If the currency was gold backed, the right hand would be tied until the treasury deposited gold; now they can do it whenever the left hand looks empty.
Reserve assets always have a separate source of value. Usually this means other currencies. And often it can even be gold reserves!
Without the reserve assets, other banks wouldn't do business with your account, and you couldn't pay for that vacation.
For a reasonable definition of money (something you use to buy stuff) they are in fact creating money out of thin air. "Money" isn't a term that has an agreed upon definition.
Commercial banks sell their treasuries to buy other treasuries? Really?? And where is the money to buy groceries and cause inflation supposed to come from?
Come on the answer is so simple you don't need to act stupid.
Commercial banks issue deposits against the treasuries and buy more treasuries which they then sell to gain reserves which then lets them issue more deposits to buy treasuries. This is definitely a loop but it has nothing to do with the central bank. The commercial bank could have done the same thing by creating deposits against illiquid treasuries without central bank help but it would endanger the banking system via bank runs.
QE basically just turns illiquid treasuries into liquid treasuries, it is basically a duration transformation provided by the central bank so individual banks do not need to take that risk. This by itself can't cause inflation because the type asset changed but not the quantity. You need the government to actually issue more treasuries for inflation to occur and the commercial bank to play along.
It's unclear what the point of this comment is.
Isn't this only half-true though? While they are not physically printing money, in a fractional reserve banking system they can certainly add to the money supply by exchanging illiquid assets for liquid ones.
Agreed though that this is not infinite nor out of thin air.
If anything QE sucks liquid money out of the economy, elevating the price of that money (somewhat, according to central banks) in the process.
> Reserve assets are not very liquid at all.
??? Just stop confusing people. This statement has no meaning. Treasuries and gold are both incredibly liquid and are both among thr most common reserve assets. Feel free to google gold market liquidty depth and verify that assumption yourself
While I agree it's not printing money out of thin air. It definitely seems to be making money more widely available, and in the end the outcome is the same. However, I think what you are alluding to is there isn't some chaos machine that dump money in the economy with no levers to pull it back.
Anytime someone borrows money from a bank new money is created. It's supposedly not a problem because when the debt is paid back the money is destroyed again. In reality, though, debt is never paid back, especially by governments. Instead it's refinanced be taking on ever more debt. The amount of debt is only ever growing and so is the money supply.
It is done that way to prevent out of control money printing. This process has stopped the concept of money printing since 1970 and it ensured there is less inflation. The central bank is doing its inflation fighting job right now. The difficulty of creating more money is being increased. At some point the deflationary forces of paying back money will arrive and inflation won't continue. It takes time.
>In reality, though, debt is never paid back, especially by governments. Instead it's refinanced be taking on ever more debt. The amount of debt is only ever growing and so is the money supply.
This is actually orthogonal to how money is created. The gold standard wasn't safe from a permanently expanding money supply even though digging gold is very expensive.
If you want to stop debt expansion you would need to read up on Silvio Gesell. Essentially the argument goes that money is both a medium of exchange and a store of value. Those two functions contradict each other. Saved money cannot be used to buy things. As a country becomes more prosperous the medium of exchange becomes scarce because people are saving and delaying consumption. There are still some people who have the need to transact and they need money. They could borrow money but that would make the debt problem worse because they would have to pay interest. They could issue more money but that would make the money supply problem worse. How is this supposed to be resolved? That saved money is like a blocked road, if a road is used as a parking lot, it cannot be used for its intended function, driving. We fine people for illegal parking and they will get their cars off the road and pay for private parking. What is a parking fee on money? It is effectively a negative interest rate or a demurrage fee. It encourages people to save in non money assets and give money to people who still have transaction needs.
This is completely orthogonal to what kind of money you have whether it has to be dug out, is printed by the government directly or you have a credit money system. All of them must have what amounts to a parking fee when debt is being paid off.
Or just call it borrowing money because debt is the real problem.
Printing is rhetorical framing that people use to say the government is stealing from you through inflation.
The problem is that paying off debt cripples the economy because people aren't using money as a medium of exchange, they save in liquid money when they should be saving via CDs.
The impact of QE is an increase in money supply.
No net money is created.
Interesting that you're separating the responsibility of money creation to "banks within the banking system", and not the Fed, despite the Fed being the only power here who can buy unlimited assets.
Bank A sends the central bank a real asset worth $1 million (say, a 10 year government bond). The central bank says "you have a balance with us of $1 million now", and updates their SQL database.
"Everyone" agrees the balance with the central bank has real value. Everyone = creditors of the bank, regulators of the bank, accounting standards bodies, auditors, the SEC, trade partners, and probably 10 other groups I can't think of.
They can also use it to buy securities from the Fed, to buy securities from other banks, to settle derivatives contracts and margin calls around them.
> Reserve assets are financial assets denominated in foreign currencies and held by central banks that are primarily used to balance payments.
https://www.investopedia.com/terms/r/reserve-assets.asp
The OECD seems to define it consistently with Investopedia: https://stats.oecd.org/glossary/detail.asp?ID=167
Could we perhaps have a source for the definition you're using here?
> Printing money is the job of the Federal Reserve, but only figuratively speaking. When the Fed decides to stimulate the economy by pouring more money into the system, it electronically transfers additional credits to the deposits of its member banks. The banks lend that money out to consumers and businesses at a profit, putting the money into general circulation.
This is not true, at least in the US. The Treasury issues currency.
What the Federal Reserve can do (and has done under QE) is perform an asset swap. An asset held by a bank (such as a treasury bond) is purchased by the Fed and held on its balance sheet. In exchange, the Fed credits the bank with a reserve asset. This reserve asset can not be spent in the real economy. It is locked in the banking system and can only be used within it.
Reserve assets are not money. They're much more like a utility token. Therefore, the US Federal Reserve does not print money under QE.
But there's the fact and then there's perception. Many are either unaware of how QE actually works, or think the distinction between currency and reserve assets doesn't matter. So they behave accordingly.