News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Please change the name of this project by rektide on Monday September 26, 2022 @11:11PM (#32991190)
If we asked 100 engineers who'd never heard the term before what a "buildpack" might be, I 25%+ would have the general idea. If we asked people with at least moderate familiarity with containers what it might be, we could be probably get to 50%.

The specifics here are unimportant & nonspecial. They might not jave been invented. But there have been plenty of container appkit ideas for a while & this specific incarnation offers little in specific.

This trademark is over a very broad obvious term, & as such it insults the idea of trademarks. Trademarks should have to have se novelty. I shouldnt be able to go trademark "computer system" or "software application". This isnt quite that broad but kt's hardly far off. The specific meaning is irrelevant because the term already has a broaderly useful generic sense: to ignore the general obvious sense is to disrespect common sense.

Re:Please change the name of this project by jacques_chester on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @09:23AM (#32994916)
I believe you are conflating patents and trademarks. Patents require novelty to be accepted. Trademarks do not.

As it happens, there are many registered trademarks and variants of trademarks for "computer system": https://trademarks.justia.com/search?q=computer+system

Re:Please change the name of this project by rektide on Tuesday September 27, 2022 @11:52AM (#32996987)
Im not conflating. I think the law is debasing itself by failing to set a reasonable minimum bar for what can be trademarked. This feels like a case where the law should recognize the self obviousness of two terms smashed together.