News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by Archio on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:05AM (#3303973)
What is it about European countries that make them so reasonable and open to progress? This is great news, because for once there's actually a law on pirating that's based on research, unlike US laws centered around "job creators" losing money.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by rickmb on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:43AM (#3304087)
As far as copyright is concerned, it has nothing to do with "reasonable and open to progress". The main differences are:

* The powerful copyright-industry mostly resides in the US. European countries that have somewhat of a copyright industry of their own (France, UK) are considerable less "reasonable".

* Success in European elections is way less dependent on corporate financing. Lobbying is way less effective if the politicians you target don't need your money. It's not less corrupt, but more about influence and favors, and the US copyright lobby has relatively little to offer in that respect.

In other words: the copyright mafia has less politicians in their pockets, and therefor less influence on public policy.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by larrik on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:21AM (#3304018)
Because in Europe you have lots of very different countries that your mind cherry-picks the best parts out of when you hear these stories. Actually living in Europe requires that you pick one country, and involves compromising on something. (Germany doesn't really have freedom of speech. UK has big brother issues and crazy libel laws. France hates the internet. Sweden wants everyone to think they hate men. Etc.)

Of course, I don't hear a lot of negatives about Switzerland. Except from the IRS, of course :)

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:59AM (#3304159)
Lately Switzerland seems to have a small right-wing problem, first banning the construction of minarets and then voting to deport criminal foreigners. A few of my Swiss friends found this quite embarrassing and attributed it to the vagaries of direct democratic processes and voter turnout.

But as you say, each place has its crazy idiosyncrasies, and in the grand total, Switzerland scores pretty highly in the list of countries to live in. Unless you hate mountains and/or chocolate, of course. (Or they won't let you in, which might be an issue)

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by CaptainZapp on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:10AM (#3304202)
That's the price you pay for direct democracy. Sometimes really, really bad laws get accepted by the population in a referendum.

Actually the Swiss Popular Party (SVP, the right wing party) didn't do too well in the most recent elections. While they hoped to achieve > 30% of the popular vote, they're hovering around ~26%. A lot of their candidates for the smaller house of parliament (Ständerat, would be the Senate in the US) got actually hammered.

So from a perspective of reason things actually seem to be looking brighter.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by danssig on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:03AM (#3304366)
Why would it be a problem to deport criminal foreigners? And if you think Switzerland is hard to get into, try to get into Denmark.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:22AM (#3304444)
Do you still have to properly pronounce "rødgrød med fløde"?

The problem isn't deportation per se (which lots of states have), but the specific bill. First of all, it made it automatic deportation, is likely to conflict with international and EU law and references a few crimes by names that aren't the proper legal terms. IANAL and this is from memory, but it went a bit over the top for most people not on the far right. And the campaign for the referendum was quite on the fear-mongering side, if not a outright racist.

I think right now it's still in a state of flux. It passed, but the legal bodies now have to properly determine for which crimes it really applies. Might take a few years yet.

People aren't used to GOP-candidate-level craziness from the Swiss… (It barely passed, and was generally rejected by the French-speaking part of Switzerland. I blame the German grammar, it seems to create some kind of envy against every nationality who don't have to learn that many cases, genders etc.)

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by danssig on Monday December 05, 2011 @04:09AM (#3313834)
>Do you still have to properly pronounce "rødgrød med fløde"?

I've never been to Denmark myself, I just have several friends from there who complained about how hard it was to get in. Apparently even marrying a Dane isn't enough to stay there if you're not from the EU.

>And the campaign for the referendum was quite on the fear-mongering side, if not a outright racist.

Oh for sure. The SVP posters have been really awful for a while but I think it's starting to backfire with the public, so hopefully that will stop.

>People aren't used to GOP-candidate-level craziness from the Swiss…

That's a bit of an exaggeration. The SVP gets pretty dirty from time to time but the GOP is a caricature of a right-wing fringe group.

>I blame the German grammar, it seems to create some kind of envy against every nationality who don't have to learn that many cases, genders etc.

