Re:There And Back Again: A Lengthy Weighing Of The Galaxy Ne...
by baddox on Monday December 05, 2011 @04:01AM
(#3313810)
For one thing, the standard buttons are ridiculous. Differ phones have them in different orders, and the app deceleration has free reign to make them do whatever they want. The "menu" button sometimes hides crucial information and functionality, but there's no indicator when this is the case. In the Path app, recently lauded for its design and user experience, on one activity you have to press the phone's menu button, then choose "menu" from the onscreen menu. At that point, you're actually at the menu.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:There And Back Again: A Lengthy Weighing Of The Galaxy Ne...
by Tichy on Monday December 05, 2011 @06:55AM
(#3314242)
So you have several Android phones from different vendors, and use them all on a regular basis? Because otherwise the complaint about the buttons being arranged differently on different phones seems a bit odd. Why would you care, as long as you know the arrangement on your phone?
Is the path app for iOS better than the Android version? Because it also seems odd to blame the OS for the flaws of some specific apps.
Personally I am sad to see buttons being optimized away. For example my Galaxy Tab doesn't have a search button. Now all apps seem to hide the search functionality in a different place. I miss not having to search for the search button.
Re:There And Back Again: A Lengthy Weighing Of The Galaxy Ne...
by baddox on Monday December 05, 2011 @01:43PM
(#3315830)
I do frequently use many different Android phones, because I do Android development.
I've briefly compared Path on Android and iPhone. Other than performance (iPhone is much smoother), I didn't notice many differences. I'm not really blaming the OS for having any technical flaws. I'm speaking more to flaws in the platform.