Re:Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
by YeBanKo on Friday September 30, 2022 @11:59PM
(#33043755)
I have made through 2/3 of the article and could not figure out what problem the author is trying to solve or what he is trying to achieve. Seems like someone from a consulting firm, who does not write software, making a presentation about how to write software.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
by travisjungroth on Saturday October 01, 2022 @12:31AM
(#33043884)
It’s common for people to use a term they think is straightforward (dependence) but it’s not. They make arguments and decisions that hinge on this term. This article is showing how “dependence” is three major things that can each be broken down even more.
This teasing apart can be really useful. Sometimes you end up debating “should A depend on B”, but then it’s “does A depend on B” and all the way to “this is what dependency means / means to me”. That last step is a terrible way out of the argument. A better thing is something like “we’ll call your dependency definition type 1 and mine type 2” and you realize there’s more common ground than you had before, the disagreement quite narrow. Maybe the disagreement even becomes a matter of fact and you can go find out! I find having a concept already broken down by someone else to help this process.
Re:Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
by YeBanKo on Saturday October 01, 2022 @03:40AM
(#33044791)
The meaning of dependence is context specific. Arguing about what it means in the in abstract does not make sense. There can be a build dependence, a deployment dependence, etc
Re:Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
by capitalsigma on Saturday October 01, 2022 @12:05AM
(#33043776)
If a minor version number is bumped in the woods and no one is around to hear it, does it break your build?
Re:Puzzles to convince you you don't understand dependence
by ReptileMan on Saturday October 01, 2022 @05:17AM
(#33045205)
Ask the people that had to foldr strings because they were deprived of left-pad.