News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by narkee on Monday December 05, 2011 @10:01AM (#3314809)
I think that's the difference between academic education, and vocational training.

I've made this point before, but people often conflate the two, and are unable to separate them in their minds.

What this person is saying is "these things do not train a person to perform these specific sets of tasks". That's vocational training, and there's nothing wrong with that. Academic education, on the other hand, is about learning to think, about history, rhetoric, science, and all sorts of things that aren't directly applicable to a particular job, but provide a necessary foundation for critical thinking and enlightenment, so to speak.

What our system really needs is two streams. An academic stream, for those who choose, and a vocational stream, which is what a large proportion of students and seemingly educators like this guy want.

This way, everyone gets what they want. Students truly interested in learning things not directly related to performing a job will have the benefit of a more supportive learning environment, and students who just want to get a job will also attain the required vocational training.

It's really win-win.

Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by gnaritas on Monday December 05, 2011 @10:15AM (#3314856)
Our system already has those two streams, has practically forever. People still abuse the college stream as if it were vocational training.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by absconditus on Monday December 05, 2011 @11:00AM (#3315091)
Unfortunately they are winning and academia is being dumbed down so that everyone can obtain a degree.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by michael_dorfman on Monday December 05, 2011 @11:16AM (#3315158)
How do you reconcile that position with the original article?
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by SoftwareMaven on Monday December 05, 2011 @11:50AM (#3315329)
The article is a single anecdote from the wrong side of the college continuum. After helping my daughter all year with geometry, it is not surprising to me that he couldn't do the math. Those kinds of tests ask questions like "Can you prove these triangles are congruent" and you have to remember all the SAS, SSA, ASA, etc theorems and postulates to have a chance. You will forget those after 20 years, no matter how much you excelled in high school, if you aren't using them (or derivative concepts in higher math) regularly.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by bostonvaulter2 on Monday December 05, 2011 @12:28PM (#3315472)
Proving theorem's is often taught very poorly. If you haven't already I highly recommend you read Lockhart's Lament:

http://www.maa.org/devlin/devlin_03_08.html

Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by rapind on Monday December 05, 2011 @03:27PM (#3316324)
I haven't finished reading it yet, but so far it's been pretty eye-opening. It reminds me of how I once took a photoshop course in order to improve my design skills... pretty easy to guess how well that worked.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by sidek on Monday December 05, 2011 @07:12PM (#3317160)
Perhaps I'm the exception, but in Grade 10 I didn't take math (long story) and had never seen most of the math concepts but still was the go-to math helper. High school math is fairly trivial- easy enough to figure out with just some intuition and general thinking skills.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by sbov on Monday December 05, 2011 @08:06PM (#3317314)
There's a huge leap from being able to figure it out with a book and all the equations inside of it as opposed to taking a test with only questions, no reference material, and presumably a time limit.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by sidek on Monday December 05, 2011 @10:48PM (#3317779)
No, I never used a book or any equations. People would give me questions with no context, and I would take a second to think through it and then help them. Things like solving systems of equations are easy - you just need to truly understand algebra. Similarly, high school geometry doesn't get far past the axioms themselves.

As a disclaimer to all of this, I was the type that had fun proving stuff in seventh grade and had already read through Spivak's Calculus by Grade 10.

Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by dhume on Tuesday December 06, 2011 @09:51AM (#3319456)
As a disclaimer to all of this, I was the type that had fun proving stuff in seventh grade and had already read through Spivak's Calculus by Grade 10.

This makes your earlier claim of never having seen most of the concepts rather dubious.

Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by absconditus on Monday December 05, 2011 @11:55AM (#3315348)
I do not have a high opinion of school board members and the article seems like superficial fluff.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by jbooth on Monday December 05, 2011 @05:17PM (#3316778)
If you don't have a high opinion of them, you should try it, run and fix all of the things they're fucking up.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by makmanalp on Monday December 05, 2011 @12:52PM (#3315580)
Absconditus is talking about higher education, I think.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by lambersley on Monday December 05, 2011 @11:15AM (#3315151)
These streams already exist. One of the major issues I see wit this is it assumes a child at 15 years old is capable of making this choice and understands all the implications. I think back to grades 9 thru 13 (Canadian), thank God it's not so long ago, but I realize decisions I made then were primarily based on emotion, testosterone and some social influence. Could I really have imagined life 15 years later? Absolutely not.
Re:Man with multiple degrees fails standardized test for chi... by amurmann on Monday December 05, 2011 @10:44AM (#3315007)
This is once again caused by education inflation. It's easier for the HR department to compare formal education than to really look at the applicant. So Master's degree wins over Bachelor's wins over solid vocational training and society carries the cost.