Interesting, looks like there was some kind of attack on privacy.com in 2020[0] that caused transactions to be run from vendors without them.
0. https://blog.privacy.com/a-different-type-of-card-fraud-anat...
Thanks for digging that up! I knew they made a post about it. Didn't notice before that they tried to say they "made (everyone) whole".
Maybe they think that not sending me to collections after I stopped the payment at the bank and closed my account is "being made whole."
This was during a big wave of unauthorized activity being attempted on their cards as well, a lot of friends reported blocked charges for random amounts at like a retirement/hospice home(?) at the time.
This was like 3+ years ago, and my only guess now (read: can't remember if this is true) is that the card had never been charged to the merchant, only pre-authed. But even then I'd expect the pre-auth to lock it to a merchant.