Keep in mind that Switzerland has the highest "auslander" percentage of any western European country. That's going to create a big of backlash.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by tedunangst on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:22AM (#3304443)
Because what usually happens (or what makes people angry anyway) is that someone who's been living in the country for ten years gets deported because of a shoplifting offense also committed ten years ago. Violates the principle of no ex post facto laws.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by danssig on Monday December 05, 2011 @04:10AM (#3313836)
Any citations on that? I've heard people claim that but in actual practice I believe it's only used against career criminals. The issue I've heard complained about is that if there is a career criminal dad, he can cause the whole family to end up getting deported (though I'm not sure that one is true either).
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by rmc on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:13AM (#3304208)
I don't hear a lot of negatives about Switzerland

It's probably one of the most expensive countries in the world to visit.

They probably hide a lot of the money of corrupt governments and world leaders.

Also this might be good or bad, but it's all very neat and tidy. All the roads in rural areas are all very good and all the grass is clipped. Makes the place feel totally tamed. (Though good roads is a plus, just makes for some not-as-interesting motorbike touring)

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by getsat on Saturday December 03, 2011 @04:26AM (#3307365)
> It's probably one of the most expensive countries

This is said by everyone about every country ever. Is this fact, or does my previous sentence cover it?

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by o1iver on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:55AM (#3304138)

    Germany doesn't really have freedom of speech
What do you mean? (I am German)
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:03AM (#3304173)
The whole "Volksverhetzung" thingamajig, i.e. you're not allowed to deny the Holocaust, display swastikas etc. The US has its hate crime laws, but these usually don't restrict free speech in the same way.

A few European countries share these specific restrictions by the way (or at least some of them). Including Switzerland.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by waqf on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:17AM (#3304222)
And in the U.S. you aren't allowed to advocate the violent overthrow of the government, to shout fire in a crowded theater, to distribute child porn or to conspire to blow up airliners.

The only difference is that U.S. culture teaches you to believe that those exceptions "aren't covered by free speech", i.e. they don't count because we said so ... just as o1iver thinks about Holocaust-denying.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by tedunangst on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:13PM (#3304711)
I'll go at this another way. AFAIK, you aren't allowed to do any of those things in Germany either. So it's not really an issue of these things are free speech in one country, and other different things are free speech in another country. It's kind of irrelevant what the US does, Germany has all the same "reasonable" exceptions, but then some more on top.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by tedunangst on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:26AM (#3304456)
Except your examples aren't really even examples of speech, free or otherwise. Walking around with a swastika on your arm is quite different than actively holocausting people.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by waqf on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:56AM (#3304604)
For convenience of argument I will retract the child porn example, but "conspiring", "shouting" and "advocating" are much closer to a common-sense understanding of the word "speech" than is "walking around with [any particular symbol] on your arm".

Unless you totally missed the words "conspire" and "advocate" in my post, I'm not at all sure what you're trying to say.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:17PM (#3304727)
Doesn't the crime of conspiracy at least require one overt act?
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by waqf on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:43PM (#3304854)
Good call, but in the U.S., according to Wikipedia: "The Shabani case illustrates that it is a matter of legislative prerogative whether to require an overt step, or not to require an overt step in any conspiracy statute."

So conspiracy without an overt act is not constitutionally protected.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by tedunangst on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:07PM (#3304663)
After you conspire to blow up an airliner, people die. After denying the Holocaust, nobody dies.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by waqf on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:36PM (#3304819)
Conspiracy does not mean that you carried out the act, or even that you tried to.

