News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economics Awarded to Ben Bernanke, Douglas... by VictorPath on Monday October 10, 2022 @11:33AM (#33152694)
> turning into an anti intellectual space where takes like "economics is not a science, it's a social science!" are the best we have to offer

A bank taking an endowment awarding a prize and money to physicists, chemists and biologists, and ramming in to it a prize for economists saying nonsense the bankers like to hear, is the definition of anti-intellectual.

The physicists, chemists and biologists are the intellectuals and scientists, the economists are frauds telling the bankers what they want to hear.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economics Awarded to Ben Bernanke, Douglas... by snake_doc on Monday October 10, 2022 @11:48AM (#33152893)
Argument:

> turning into an anti intellectual space where takes like "economics is not a science, it's a social science!" are the best we have to offer

Evidence: VictorPath's reply

> A bank taking an endowment awarding a prize and money to physicists, chemists and biologists, and ramming in to it a prize for economists saying nonsense the bankers like to hear, is the definition of anti-intellectual. The physicists, chemists and biologists are the intellectuals and scientists, the economists are frauds telling the bankers what they want to hear.

Q.E.D.

Re:Nobel Prize in Economics Awarded to Ben Bernanke, Douglas... by kiba on Monday October 10, 2022 @02:04PM (#33154539)
Neither of these intellectuals and scientists are any good for doing economics, precisely because they are on a wrong level of abstraction.
Re:Nobel Prize in Economics Awarded to Ben Bernanke, Douglas... by yobbo on Monday October 10, 2022 @02:25PM (#33154807)
How does one evaluate the work of an economist - repeatably and independently?