". But of course this prediction by many physicists is now notorious for its wrongness. Beautiful theories sometimes get spoiled by ugly facts. Nature doesn't always do what theorists expect.

As for professorships, obviously a professorship in theoretical physics is going to be based on someone's theoretical work, which might be judged by different standards than the standard of "scientific truth". Many theorists have come up with theories that didn't turn out to be right. That doesn't make them bad theorists. It just shows that theories need to be tested to see whether they make accurate predictions. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don't. Nobody gets it right all the time.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by throwaway81523 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:26PM (#33172027)
> If by "relativity" you mean special relativity, nobody used it for anything when it was published. The first real use of it theoretically was to explain the Compton effect in 1921,

The Michelson-Morley experiment was in 1887 and a whole bunch of theories resembling relativity were developed to explain it. SR itself was one of those, and the cleanest.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @11:25PM (#33172425)
Yes, good point. Also, classical electrodynamics based on Maxwell's Equations was already known to be Lorentz invariant, not Galilean invariant, so SR can be thought of as simply taking the invariance properties of electrodynamics and "porting" them to mechanics (whereas pretty much all other approaches went the other way, trying to "port" the invariance properties of Newtonian mechanics to electrodynamics).
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by throwaway81523 on Tuesday October 11, 2022 @10:20PM (#33171973)
If physicists are getting their research directions from pop-sci NYT articles than we are in bigger trouble than merely having interesting theories not pan out.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by kalimanzaro on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @07:31AM (#33175435)
GP probably meant young people deciding to go into physics after reading these articles. I'm a physicist and many of us were massively influenced by the pop-sci books we read as kids before we knew better. You don't get specific research directions from NYT but you do get educated in what kind of ideas will get media attention, and that is as bad as the hypothetical big troubles you allude to.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by throwaway81523 on Thursday October 13, 2022 @04:14AM (#33188522)
Meh, lots of scientists first got that tendency by watching Star Trek and the like. NYT articles are a huge step upward in rigor, compared to that. I wouldn't worry.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:17AM (#33177302)
Now you've made me feel like I was too hard on ADS/Cft!

Empirical confirmation is not, in my opinion, a requirement for taking a scientific idea seriously. There is a lot of discussion of relativity in the threads on this comment, but most of it misses what I think is the salient point: _general_ relativity was formulated not because of any compelling physical observation which demanded a theory of curved spacetime or some other relativistically invariant theory of gravity. General Relativity was formulated because _special relativity_ more or less demanded that the effect of gravity propagate in some way coherent with the idea that causes and effects are ordered and move from place to place at a finite speed.

There is nothing wrong, in my opinion, with undertaking a research program on the basis of a compelling outstanding but purely theoretical problem. I don't think the existence of such research programs alone, nor their discussion in public per se, tends towards a kind of scientific authoritarianism. My problem with the article is entirely in how it communicates the ideas here, which is badly and, more importantly, without situating them in the greater epistemological context of progress in physics. I suppose the presenting the material without that context does kind of support "scientism" but such is so common in media that this doesn't seem like a particularly outstanding example. Really, the inability of the public or the press to understand science is a deep cultural and political problem of which this kind of reporting is just a symptom.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @10:40AM (#33177679)
> Empirical confirmation is not, in my opinion, a requirement for taking a scientific idea seriously.

Taking it seriously as far as investigating it, I agree; you don't need empirical confirmation for that, indeed it would make no sense to insist on it, since at least one major point of investigating it is to see if you can find empirical confirmation (though you might have to expend a lot of theoretical effort to get to that point).

Taking it seriously as far as claiming it is true, no. For that you need empirical confirmation.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by atoav on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @02:34PM (#33181109)
You can investigate whatever, but at a certain scale of investigation it starts to make sense to think about how wise it is to spend the resources, time and collective effort on any given investigation carried out in the way it was meant to be carried out.

E.g. we could do a really hardcore investigation into whether the moon is made of cheese despite all evidence to the contrary. Then we could fly there have one guy be like "Yep it is not cheese". Then have a psychological analysis of that guy and send another one just to be sure, ad infinitum leaving nothing for actual serious, on the edge of knowledge investigations.

That overdriven would dadaist investigation is of course just a carricature I made up now, but the underlying issue is real: science costs us all and we should spend it where it helps. Sometimes that must also mean not knowing to which ends we do investigate something. But it should not become dadaist in a way similar to the outlined story.

Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by nathan_compton on Wednesday October 12, 2022 @09:32PM (#33186106)
Very true. But the fact is that theorists like Susskind are cheap to maintain.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by atoav on Thursday October 13, 2022 @03:54AM (#33188407)
That is true as well.
Re:Black Holes May Hide a Mind-Bending Secret About Our Univ... by pdonis on Wednesday October 19, 2022 @01:04AM (#33257941)
Reminds me of an old joke about the dean of a university complaining to the head of the experimental physics department about how much his department costs. "You have all that expensive equipment," he says. "Look at your counterparts in the theoretical physics department. They're as cheap as the math department: all they ask for is pencils, paper, and erasers." He stops and thinks for a moment. "And the philosophy department is cheaper still. They don't even ask for erasers."