Besides, people die after someone shouts fire in a crowded theater, but it's still speech.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:57PM (#3304914)
To take this a bit ad absurdum, so is ordering someone to kill someone else (or a few hundred). I think we shouldn't confuse the dictionary with a legal text.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by waqf on Friday December 02, 2011 @01:06PM (#3304957)
Good example (I think it's most similar to "conspiracy", though it might depend on what kind of implicit threat is backing up the "order").

btw, I'm not necessarily advocating free speech at all costs. If I'm going after anyone in this thread, it's the U.S. for hypocritically advertising "WE H4Ve phR33 5P34CH!!! unlike u european 1o5erz" and not being upfront about how delicate the line is.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by lutorm on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:28PM (#3304779)
Well, in the U.S., spending money is seen as speech, leading to many absurdities. So spending money in support of various abhorrent things is apparently the same as just talking about it. Except if it could be construed that you are supporting terrorism, of course, since then all constitutional protections are off.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by getsat on Saturday December 03, 2011 @04:27AM (#3307366)
> in the U.S. you aren't allowed to advocate the violent overthrow of the government

Yes, you can.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:10AM (#3304394)
How much influence did the Americans, British and French (as occupying powers) have on those laws in what was originally Western Germany?
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:24AM (#3304448)
Yes, it originally was part of Allied regulations in the occupied territories and was basically included as is in the new German constitution.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @11:41AM (#3304536)
Seems rather unfair then for people (especially Britains, Americans and French) to criticise Germany for these laws when they were actually imposed on the country!
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by mhd on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:15PM (#3304721)
This is a pretty complicated subject. Just because they were in existence before doesn't exactly rule out that they weren't wanted in Germany. Or even needed. The general trend was to both forget and prevent. So banning certain symbols, books, movies from the public eye was generally considered to be what's best. I know, it's not that easy, which caused a lot of problems later on and still is pretty hard to deal with.

And I don't get that much criticism about the laws. Yes, Americans generally look quite astonished on any country perceived to have fewer freedoms (and "socialist Europe" certainly applies for that), but the Brits and French usually don't mock us for that. They tend to be quite more panicked whenever some neo-nazis appear, and if they were using the original symbols this might get worse. (Never mind that France has laws against holocaust deniers, too.)

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by zura on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:33AM (#3304268)
I wish we had the same restrictions regarding communist symbolism here in East Europe.
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by adimitrov on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:53AM (#3304131)
> Of course, I don't hear a lot of negatives about Switzerland. Except from the IRS, of course :)

That's your opinion because you're not an "Ausländer" (foreigner) living in Switzerland. See:

* http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/politics/Council_of_Europe_attac...

* http://www.swissinfo.ch/eng/Specials/Parliamentary_elections...

* http://www.humanrights.ch/en/Switzerland/Human-Rights-in-Int...

I was thinking of moving to Switzerland, but in the end I had the feeling that there's a significant portion of the population who would like to keep it "Swiss." Also, immigration laws are rather harsh.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by algorias on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:31AM (#3304263)
>there's a significant portion of the population who would like to keep it "Swiss."

s/significant/vocal and you're closer to the mark. The right wing party here routinely attempts to shift blame of every conceivable problem to the fact that there are lots of foreigners living here. It's not that there aren't real issues (e.g. abuse of asylum rights), but they tend to be blown vastly out of proportion.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by arethuza on Friday December 02, 2011 @10:04AM (#3304178)
"UK has big brother issues and crazy libel laws"

Nitpick: England has crazy libel laws.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by roel_v on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:44PM (#3304859)
"Of course, I don't hear a lot of negatives about Switzerland."

Apart from being a country that gets much of its wealth from hiding the blood money of dictators and criminals? Right.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by JoshTriplett on Saturday December 03, 2011 @09:07AM (#3307761)
> Of course, I don't hear a lot of negatives about Switzerland.

Take a look at the tax rates.

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by kzrdude on Friday December 02, 2011 @02:20PM (#3305275)
"Sweden wants everyone to think they hate men."

What does this mean?

Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by VMG on Friday December 02, 2011 @09:46AM (#3304104)
And let's not forget the economy..
Re:Swiss Government: Downloading Movies and Music Will Stay ... by Tycho on Friday December 02, 2011 @12:04PM (#3304647)
Because they import most of their entertainment form America, maybe?