Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by tunesmith on Thursday October 06, 2022 @04:25PM
(#33113607)
Progressives cluster in dense areas (and/or perhaps density causes progressiveness), and density also causes greater NIMBYism. It doesn't necessarily follow that progressivism causes NIMBYism.
Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by Tiktaalik on Thursday October 06, 2022 @05:21PM
(#33114261)
The mistake is that on municipal and land use issues it's a two axis political system.
It's not left/right, it's also urbanist/conservationist.
You will find those on both the left and right that for various ideological reasons end up at the same point of wanting to obstruct new housing creation.
Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by spaniard89277 on Thursday October 06, 2022 @04:20PM
(#33113536)
I see. Is there overlap between "progressives" and "housing nimbys" in the US?
Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by vorpalhex on Thursday October 06, 2022 @04:22PM
(#33113564)
Yes, both directly (NIMBYism is generally worse in liberal areas) and indirectly (density makes everything harder and more complicated).
Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by Tiktaalik on Thursday October 06, 2022 @05:23PM
(#33114272)
There's overlap of both progressives and NIMBYS and conservatives and NIMBYS.
Just as there are progressive YIMBYS and "conservative" (usually labelled "market urbanist") YIMBYS.
The left/right axis is inadequate to describe the dynamics of municipal politics. You need a second urbanist/conservationist axis to describe support or opposition for housing development.
Re:More than half of Silicon Valley residents want to leave:...
by kwillets on Thursday October 06, 2022 @04:35PM
(#33113746)
left-nimby's, as they're called, obstruct housing with price controls and other uneconomical demands on housing producers and buyers. Often they reject projects out-of-hand if they show any possibility of making a profit.
Before anyone responds looking to argue, I'm not saying whether it's true or false, just stating that that's the perception.