News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by thrown_22 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @07:58PM (#33061717)
There is a very gung ho culture in labs about safety. It slows you down to do things right and when it comes to reviews the cowboys (and girls) who do things wrong but fast get better reviews because they get more done.

Nuclear labs kill the people inside them at worst. Bio labs ... Well there's a reason why I think covid was the worst lab accident in human history.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bumby on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:27PM (#33061930)
I’m not sure why you’ve been downvoted but this is a very prevalent attitude at hazardous facilities that are run by contractors. In particular, when the hazards are relatively low probability events and there are perverse incentives to roll the dice in the name of productivity.

In a previous job in a hazardous facility, I’ve had very senior managers sit me down to tell me I don’t want to get the reputation for slowing things down by enforcing safety rules. I’m personally glad I’ve moved on with my career.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by rdtwo on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:32PM (#33061976)
I think this is universal. The safety rules go so overboard that the critical ones get ignored with the stupid ones because employees don’t know which ones are the important ones. If everything is critical nothing is
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by sbierwagen on Monday October 03, 2022 @04:36AM (#33064893)
My first job out of highschool: overnight loader/stocker at a hardware store.

The guy who ran the big forklift in the lumber section was a bit of a cowboy. At the start of the night there would be a big pile of lumber, and he had to sort it and get it on the shelves. We couldn’t really run two lifts at the same time due to aisle width, so he did the job solo, and ran the equipment fast to get it done in time.

Start of shift one evening an upper manager came down and said they reviewed security camera footage, that he was driving too fast, and needed to be more careful. But how do I get it done in time, he said? She emitted the verbal equivalent of a shrug, and left.

Because, of course, she doesn’t want him to be slower, she wanted him to be more careful. To be on record as having issued a warning, so that if something happened, her ass would be covered. She couldn’t solve the problem but she could certainly apportion blame beforehand.

A formative experience for 19 year old me.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bumby on Monday October 03, 2022 @11:52AM (#33069222)
Yeah, that's more of a CYA than an actual strong safety culture. It's more safety theater than anything else. I've had plenty of similar instances, where managers were allowed to get rid of safety/quality requirements as long as they formally documented that they understood and accepted the risks. They almost were never willing to do so, but would still pressure their employees to, you know, find some other way to get the work done faster.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by s0rce on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:56PM (#33062149)
This is major issue in my experience. Even introducing new benign chemicals can lead to lengthy reviews and project delays. I've also found that when I've asked directly how to safely handle something the safety people don't have an answer and end up with an extremely conservative approach that doesn't appear to be driven by actual risks (severity or probability).
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bumby on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:37PM (#33062015)
This is very true. At a certain point, management needs to be willing to prioritize what safety requirements they are willing to endorse. The worst of both worlds is when leadership isn't willing to formally do so, but push an informal culture to ignore safety rules.

It’s worse when it’s low probability but high severity risks. Sometimes something that is critical but low probability is more easily conflated with not being a legitimate risk. I dog think it’s telling that the article made it seem like the entire safety team quit en-masse

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by BurningFrog on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:07PM (#33062224)
Classic "boy who cried wolf" syndrome.

Also:

    “The safest way to make laws respected is to make them respectable.” ― Frédéric Bastiat
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bumby on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:15PM (#33062277)
Counterpoint is that it's easy to dismiss a requirement when one doesn't fully understand it. Sometimes that takes less work to dismiss it rather than spending the effort to remove one's ignorance. Particularly in safety critical systems, it's probably prudent to assume there is a good intent first.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by jackvalentine on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:41AM (#33063540)
A classic one for home food preserving - some of the old recipes have steps that ‘don’t make sense’ but are crucial to food safety. Without them you might get botulism.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bumby on Monday October 03, 2022 @09:16AM (#33067071)
I just learned about this one recently. Basically, how canning with oil isn't really worth the risk.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by justinator on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:46PM (#33062063)
> I’m not sure why you’ve been downvoted

Because "Covid 19 was engineered in a lab, then released" is nothing but a conspiracy theory.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by tormeh on Sunday October 02, 2022 @08:53PM (#33062115)
Conspiracy to cover up a mistake, maybe. There's no way to know, but given what is known about the origin of covid it's too plausible to just dismiss. We'll just have to live with the ambiguity.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by leetrout on Sunday October 02, 2022 @09:47PM (#33062522)
You jumped to some conclusions.

OP said a lab accident. This could have been from an animal sample.

Everyone seems to conflate lab leak with lab manufacture (or jump further to purposeful leak).

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by chihuahua on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:36PM (#33062893)
In addition to what you said (conflating lab leak with various things), there's another factor: Early on, the people who were funding the gain-of-function research at WIV put out a statement that considering possibility of lab leak == racism, and some people are still following those orders.

There is no proof that it was or was not a lab leak, engineered or not, intentional or not. Whatever evidence there was has been destroyed.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by thrown_22 on Sunday October 02, 2022 @10:41PM (#33062923)
There's a difference between escape and release. Not sure why you put words in my mouth.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by justinator on Monday October 03, 2022 @11:32AM (#33068948)
I'm certainly not putting words in your mouth. You asked why you were being downvoted. I mentioned that there's a conspiracy theory along the lines of what you're saying. In no way did I say, "YOU'RE propagating a conspiracy theory". Just that there is a thing, and that thing is in some way influencing people's opinion on your comment. That does not imply intent.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by thrown_22 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:07PM (#33073720)
> You asked why you were being downvoted.

I did not.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by BlueTemplar on Monday October 03, 2022 @06:15AM (#33065518)
That the governments have tried to make appear the theory of a lab leak, contrary to expert opinion, as "exceedingly unlikely" is now a conspiracy fact, not theory.

If you want some theory, then : The Wuhan Virology Institute database has been taken offline in September 2019. And investment was made in aeration systems. French intelligence agencies have been mandated to investigate in autumn 2019. (The October 2019 Wuhan military sports games would have been a good occasion.) Then, in January 2020, the passengers list for a military plane from Wuhan to France didn't match.

Those are facts too, the theory part is the way I put them together. (Could have been a coincidence of course.)

P.S.: Also relevant to the article here is the relationship between the French nuclear program and the Wuhan lab. (Both need pretty extreme safety, so I guess it's not surprising how the know-how from the former resulted in the latter !)

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by bboygravity on Monday October 03, 2022 @12:28AM (#33063477)
> Well there's a reason why I think covid was the worst lab accident in human history.

And that reason likely has to do more with the fact that you're not a virologist nor someone who has a deep understanding of virus evolution and how Sars-CoV2 does what it does.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by thrown_22 on Monday October 03, 2022 @05:24AM (#33065171)
If there's a big explosion in Los Alamos I'm going to think it's a nuclear explosion even if everyone else says it's a meteor. Balance of probability is that the biological weapons lab was doing biological weapons research and it got out.

Without a non virologist investigating what happened there this is the same level of believability as cops clearing themselves of wrong doing in an afternoon.

Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by dreamcompiler on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:22AM (#33066477)
The probability of a nuclear explosion at Los Alamos is vanishingly close to zero for lots of reasons. The probability of a nuclear accident at Los Alamos is pretty much 1.0, since several have happened there before, and recently.
Re:A near-disaster at a nuclear weapons lab takes toll on Am... by thrown_22 on Monday October 03, 2022 @08:26AM (#33066519)
That's not what I said.

I said that if an explosion similar to the Chelyabinsk meteor happened there I'd need _extreme_ proof that it wasn't a nuclear explosion.