Btw crypto is worse on this in every way and there is no system that actually solves this problem. I wonder if it is even possible to solve.
In the end it all has to come down to trust. If all transactions were easy to reverse, we would see the opposite problem: scammers who pay people money and the. demand it back, claiming fraud.
The scenario is, someone pays for porn, their spouse sees it on the bill and gets really angry, and the other person says it wasn't me, it must have been fraud! So they file a chargeback.
I don't see a problem with that. If fraud is rare, the fee would be small. If fraud is not rare, then there's a problem they should fix.
For every 100 Zelle transactions, how many are due to fraud or scams? Maybe three or four? Then the fee should be 3-4%.
Banks might be trying to pretend Zelle isn't covered by Regulation E, but I haven't heard any good argument for why it doesn't apply, other than arguments similar to yours that they simply don't want it to.
And it won't be the end of free electronic transfers, it'll just mean acknowledging that those transfers aren't any more final than writing a check.
Regulation E talks about liability for "unauthorized transactions". Those are transfers "from a consumer's account initiated by a person other than the consumer without actual authority to initiate the transfer".
If you initiated the transfer but were misled into doing so or provided the wrong payment information or whatever, it's still an authorized transaction from Regulation E's perspective; so you are still liable for it. The only exception is if you were induced by force to initiate the transfer.
Errors under Reg E include any instance where Party Y is not who receives the funds, including wrong payment info.
In a technical sense you're correct; in both cases the transactions are effectively irreversible. That said, I think there is an important difference:
Everyone (well, kinda) knows that a crypto transaction is irreversible; that's basically the point. Because of this, it is expected and normal to layer on extra systems to cope with the risk of not having an authority to dispute stuff to. Consider darknet markets: they use escrow and reputation systems to protect both parties.
But everyone (well, kinda, in the same sense as the above) also knows traditional financial institutions are "safe" and that transactions are reversible. That false sense of security means other security/resolution methods aren't considered, so when the centralized authority has a bad day the end user is out of luck.
But isn't an escrow system just another centralized authority? Sure, but at least I can choose what escrow system I want to interact with. The banking cartel behind Zelle doesn't afford me the same degree of choice, and using small credit unions isn't a panacea either because they farm out everything complicated to one or another of the payment cartels. Quality of escrow system is an important discriminator when choosing a DNM; I wish I could assess various traditional financial institutions' likeliness to rip me off as effectively.
If centralized financial institutions want to act like crypto in terms of irreversibility, fine, but I think the scale of the problem described in TFA indicates that some "are you suuuuuuuuuuuuure you want to send money to Joe Blow" popups in the app aren't enough to overcome that aegis of "this is a safe institution" floating around in the public consciousness. I see it as more a problem of false advertising than anything else, really. Copy from the landing page of their site:
> Zelle® works between U.S.-based banks. Which means, even if you bank somewhere different than your friends and family do,1 you can still use Zelle® to safely send and receive money straight from your banking app.
> safely
Obviously it's not a legal doc or anything, but I'd argue the service is both explicitly and implicitly casting itself as akin to a bank-provided service like a credit card, not something as wild west as cash.
As a seller, or a buyer dealing with someone I trust, recourse is a serious hazard I want to avoid. For this reason I demand cash or crypto when selling items.
>but can you really defend the position that you thought those arguments were suspect because you knew banks were going to stop fraud corrections?
I knew those arguments were suspect, because the very same thing that makes such an intervention possible is the very same thing that makes it unreliable: a central authority, that first and foremost acts in its own best interest and is prone to corruption, abuse of power and what have you.
> While simultaneously preferring systems that never had it at all?
You can still build such a system on top of a decentralized system and put your trust in random 3rd parties, if for whatever reason that happens to float your boat.
I always knew that some of the pro arguments for centralized systems were suspect, but it's good to have some evidence for it now.
Now I wonder how many other cases that are touted as arguments for centralized systems don't hold up to any scrutiny.