Re:New asteroid strike images show impact 'a lot bigger than...
by jl6 on Monday October 03, 2022 @02:57AM
(#33064316)
The variability of composition of asteroids, from rubble piles to solid masses, makes me think that future asteroid diversion missions will look not so much like a big gun fired at the last minute, and more like a decades-long programme of search, analysis, and engineering tailored to each target.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:New asteroid strike images show impact 'a lot bigger than...
by saiya-jin on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:18AM
(#33064810)
Wouldn't nuke going off just next to it nudge anything enough off course to not have to worry about composition? Or Hollywood yet again inserted a very unrealistic picture of how things work in my head.
Or we strictly prefer not sending nukes up there outside WWIII scenario. But then plenty of satellites have/had nuclear fuel as main source of energy, just not critical mass for anything BAM, just nasty dispersion in the upper atmosphere threat.
Re:New asteroid strike images show impact 'a lot bigger than...
by XorNot on Monday October 03, 2022 @07:11AM
(#33065903)
A nuke going off "near" anything in space will do very little damage - there's no shockwave propagation, so all you have is the bombs heat - which at least half gets wasted on empty space.
One of of the big problems with nuking asteroids is, as in this case, if it's a rubble pile then it can be considerably difficult to get enough physical contact with it to even meaningfully effect it.
Hence the reason for DART: we've got an impressive something but the question is did we even successfully deflect the trajectory of the bulk of the material?
Re:New asteroid strike images show impact 'a lot bigger than...
by ncmncm on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:03AM
(#33066275)
A lot of smallish bolides could be much worse than one big one.
Particularly if the big one would miss, but many of the saller ones don't.
Re:New asteroid strike images show impact 'a lot bigger than...
by BatteryMountain on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:14AM
(#33065508)
Or, just fling a giant tarp or net (depending on whether it seems solid or not) at it and pull it in a different direction instead of essentially firing a projectile at it.