Re:Calif. Law to Protect Children's Privacy Could Lead to In...
by O__________O on Saturday October 08, 2022 @12:38PM
(#33133749)
My memory was that the tokens enter a pool of tokens and that neither government or endpoint is unable to trace which user used which token and they’re one-time use tokens, so users is unable to share them. Guess never really gave system much thought at the time, since governments rarely want less data or to provide anonymous access — and average person does not care about anonymous access, in fact, in my experience they want everything logged.
Even then, if the government actively compelling endpoints to hand over their data is within the threat model, the government could inspect any cached temporary tokens to deanonymize the users. This could perhaps be mitigated with some way for users to irreversibly transform the temporary tokens given by the government, but I'm not sure if that's possible while retaining the ability for endpoints to verify the tokens.
Overall, though, the sharing problem seems to me to be the biggest issue by far with this scheme. What makes a user an individual human? In current implementations, their unique government ID (perhaps made illegal to falsify) is used for this. But I can't see how individual humans can be distinguished in a privacy-preserving way.