News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by shocks on Friday December 02, 2011 @04:56PM (#3305864)
I agree with a lot of RMS' views, but I would be very interested to know what he thinks about computer games (PC, and consoles). Can anyone shed any light on this?

The way I see it, games are much like an interactive film. It's an experience someone has personally created for us. It's more of an art than a computer program. I'm aware of open source games, but I wonder how an open source model would affect a game like Battlefield 3? Cheating would surely be rampant. I certainly do not expect Terabytes of data when I watch a film so I can make the changes I want, nor do I expect sheet music when I buy an album. Games are as much of an art as music & films.

What about consoles? They are viciously protected from custom modifications. I don't agree with this, I believe it's our hardware and we should be allowed to do as we wish (hey Microsoft, blowing fuses in my NVRAM without telling me is really not cool).

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by redthrowaway on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:43PM (#3306270)
>I would be very interested to know what he thinks about computer games

See Stallman's Reddit AMA (#7): http://blog.reddit.com/2010/07/rms-ama.html

Essentially, he thinks that the production quality associated with studio games is not worth the sacrifice in user freedom. Your point about games being much like film is an interesting one. Elsewhere in the AMA, he says that he doesn't consider proprietary software that controls, eg, a microwave, to be unethical as it's functionally indistinct from hardware. Now, with some games (cough BF3) being functionally indistinct from movies, it would be interesting to know whether he believes those, too, are unethical. My guess is yes, as there are many things like DRM and data collection going on behind the scenes that the FSF is opposed to.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by pantaloons on Friday December 02, 2011 @05:34PM (#3306042)
> Cheating would surely be rampant.

Not at all, as it is anybody can modify the game binaries in the same way they would modify the source code (albeit with more difficulty).

Cheating is prevented by having a central server validate all client actions for consistency, or in games without a simulation server (Starcraft II) having clients compare a game state hash and disconnect if they differ.

Client side cheating (Wallhacks, Aimbots) are not preventable without a locked down client, open source or not.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by omouse on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:46PM (#3306734)
In opensource code, you would have decentralized servers run by various groups that may or may not accept "cheating" (cheating is just a different set of game rules). You could have peers validate the game rule set for each of their peers as well so that everyone playing on servers is agreeing to the "cheats".
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by JoshTriplett on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:05PM (#3306650)
> Client side cheating (Wallhacks, Aimbots) are not preventable without a locked down client, open source or not.

You can easily prevent wallhacks; just don't tell clients information they shouldn't display to the user, such as the positions of players the user can't currently see.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by jiggy2011 on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:49PM (#3306737)
I think this is a case for performance mostly. A character hidden behind a wall will be likely to appear to the player very soon. The client then gets a chance to pre-load any necissary rescources into memory and download from the server any information about the other character it might need. If you didn't do this then for example the page containing the player character model might have been swapped to disk and the delay caused in bringing this back in might cause a lag which will give one player a disadvantage.

Also you may be able to hear the person behind the wall , for (even though it may only be a very quiet sound from the other character walking slowly). The client application will need a location in order to play the sound correctly, this information could be used to make a wallhack.

The other alternative would be to pre-prepare all sound on the server and stream it to the client , but this would put extra stress on the server and more demand on bandwidth.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by jeremysalwen on Saturday December 03, 2011 @05:32AM (#3307458)
Hmm...I don't think you would need that much of a performance drop.

If the data was received encrypted, you could have a relatively small decryption key sent when necessary, thus solving the "prefetch from server" problem.

If the model files were broken up into chunks and xored with each other in various ways, and saved in a redundant manner, I could imagine that there is a setup in which there are a combinatorially large number of possible ways to fetch a set of blocks which reconstruct a given model, and if you prefetch a few red-herrings as well, it would be infeasible to determine which model you are loading based just on the commands the sever sent you on which blocks to load. Then, when the time comes, they send a very short command which tells you which blocks to use and how to reconstruct the model. Hmm... but now I'm thinking about it, I think you'd need a large overhead in both directions to make it difficult to just match the patterns of which blocks you used.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by jiggy2011 on Saturday December 03, 2011 @07:32AM (#3307591)
Most 3d models in games are are loaded whole rather than in chunks (this allows them to be smaller and rendered more efficiently), there may also be 3 or more seperate models with different levels of detail. Some of these models can be very detailed in recent games and preloading allot of them as red herrings would eat graphics memory and kill the performance.

Online games always walk a tightrope between performance and security. The currently popular model seems to be to optimise the game for performance but use a second program to verify that the client code has not been modified.

Of course you then have to make sure the anti-cheat is not modified itself. I have to say though that cheating is not a big apparent problem in most online games that I have played. Most cheating problems are in older games that have not been updated in some time.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by JoshTriplett on Saturday December 03, 2011 @05:13AM (#3307438)
This is a very old discussion, by the way: http://catb.org/~esr/writings/quake-cheats.html
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by pantaloons on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:50PM (#3306739)
You are correct although there are a myriad of reasons why this doesn't work in practice. Perhaps I should have said augmented overlays, task queuing (macros) and so on instead -- they better illustrate the point.
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by shocks on Friday December 02, 2011 @05:58PM (#3306132)
But open source would make cheating far more "assessable". It would be a trivial job to modify the opacity of walls for example - I imagine such a feat would be substantially harder without access to the source code (of course, still possible).

It's easier to trust a "cheating hack" if it comes as a source code patch or the source code is readily available. If I was so inclined to cheat, I certainly would not trust a strange patch/executable from some shadowy figure I knew nothing about.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by chc on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:17PM (#3306189)
That's like worrying that sharper knives will make stabbing people easier. It's true, but stabbing is already easy enough with the knives we have that the difficulty of the act isn't really stopping anyone. Similarly, games get hacked, open-source or not.
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by pantaloons on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:44PM (#3306278)
Ignoring the security through obscurity mess, the more salient point is that there are classes of problems that cannot be solved at present without a locked down client. If solving such a problem is the entire function of the device I don't know that I'm against this.

Technology will eventually solve such problems (thin clients or fully homomorphic encryption) but these have serious issues of their own.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by dchest on Friday December 02, 2011 @05:13PM (#3305942)
See this talk: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h_3i7ZX_Gvk "Copyright vs Community".

Text: http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/copyright-versus-community.htm...

Search for "I distinguish three broad categories of works".

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by shocks on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:01PM (#3306143)
Many thanks for this.
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by jerrya on Friday December 02, 2011 @05:47PM (#3306100)
Similarly are distributed computing projects like SETI at Home which (last I knew) were explicitly NOT open sourced because allowing others to see the code would explicitly undermine their trust in the computations done remotely.

I haven't seen RMS address that either; I think his views would be interesting.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by dchest on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:33PM (#3306238)
Can't such software be reverse engineered?

Also, the home page for BOINC (http://boinc.berkeley.edu/) says it's open source.

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by jerrya on Saturday December 03, 2011 @01:45AM (#3307143)
It's been sometime since I looked at it, but you can see http://forums.anandtech.com/showthread.php?p=7531773 that as of 2003, it was closed source

The FAQ states they decided to make the code proprietary "for security reasons and for science reasons as well".

Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by tikhonj on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:23PM (#3306793)
Isn't the natural solution to something like that just to do some redundant computation? I think that's how people deal with similar problems in services like Mechanical Turk. It would, at worst, make the computation three or four times less efficient but would limit both active meddling and errors. Also, relying on a closed source for security is a bad policy anyhow.
Re:RMS on evil developers, spying social networks, the legit... by seiji on Friday December 02, 2011 @06:27PM (#3306226)
Zealotry is not compatible with nuance.