News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by mrguyorama on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @03:09PM (#33011928)
You're missing the concept of "credible accusations". The court of public opinion does not care about "beyond a reasonable doubt" because if we actually limited anything to that nobody would be punished for anything.

If you want "convicted" to be the bar before the public treats someone poorly, you're going to have a bad time, because it's terribly difficult to actually convict someone of rape because there's almost never any actual evidence, by the very nature of the crime. Nevermind the fact that lots of people either cannot admit to themselves or don't remember or don't realize they were raped. Very few people who actually commit rape (whether they realize it or not) end up convicted. It's not a rigorous stat, because again, the reality of the situation is only truly known by the two involved, so it often comes down to who you trust.

Consider why you trust supreme court justices to not have raped people.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by _-david-_ on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @03:48PM (#33012351)
>You're missing the concept of "credible accusations".

I don't consider them to be credible so I am not missing anything.

>The court of public opinion does not care about "beyond a reasonable doubt" because if we actually limited anything to that nobody would be punished for anything.

Sure, but people don't need to go calling people rapists just because they got accused.

>If you want "convicted" to be the bar before the public treats someone poorly, you're going to have a bad time, because it's terribly difficult to actually convict someone of rape because there's almost never any actual evidence, by the very nature of the crime

I just want some level of evidence more than just having an accusation that something happened years ago. That just isn't enough for me to treat someone poorly. Maybe a couple accusations or weird behavior or the alleged suspect getting caught in lies about this issue or something.

Eye witness testimony is very frequently inaccurate especially when the incident occurred decades before. And that is with the assumption they aren't making it up. An accusation especially against political people is just not trustworthy in my view to begin with.

People lie for politics all the time. People slander/libel for politics all the time. Why should I trust an accusation without any corroborating evidence or additional accusations or anything of the sort?

>Nevermind the fact that lots of people either cannot admit to themselves or don't remember or don't realize they were raped.

That presumably wouldn't make a difference in this situation. If they won't admit it or don't remember then they won't be accusing justices of doing it.

>Very few people who actually commit rape (whether they realize it or not) end up convicted. It's not a rigorous stat, because again, the reality of the situation is only truly known by the two involved, so it often comes down to who you trust

I understand. I should have been more clear that I don't strictly need a guilty verdict. I want something more than a single accusation especially against political people.

>Consider why you trust supreme court justices to not have raped people.

I never said I don't think they raped anybody. They very well may have. I think people who are in positions of power probably on average have lower morals and are more likely to be a rapist. I just don't like going around calling people rapists without any real evidence other than just an accusation that came up years / decades after it allegedly occurred.

I think we are getting to a point where people throw around allegations and various -ists and phobias too often. Every day somebody is called a racist or homophobe or is accused of being a traitor to the country. I think we need to cool it with decisiveness and stop with this type of language unless there is a reason to use in a specific case.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by mrguyorama on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @04:09PM (#33012624)
>I don't consider them to be credible so I am not missing anything.

Why?

>Maybe a couple accusations or weird behavior or the alleged suspect getting caught in lies about this issue or something

Did you not watch the confirmation hearings?

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by _-david-_ on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @06:39PM (#33014139)
I am assuming you are talking about Kavanaugh?

>Why?

Because it looked like a political hit.

- She couldn't remember which party it happened at

- She couldn't remember what year it even happened

- She told nobody until 2012 and even then she didn't mention Kavanaugh

- Multiple people she described as her friends denied they knew anything of this event including one who was allegedly at the party

- She lied to the Washington Post when she said she was frustrated that in 2016 she heard that Trump would potentially nominate Kavanaugh. She couldn't have been frustrated in 2016 since Kavanaugh didn't have his name put out until 2017.

- Her parents and siblings would not sign a document in support of her statement. Her family in law did though.

I understand you may have issues after a traumatic event, which can cause you to forget or misremember, but none of this is adding up to me.

Just to be clear, I am not denying she was assaulted or even that Kavanaugh may have been the assailant. I just don't think the testimony was credible and she didn't provide any evidence or have anybody who knew her back then back her up.

>Did you not watch the confirmation hearings?

Yes. Which thing do you think Kavanaugh did of my list? There was 1 person making an accusation, there was some stupid teenage stuff with some drinking, he didn't lie (to our knowledge) about this rape case.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by olliej on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @04:08PM (#33012611)
> I don't consider them to be credible so I am not missing anything.

Of course you don't, it's just the word of a woman, and as noted elsewhere you're clearly sexist.

The FBI had more than 4500 tips, a multiple corroborating witnesses. They chose not to go anywhere due to it being the 80s and all rapes being the woman's fault.

But I'm going to say: it's a very clearly credible claim if there were supporting witness statements even in the 80s.

> I think we are getting to a point where people throw around allegations and various -ists and phobias too often. Every day somebody is called a racist or homophobe or is accused of being a traitor to the country. I think we need to cool it with decisiveness and stop with this type of language unless there is a reason to use in a specific case.

If a someone's position is that trans and gay people should be de facto treated as criminals or at the very least denied equal protection under law they're clearly transphobic and/or homophobic. If you vote in support of those policies you are stating very clearly that you don't consider LGBT people to be, you know, people. Because the idea that treating them equally is just a "political position" is an explicit statement that they you do not consider them to be people.

If someone supports groups that have explicitly stated white supremacist, antisemitic, sexist, homophobic and/or transphobic "talking points", then they are antisemitic, sexist, homophobic and/or transphobic.

If someone is avoiding overt statements by using dog whistles ("urban youth", "globalist", "anti-family", etc) they are racist, antisemitic, etc.

The only people driving divisiveness are conservatives. They're very clearly, and on the record, and proud of incessant statements attacking the right of large swathes of people just to exist, let alone have any kind of equal rights. They're aggressively pushing laws with the explicit intent of legalizing discrimination.

A super common refrain of bigots is that if people would just be quiet and accept the bigotry, then "eventually" they'll get the equality they want. This has repeatedly been shown to be complete BS - the _only_ thing that causes change is making noise. While the bigots on the Supreme Court have been aggressively dismantling the civil rights act, that only passed after huge protests lasting years, in which many many protestors were beaten (often by police in the white power states), and quite a few were murdered. Rosa Parks sitting in the "white only" section of a bus and refusing to leave was a "crime" according to the white supremacist states. Similarly Mildred&Richard Loving.

Demanding acquiescence is purely a tool of the people enforcing the bigotry.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by _-david-_ on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @06:42PM (#33014165)
She could be a guy and I still would not believe her. Sorry to tell you, but I don't automatically believe somebody because of their sex. That would actually be sexist.

You are deliberately misconstruing what I am saying and are wasting my time. I'm not going to respond to any other part of your post. If you start off calling somebody a sexist then I'm sorry but you are not arguing in good faith.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by ghgilte on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @06:42PM (#33014166)
> or at the very least denied equal protection under law they're clearly transphobic

They already have equal protection. What's being requested in law and other policy are additional privileges.

Re:A single Texas ruling could change the web forever by olliej on Thursday September 29, 2022 @03:25AM (#33017496)
Really? What "privileges" exactly are they asking for? Because I can point to quite a few laws in quite a few conservative states that make being trans something you can be fired for, that make acknowledging the existence of LGBT people something that can get teachers fired, that make it legal to refuse to serve LGBT people.

So: List the privileges that LGBT people are requesting, that are not available to straight or cisgendered people. This should be very easy given your statement.