20% of farmland in the entire United States is doused in fertilizers, pesticides, herbicides, etc. Enough water for 3 states (which are running out, btw). Fossil fuels to for tractors, for fertilizers, for transportation, and logistics. All so you can throw it out.
So of course there are externalities: labor, land, water, environment, fossil fuels, fertilizers, pesticides, run-off, topsoil depletion and plenty more. All of which is not nearly as big a deal if it's done to achieve a goal rather than to appease the voters in Iowa. These are classic externalities that aren't priced in when you subsidize corn to below the cost of production.
The report I linked in the original post includes a breakdown of exactly where food is wasted on pages 14 to 30. [2]
There's a pie chart on page 10 which includes a breakdown by kind of food too, as a percentage of waste by weight.
- Dairy: 19.1%
- Vegetables: 19%
- Fruit: 13.9%
- Grain: 13.9%
- Added sugars and sweeteners: 12.6%
- Meat, fish and poultry: 11.5%
- Fats and oils: 7.5%
- Eggs: 2.1%
- Tree nuts and peanuts: 0.4%
[1] https://www.usda.gov/peoples-garden/food-access-food-waste/f...
[2] https://www.nrdc.org/sites/default/files/wasted-2017-report....
It also requires 3 pounds of grain and 4.5 gallons of water per gallon of milk and dairy is almost 20% of the waste.
The scale of this waste is mind-boggling.
If in the process you used practically finite fertilisers in the form of phosphorus from Morocco and nitrogen from fossil fuels, etc then you may wish to rethink that.
of all the things that are limited in this world, this seems like it ranks among the least concerning. Sure, it takes electricity, but that itself can be much more efficiently collected going into the future
But you are right that making nitrogen fertilizer doesn't require fossil fuels. It would be a major market for "green hydrogen", which would be a great dispatchable demand to help smooth variability in renewable power output and in other demand.