Re:Steve Jobs and America's decline
by SkyMarshal on Saturday December 03, 2011 @11:01AM
(#3307977)
American exceptionalism isn't just that the USA is great b/c it's the USA, but because it founded as an implementation of a set of moral ideals.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/American_exceptionalism
As an American, I agree though, it is nauseating when politicians or citizens pull this card and use it to justify nationalism or other bad things and abuses. It cancels the very reasons for the idea of exceptionalism in the first place.
This is indeed nauseating, especially when you consider that the USA is not even in the top 10 in many human development measures. The reflexive tribalism you see on the right makes me think we must be number 1 in self esteem.
OTOH the U.S. has a much more diverse, wideranging population and geography than countries ahead of it in those measures (that I think) you're thinking of. Regions that would be different countries in Europe or Asia are all states unified under a federal system, which has its upsides and downsides.
Totally agree. Folks who migrate here keep the "greatness" "non-hereditary". I'm not sure how much longer such a thing will last though, as more opportunities continue to develop in their home countries.
The second part is the idea of American exceptionalism: that the USA is great because it's the USA. This is nauseating, indeed. It's also obviously harmful, since now "greatness" is a birthright rather than an achievement.