Re:A study of lights at night suggests dictators lie about e...
by vidarh on Monday October 03, 2022 @07:03AM
(#33065835)
Note that while I partially agree with this hypothesis this graph (can't see the whole article) does not speak to that.
What this graph shows is the reliability (or lack thereof) of the official statistics.
The data still shows a number of unfree countries showing significant GDP growth even if you look at the satellite based estimate. Many of them are still above many free countries. This is not surprising, because many of those unfree countries are early in their development curve and have had a lot of easy gains to make.
To support the hypothesis you present, you'd need to investigate how the growth rates of countries at a similar level of development, correcting for global trends, fare under different levels of authority.
That said, personally, my hypothesis is that sadly (because it's depressing in terms of how little impact changing government potentially has) regulatory and legal stability matters far more than specific government type. E.g. look up China's reported GDP growth before and after Deng got into power. China's growth after the revolution until Deng got into power was growth punctuated by massive crises that reset things whenever the rules changed under people. Once Deng got into power it stabilised even before his economic reforms, because while the system was still deeply authoritarian, people learn to play the game however rigged it is as long as the rules don't change all the time. Even deeply brutal dictatorships can see sustained growth - especially in developing countries growing from a small base with lots of easy wins - as long as they're consistent.
And that is exactly the primary danger of an authoritarian system for economic growth: It might well work fine for a while, and to stick to China they learned a lot from the stability Deng brought and have since been afraid to rock the boat, but with an autocratic system there's always a significant risk that the next leader will change the rules again.
Meanwhile, even really broken democratic governments rarely manages to more than slightly change the trajectory (there's a certain irony that I'm writing this from the UK after the last couple of weeks chaos, but even though I think our current UK government are idiots, I don't think they'll have much of a lasting effect) because they tend to tinker around the edges rather than fundamentally change the rules (e.g. consider the massive backlash the UK government faces over tinkering with tax rates)
What this graph shows is the reliability (or lack thereof) of the official statistics.
The data still shows a number of unfree countries showing significant GDP growth even if you look at the satellite based estimate. Many of them are still above many free countries. This is not surprising, because many of those unfree countries are early in their development curve and have had a lot of easy gains to make.
To support the hypothesis you present, you'd need to investigate how the growth rates of countries at a similar level of development, correcting for global trends, fare under different levels of authority.
That said, personally, my hypothesis is that sadly (because it's depressing in terms of how little impact changing government potentially has) regulatory and legal stability matters far more than specific government type. E.g. look up China's reported GDP growth before and after Deng got into power. China's growth after the revolution until Deng got into power was growth punctuated by massive crises that reset things whenever the rules changed under people. Once Deng got into power it stabilised even before his economic reforms, because while the system was still deeply authoritarian, people learn to play the game however rigged it is as long as the rules don't change all the time. Even deeply brutal dictatorships can see sustained growth - especially in developing countries growing from a small base with lots of easy wins - as long as they're consistent.
And that is exactly the primary danger of an authoritarian system for economic growth: It might well work fine for a while, and to stick to China they learned a lot from the stability Deng brought and have since been afraid to rock the boat, but with an autocratic system there's always a significant risk that the next leader will change the rules again.
Meanwhile, even really broken democratic governments rarely manages to more than slightly change the trajectory (there's a certain irony that I'm writing this from the UK after the last couple of weeks chaos, but even though I think our current UK government are idiots, I don't think they'll have much of a lasting effect) because they tend to tinker around the edges rather than fundamentally change the rules (e.g. consider the massive backlash the UK government faces over tinkering with tax rates)