Re:A surprising way to lose your files on Windows
by Wowfunhappy on Saturday October 01, 2022 @07:37PM
(#33051185)
The Files app is a huge improvement, but it doesn't integrate into other apps very well. For example, if I play an audio recording, playback happens within the files app, so I can't browse through other documents at the same time. I could import the audio file into e.g. VLC, but now I'm copying it into a new location.
Contrast this with traditional OS X. I can open a file in any app, but the file continues to live in Finder. In a way, you could say that the Mac puts files first in the way that iOS puts apps first. An app is just a tool, and could be used for anything: I write papers for school and documentation for work and poetry for pleasure. A file, on the other hand, has a distinct purpose.
Re:A surprising way to lose your files on Windows
by alistairSH on Saturday October 01, 2022 @09:12PM
(#33051755)
Totally agree on that point - the relationship between apps and files is really odd in iOS for anybody who grew up on PCs/Macs. I’ve mostly given up trying to manage files and just trust (Hope? Wish?) iOS to do the right thing. And it usually does, but I’m not creating content or doing work, just consuming.
All that said, I do agree with the general premise that files should be organized in reasonable places by default and users should be able to override that should they see the need.