News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by TheRealPomax on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @08:56PM (#33003095)
Congrats: you are an outlier. That's pretty cool, and it means you can read a lot of code quite easily, which I'm sure lets you be more productive than most, but you are not like most other people.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by kjeetgill on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:19PM (#33003231)
I think this is one of those silent majority situations.

Almost all programmers can read a C-like language because well, that covers like 95% of languages by use. You have C/C++/Java/Go/JS/Kotlin/Rust/zig/C# etc.

BUT second to that in sheer use is probably Python. Almost everyone (that I know) has touched it atleast a bit whether its dev scripts, tooling, scientific work (bio, cv, etc.), robotics, mech engineers, ml/ai space etc.

Why would anyone nitpick to death tools that have so much ubiquity? Well they'd have to have a narrow focus to even consider it. The majority of algebra users never second guess +, *, ^, (), etc.

I'd say lisp is probably the hardest to get used to combine with the least frequent to cross your path. And then there's a long tail of bash/ruby styles, tcl, ocaml, etc etc.

Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by TheRealPomax on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:23PM (#33003252)
I think this is a dangerous assumptions to make: the last time I looked at C was 30 years ago, you show me real C code with pointers and references and namespaces and I couldn't tell you wtf was going on if my life depended on it.

With a few weeks of study to "re"learn C and/or C++? Sure, they're just programming languages. But right off the bat? No idea what the hell is going on in real, production C code.

Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by Entinel on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:35PM (#33003321)
This is my point though. People just complain about whatever syntax they aren't used to using but none of them are inherently more difficult to read.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by TheRealPomax on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:54PM (#33003428)
None of them are inherently more difficult to _learn_ but they sure as hell are more difficult to read when everything's peppered with :: and * and &.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by Entinel on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @10:22PM (#33003571)
That's a matter of opinion and one I disagree with.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by thrown_22 on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @10:55PM (#33003782)
The problem of working C code isn't the syntax, it's the semantics.

Casting pointers isn't difficult to read because dereference and multiplication share *, it's difficult to understand because it's not something you do outside of C.

Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by skywhopper on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @08:28AM (#33007115)
Maybe you don’t.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by Peritract on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @04:33AM (#33005633)
In my experience, people who struggle with different syntax conventions are the outliers; if you can handle the idea of brackets generally (as we all do regularly), then you can deal with one set of conventions.

Similarly, if you can grasp the concept of a paragraph, or of bullet points, or a bunch of other things in normal text that convey meaning through whitespace, then you can deal with another.

It's only code that (some) people complain about this with. In every other context, we all know that we can work with syntax based either on brackets or spacing. Just in normal communication, all humans deal with a dizzying array of complex conventions without even thinking about it.

The reluctance to use whitespace-sensitive languages (or the other way around) is learned helplessness, rather than a widespread inadequacy.

Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by sweezyjeezy on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:05PM (#33003158)
Are you sure this an outlier opinion amongst regular python users?
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by p1necone on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:08PM (#33003168)
Well no, I imagine that that group would somewhat self select for developers who are okay with reading whitespace based syntax. Someone who finds it hard to read is probably not going to become a regular user of the language unless they have to.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by sweezyjeezy on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:20PM (#33003235)
Python is lingua franca in data science / ML, i.e. you pretty much do have to to work in the field. In my experience the people who complain about this aspect of python are those just starting out.

Dependency management would be an example of a real Python issue, not a "everyone gets used to it" one IMO.

Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by OrderlyTiamat on Wednesday September 28, 2022 @04:12AM (#33005459)
I use python extensively, and whitespace very much is an actual issue. Not a big one, but it is annoying every once in a while e.g. when copying code. Especially as autoindenting is very much hampered in that case, because the editor can't tell what the indent is supposed to be if multiple options are valid python. Dealing with braces instead is much easier. Not a deal-breaker or major issue, but an annoyance nonetheless.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by TheRealPomax on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:25PM (#33003265)
Why would a python programmer have any understanding of code that's full of pointers and memory addresses? You show someone who started on Python, and still uses it today, real product C code and their eyes glaze over real fast.
Re:Guido was right, there should be no lambda in Python (2018) by sweezyjeezy on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:29PM (#33003285)
I think you replied to the wrong person.